More Minions? Toon Studios Talk Sequel Strategies

Toon Be Continued: 'Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs 2,' 'Despicable Me 2' (above), 'Monsters University' and 'Smurfs 2' extend hit franchises

Of the 10 pics to have earned more than $500 million at the 2013 box office, three are animated features. Considering what big business toons represent today, it’s no surprise that the studios responsible have shifted into the sequels business. But revisiting popular animated characters — and keeping them fresh — can be a tricky balancing act.

“Audiences want the familiarity of the same characters, but at the same time, they don’t want just a repeat of the first film,” acknowledges Dan Scanlon, director of Pixar’s “Monsters University.” “And it’s really tough as those characters were specifically designed to tell one story, which has now been told. So you have to design a whole new story and journey, and also make sure that there’s a new emotional change. It can’t be the same as the first movie, and sequels often fall into that trap.”

To avoid that, the “Monsters” team decided to take the prequel route instead. “They’re just 18-year-olds now, and we’re all very different when we’re younger,” he says. The team also took risks. “Mike is less the easy comic relief, and more the sincere heart of the film,” says Scanlon. “So he’s more of a naive and idealistic kid.” Similarly, the lovable, sweet Sulley of the first film is now a cocky know-it-all. It helped that actor John Goodman, who voices Sulley, “really related to that teenager attitude,” Scanlon explains. “He says he was that kid at that age, and it’s a characteristic we can all recognize.”

For Kris Pearn and Cody Cameron, boosted from the story department to directors of “Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs 2,” the big challenge was “not to repeat ourselves in both the types of jokes and the character stories,” Pearn says. Making things slightly easier, however, the team didn’t have to sell the concept this time out. “The studio had a lot of reservations about ‘Cloudy 1,’ as it was so ‘Muppetty’ and cartoony with this whole crazy world,” he recalls. “We spent one year out of the four-year process just trying to convince them it would work.”

The team also decided to stray from the original’s mock disaster-movie format. “This time we went for the monster movie, which gave us all this new energy, and took the sentient food idea — which made the least sense in the first film — and ran with it,” explains Pearn. The result? A quasi-“Jurassic Park” filled with “foodimals.” “We also took inventor Flint Lockwood, who emotionally seemed about 14 at the end of ‘Cloudy 1,’ and sent him into high school,” Pearn adds. “That gave us a whole set of new experiences and stories for him.”

While the creative force behind the “Ice Age” films saw that franchise’s road trip-style sequel as “essentially a straight line” in terms of storytelling, he faced “the exact opposite experience” in conceiving “Despicable Me 2”: “It was almost as if the story hadn’t finished being told,” says producer Chris Meledandri, who once again sees the villainous antihero Gru as the center of the movie. “The story became Gru’s emotional quest to continue to heal and complete himself, whereas in the first movie he was dealing with the experience of love for the first time with these three little daughters. The question of romantic love was just staring us right in the face, and we knew that he had been wounded by bad parenting and was terrified of romantic love. From that point forward, the story actually started to tell itself and everything else formed around that.”

Adds Meledandri: “I think the big difference here is that it was an organic process of storytelling rooted in character. The discipline that everyone brought to the second one was the knowledge that there were core elements of the story that everybody loved (think Minions — and more Minions). But there was a tremendous amount of discipline to make sure that we were continually pushing into new terrain and that meant new situations, new characters, new vulnerabilities for those characters, new comedic scenes.”

For “The Smurfs 2,” returning director Raja Gosnell largely stuck to the same formula as the original film: a kid-friendly mix of human slapstick and CG Smurfs. But this time around, the filmmakers moved the action to Paris, and added some fresh blood to the mix. Christina Ricci, Brendan Gleeson and J.B. Smoove joined regular cast members Neil Patrick Harris, Katy Perry and Hank Azaria, while the exotic backdrop opened the door for Britney Spears to contribute her original Smurf song “Ooh La La.” The resulting global box office (international tellingly far outstripped domestic) has already powered up a third installment, due to be released in summer 2015.

“In a sequel, you have to pick up the original story, create a new problem, and take your characters on a new journey,” Pearn says. He admits that they struggled with some elements, including juggling many new characters, “right till the end.”

For Pixar’s Scanlon, keeping sequels fresh means “nothing’s sacred.” He says, “That’s something we do a lot. We’ll break the characters if it means telling the right story.”

Scanlon cites Mike’s character as the key to the “Monsters” prequel: “It’s a story you don’t see very often, especially in family films, about a character who works very hard but still doesn’t attain his dream. That’s something most people can relate to. That tension was the inspiration for the whole prequel idea.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Film Republic Sells Svetla Tsotsorkova's 'Sister'

    Film Republic Sells Svetla Tsotsorkova's 'Sister' to China, France (EXCLUSIVE)

    Svetla Tsotsorkova’s second feature film “Sister,” which played at the San Sebastian and London film festivals, has been picked up by Hualu in China and Tamasa in France. World sales are handled by Xavier Henry-Rashid’s Film Republic. The film, set in a small town in present-day Bulgaria, centers on a mother and her two daughters, [...]

  • Santa Barbara

    Morelia Film Festival Readies 5th Impulso Pix-in-Post Sidebar

    Morelia Film Festival’s (FICM) Impulso sidebar for pix in progress will run Sunday through Tuesday this coming week, having become one of the territories most important launchpads for Latin American feature films in post-production. Many of the participating films in recent editions have gone on to find festival success the world around. Last year, Hari [...]

  • SUPER FAMILY -- In Disney Pixar’s

    Pixar's Ralph Eggleston to Receive 2019 View Conference's Visionary Award

    The 2019 View Conference will present its Visionary Award to Pixar’s Ralph Eggleston. Eggleston, who won an Oscar in 2002 for his animated short “For the Birds,” has worked on such Pixar hits as “Toy Story,” “Finding Nemo,” “WALL-E,” and “Inside Out.” “I’ve long been a fan of the View Conference. It’s a great gathering [...]

  • Cuervo Mexico

    Oscar-Nominated Marina de Tavira to Receive Jose Cuervo Career Recognition Award

    Mexican Oscar-nominated actress Marina de Tavira (“Roma”) is receiving the Premio Cuervo Tradicional, a career recognition award from Morelia Int’l Film Festival (FICM) sponsor Jose Cuervo Tradicional. The prize ceremony will take place on Saturday, Oct. 19. The award has been given out for more than 12 years at FICM to a Mexican actor or actress who [...]

  • Abominable Animated Movie

    Italy's View Conference Draws Key Players in Film, TV, Games and More to Exchange Ideas

    Against the picturesque backdrop of the Alps, the View Conference will celebrate its 20th year in Turin, Italy, with its fullest program ever, featuring top creatives from around the world in film, television and games and more who will give keynote talks and present masterclasses at the weeklong event, Oct. 21-25. This edition boasts director [...]

  • Serendipity Prune Nourry

    Film Review: 'Serendipity'

    “If I could have a secret superpower, it would be to heal with my hands,” says French artist Prune Nourry in her autobiographical documentary “Serendipity.” It’s an understandable enough admission, given that she was diagnosed with breast cancer aged 31, fighting a battle against it that included undergoing a mastectomy, harvesting her eggs in advance [...]

  • Daughter-of-Rage

    Laura Baumeister Brings San Sebastian Winning Project ‘Daughter of Rage’ to Morelia

    Already backed by a four-way production partnership spanning Nicaragua, Mexico, the Netherlands and Germany, Laura Baumeister’s debut feature project “Daughter of Rage” swept three of the four prizes on offer at San Sebastian’s 8th Europe-Latin America Co-production Forum this year. Now the project heads to Morelia, where Baumeister has been with short films in the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content