YouTube Paid Subscription Channels May Be One Plan Too Many

Video giant hopes viewers will pay to access niche content

It was a confluence of events Eric Schmidt must have loved.

Surely the Google executive chairman noticed two announcements in early May that occurred just days after he audaciously suggested to an audience of advertisers in New York that Internet video had effectively replaced TV.

First, Sen. John McCain proposed legislation that would allow consumers to buy cable channels on an a la carte basis. Then Schmidt’s own company unveiled a new offering that allowed users to subscribe to channels on YouTube for a monthly or annual fee.

Schmidt may have a felt a tremendous sense of validation: Here was Google providing the very service the TV industry had failed so dramatically to deliver that a senator was attempting to force the industry’s hand.

But don’t let this convenient backdrop to YouTube’s highly anticipated announcement oversell its magnitude. A comparison with YouTube’s existing offerings provides better perspective.

For one thing, there’s a huge difference between the channels McCain wants to free from the traditional pay-TV bundle and the ones YouTube has brought to market. There is little overlap between the biggest brands on TV and the 54 channels YouTube is making available across digital platforms for anywhere from 99¢ to $6 per month.

If the biggest brand YouTube has to brag about at this point is UFC, that’s not exactly a show of strength in the marketplace. But in all fairness, Google rarely goes big out of the gate with anything, preferring to iterate along the way instead of making a splash at the start.

Nevertheless, YouTube will likely suffer the comparison with its last big original programming splash, a fleet of free ad-supported channels that had real pedigree attached, from superstars like Jay-Z or brands that were homegrown phenomena like Machinima.

That’s a striking contrast.

YouTube was probably better off waiting for buy-in from some higher profile auspices before launching this latest initiative. In their absence, it’s evident that no one of stature felt strongly enough about this business model to be an inaugural partner.

Maybe there is one such partner waiting in the wings, ready to blow the doors off our expectations. But given YouTube is already couching this as a “pilot program,” don’t hold your breath.

While the new subscription business will inevitably be compared with the funded channels, there’s a lesser known aspect of YouTube’s business that may offer a more apt juxtaposition. Back in early 2010, YouTube began offering a selection of movie titles on an a la carte basis. It began with documentaries at the Sundance Film Festival before expanding to encompass more prominent titles from the major studios.

If that’s news to you, well, that likely reflects the viability of the offering, which was completely overshadowed by successes elsewhere, from iTunes to Vudu.

This forgotten a la carte mode, which lives on at the cross-platform storefront Google Play, offers a more instructive comparison with the subscription channels than the funded channels, which unlike the other two, doesn’t require the user to engage in a financial transaction with YouTube.

Having users think of the platform as more than just a place for free content is a barrier built into the very DNA of YouTube, which arguably has been a zero-cost environment long enough that consumers have been conditioned to keep their hands out of their wallets.

With the addition of subscription channels, YouTube is coming to the place where it is trying so many business models that there’s risk of confusing its massive user base. Whether that’s diversification or desperation depends on your point of view; it just might be a little of both.

More Digital

  • Andy Signore Screen Junkies

    'Honest Trailers' Creator Andy Signore Settles Defy Media Suit

    Andy Signore, the creator of Screen Junkies’ “Honest Trailers,” has settled a lawsuit against Defy Media challenging his firing for alleged sexual misconduct. Signore was one of the first figures to lose his job in the aftermath of the Harvey Weinstein harassment revelations in October 2017. Defy Media, which then owned Screen Junkies, terminated him [...]

  • Joyride

    With Joyride, Everyone Can Host Their Own HQ Trivia

    When mobile game developer Kiwi first released Joyride, the app looked familiar: Similar to wildly popular HQ Trivia, Joyride offered players the ability to win quiz shows in live broadcasts. The key difference: Joyride’s app wasn’t home to just one trivia show, but multiple shows around topics like music, dating, fandom, and yes, trivia, all [...]

  • Etika-Desmond-Amofah

    Gaming YouTuber Desmond 'Etika' Amofah Found Dead, NYPD Says

    Desmond Amofah, a YouTube gaming vlogger known online as “Etika,” was found dead by New York police on Tuesday after he was reported missing last week. He was 29. Amofah posted YouTube videos and live-streams focused on Nintendo games and other titles. A body later confirmed to be Amofah’s was found in the East River on [...]

  • Paula Pell

    Quibi Orders Comedic Murder Mystery From Lorne Michaels, 'SNL' Alums

    Quibi keeps shelling out cash for content: Jeffrey Katzenberg’s richly funded startup has ordered a short-form murder-mystery comedy written by and starring former “Saturday Night Live” writers Paula Pell and John Lutz, and executive produced by Lorne Michaels’ Broadway Video alongside Seth Meyers and Mike Shoemaker. In “Mapleworth Murders,” Pell (pictured above) is Abigail Mapleworth, [...]

  • View of the Public Library on

    New York City Public Libraries Drop Kanopy Free Movie-Streaming Service

    Kanopy suffered a blow with the decision by New York City’s three public library systems — collectively the biggest library system in the U.S., with some 210 branches across the Big Apple — to drop the free movie-streaming service, citing high costs. As of July 1, the New York Public Library and the Brooklyn and [...]

  • Cameo

    Celebrity Video Greetings Service Cameo Raises $50 Million

    Cameo, a service that works with celebrities to sell personalized video greetings to fans, has raised a $50 million Series B round of funding led by Kleiner Perkins. The Chernin Group, Spark Ventures, Bain Capital and Lightspeeed Venture Partners participated in the funding as well. Cameo wants to use the cash infusion to grow both [...]

  • Gena Konstantinakos - Topic

    Topic Hires Viceland's Gena Konstantinakos as VP, Development and Video Programming

    Topic, First Look Media’s entertainment studio and digital destination for original content, hired veteran producer Gena Konstantinakos as VP, development and video programming. Konstantinakos hails from Vice Media’s Viceland cable channel, where she was executive producer, development and current series. At Topic, she reports to Ryan Chanatry, general manager of Topic. Konstantinakos is tasked with [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content