×

Indian Cinema Straddles Centuries, Pushes for Change

As filmmakers strive to push the envelope, censors pop up from everywhere

The winds of change are blowing across Indian cinema, particularly in the contentious ratings process. Films need clearance from the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) before they can be exhibited in Indian theaters. Lately, however, state governments, political parties, pressure groups and even individuals filing public-interest suits can stall or scupper a film.

This year alone, Kamal Hassan’s Tamil and Hindi “Vishwaroopam” and Mandeep Benipal’s Punjabi “Sadda haq,” both cleared by the CBFC, were waylaid by state orgs.

“Vishwaroopam,” a spy thriller set in the U.S. and Afghanistan, was due for a Jan. 25 release but ran afoul of Muslim groups in Tamil Nadu state protesting against the portrayal of Islam in the film, leading the state to ban it. Hassan described the ban as “cultural terrorism.” The film was released in other parts of India and globally on Jan. 25 but released in Tamil Nadu on Feb. 7 after Hassan agreed to mute some dialogue that was seen as objectionable. He didn’t have a choice — the film cost $17.5 million, part of which Hassan raised by mortgaging his home.

Benipal wasn’t so lucky with “Sadda haq,” which looks at the 1980s separatist movement in Punjab from the militants’ p.o.v. Hours before its April 5 release, the film was banned by the states of Punjab and Haryana and the national capital region Delhi, on the grounds that it might cause communal tensions. India’s Supreme Court rejected an appeal from the film’s actor, producer and writer Kuljinder Singh Sidhu. The film was released in the U.K. and North America and finally last week in all of India.

Popular on Variety

State governments use the Indian Constitution’s “reasonable restriction” and another provision under state laws in order to ban films, thus creating what India’s Minister for Information and Broadcasting Minister Manish Tewari describes as “constitutional tension.”

CBFC chair Leela Samson says her org “is independent and not a political body representing any party. It should be allowed to do its job. State governments are responsible for law and order. They cannot predict a future problem based on a presumption and stop a film’s release. I think politics does impinge upon the freedom of art and is wrong.”

Still, as the country celebrates the centenary of its cinema, there are signs that India is getting more liberal. Kissing, long verboten in Indian films, hardly raises eyebrows. The CBFC also frequently clears films that employ profanity and violence, like “Gangs of Wasseypur” that played at Cannes 2012. And 2013 also sees the release of helmer Rupesh Paul’s “Kamasutra 3D,” the trailers of which show Sherlyn Chopra in the nude.

Paul says, “We haven’t done anything which crosses the guidelines of the Censor Board in the movie but will never approve any imposed amendments. I am ready to go to any extent to fight for justice.” Nevertheless, he’s preparing two cuts, an uncensored version in English for international audiences and a Hindi version where the “content has been altered to cater to the demands of Indian sensibility.”

Tewari sums up the complexity of Indian change: “You have to find a golden mean where you allow a certain amount of creativity but at the same time doesn’t offend social mores, because let’s not forget, that a part of Indiastill lives in the 19th century while another part lives in the 22nd century.

HIGHLIGHTS

More Film

  • Pablo-Guisa-and-Gabriela-Sandoval

    Morbido, Sanfic Share Specifics of New Joint Horror Initiative (EXCLUSIVE)

    Pablo Guisa, founder-CEO of the Morbido Group, Mexico’s largest horror conglomerate, and Gabriela Sandoval, director of Chile’s Santiago Intl. Film Festival (Sanfic), met in Berlin to finalize details for the inaugural Factoría Mórbido-Sanfic, a joint initiative intended to strengthen the genre film industry in Chile and across Latin America. Mórbido already has collaborations with Cinepolis [...]

  • Berlinale 2020: Variety, Medienboard Fete '10

    Variety Presents 'Ten Europeans to Watch' at Medienboard Party in Berlin

    Variety’s “10 Europeans to Watch” were feted Saturday night at a party held by Medienboard Berlin-Brandenburg at Berlin’s Ritz-Carlton Hotel. Co-hosting the evening were Kirsten Niehuus and Helge Jürgens, managing directors of Medienboard, the regional film, TV and digital-media funding body. Pictured above are U.K. filmmaker and rapper Andrew Onwubolu, known by his alias Rapman [...]

  • 'Funny Face' Review: An Anti-Capitalist Brooklyn

    'Funny Face': Film Review

    In a rare moment of light, everyday pleasure in the otherwise perma-brooding “Funny Face,” two young Brooklyn lovers build sandwiches from international deli ingredients, accompanied by Serbian butter and sour watermelon pickle, and eat their creations with relish on a bench overlooking the shore. Whether intended or not as a reference to an almost century-old [...]

  • Sonic (Ben Schwartz) in SONIC THE

    Box Office: 'Sonic' Narrowly Beats Harrison Ford's 'Call of the Wild'

    After a close box office battle, Paramount’s “Sonic the Hedgehog” pulled ahead of Disney and 20th Century’s “The Call of the Wild” on North American charts. The two movies had been in a surprising tug-of-war for first place. Heading into the weekend, “Sonic” was expected to easily dominate again but Harrison Ford’s “Call of the [...]

  • Ventana Sur

    Ventana Sur Sets 2020 Dates, a New Venue

    BERLIN —   Ventana Sur, the biggest film-TV industry event in Latin America – and bulwarked by a hugely popular Cannes Film Week hosted by Thierry Fremaux – has set dates for its 12th edition, and announced a new venue in Buenos Aires. Running Monday Nov. 30 to Friday Dec. 4, this year’s 12th Ventana [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content