Xbox One Review: Has Microsoft Gone Too Far With Its New Console?

The impressive new video game console, that replaces the Xbox 360, is a reflection of our distracted times where multi-tasking rules

Now that Microsoft’s Xbox One is out and powering up TVs across the world, the company should be praised for coming up with a piece of hardware that actually lives up to its promise of delivering pretty much everything you might want –- games, movies, live or streamed TV shows, access to social media, Skype, “Minority Report”-like controls – all in one set-top box.

But what the Xbox One also does is serve as a mirror, reflecting who we are as a society right now.

Microsoft means well by giving us the option to play a game while watching a TV show and monitoring the tweets from people we follow while recording and posting what just happened on screen all at the same time.

With the Xbox One, Microsoft is clearly trying to recapture some of the magic Nintendo conjured up with its Wii in 2006, that made gaming appeal to the entire family, not just men who wanted to spend hours shooting aliens or soldiers.

Yet while trying to please everyone in the living room, for example, Microsoft is embracing the A.D.D. that’s turned us all into a distracted mess, always staring at a screen of various sizes and unable to carry on a conversation with the people around us. The much-enhanced Kinect further encourages us to talk to our hardware.

Of course, Microsoft isn’t alone. Every major electronics manufacturer is trying to pack as many multi-tasking tools as they can onto the devices they try to sell us. But in doing so, many are losing focus and failing to actually do anything well. Nintendo is struggling to remain relevant after failing to innovate on the gaming side and turning its newer Wii U into a broader entertainment device. Microsoft needs to keep that in mind as it constantly updates its next-generation console with new capabilities.

Is the Xbox One worth buying? Absolutely. Its tech specs are top-notch, a notable step up from the eight-year-old Xbox 360 that it replaces. But its price tag is $100 more than Sony’s PlayStation 4 because it comes with the Kinect, which has also been considerably updated from the original motion and voice sensor released in 2010 with better cameras and built-in technology.

In fact, it’s like a puppy leashed to your entertainment center, eager to please every time you walk into the room. And it’s named Xbox, who demands attention and constant commands.

The Xbox One hasn’t done away with the stern Xbox voice many Kinect users suddenly found themselves adopting three years ago. In fact, it’s going to only get louder, with Microsoft wanting you to now control how you watch live TV or select content from streaming video providers.

New features like the OneGuide, which takes over the clumsily designed programming schedules on your set-top box from a cable or satellite provider is a major plus –- especially as it offers up programming from apps like Machinima and other non-traditional content providers with apps designed for the Xbox One.

Searching for entertainment like a TV show or movie, or other titles that feature specific talent, has also improved considerably through Bing, with apps and stores popping up on how to view the content.

Such search functions will be critical as more digital distributors like Netflix, Amazon and Hulu produce original content and consumers forget –- or fail to care –- who offers what.

About that box. Microsoft has embraced industrial design with its new console. It’s large and a little imposing with sharp edges, a mix of shiny and grate-like surfaces on the black box that’s almost retro in its looks, a design perhaps meant to help Microsoft win over the non-gamer, as well. It looks like something a Comcast or DirecTV would deliver when signing up as a new subscriber. The Xbox 360 was far more playful with its curves and looked like a video game console. The Xbox One is far more serious.

But when powered on, your eye immediately goes to the glowing Xbox logo that lights up on the console and the Kinect. It’s an attention to detail that’s welcoming, as is the friendly shade of green the Xbox One’s designers have amped up on its main screen, a branding decision that trumps the colder, icy blue of the PlayStation.

SEE ALSO: PS4 Review: Sony Evolves, Not Revolutionizes the PlayStation

At its core, the Xbox One is still meant to be a gaming device, and it delivers here, too.

Consoles typically show off their capabilities through sports and racing games, and EA’s “NFL Madden” football franchise and “Forza Motorsport 5” look glorious and only hint at what kind of innovative play publishers are developing for the Xbox One in the coming years.

The subtly but noticeably redesigned Xbox One controller also makes playing games a better experience; the excellent new controller is lighter, features bigger buttons, vibrating triggers and is more comfortable to hold.

But with the PlayStation 4 also packing similar power, Microsoft hopes to win over the non-hardcore gamer with everything else the Xbox One does.

It will take some time to determine whether it succeeds. But if the way society today is glued to its smartphones and tablets is any indication, Microsoft may have a big multi-tasking winner on its hands.

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Doug Scott - Twitch

    Twitch Recruits Zynga's Doug Scott as Chief Marketing Officer

    Doug Scott is leaving as game company Zynga’s marketing boss to become Twitch’s CMO. Scott assumes the CMO role at Twitch after previous chief marketing officer Kate Jhaveri exited this summer to become the NBA’s top marketing exec. News of Scott’s hire comes less than a month after Twitch launched a redesigned logo and site, [...]

  • Carter Hansen - VidCon

    VidCon Hires Ex-AwesomenessTV Exec Carter Hansen to Head Conference Programming

    VidCon hired Carter Hansen, a founding executive at AwesomenessTV, as VP of programming to oversee conference programming and content for the internet-video events producer. In the newly created role, Hansen reports to VidCon GM Jim Louderback and will be based in Viacom’s Hollywood office. As part of overseeing programming worldwide for VidCon’s community, creator and [...]

  • The Boys Amazon Prime

    Nielsen Adds Amazon Prime Video to SVOD Measurement, With Limitations

    After two years of measuring Netflix viewing, Nielsen has now added Amazon Prime Video to the mix of subscription-streaming services it tracks — and with the same set of limitations. Nielsen’s SVOD Content Ratings originally launched in October 2017 with Netflix. According to the research firm, the addition of Amazon Prime Video measurement will let [...]

  • Gavel Court Placeholder

    Netflix Movie Scammer Admits to Defrauding Investors Out of $14 Million

    A California man has admitted to defrauding investment groups — nabbing $14 million — by falsely claiming the money would be used to produce a feature film for Netflix. On Oct. 18, Adam Joiner, 41, of Manhattan Beach, Calif., pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud in U.S. District Court, according to federal authorities. [...]

  • netflix debt

    Netflix to Raise Another $2 Billion Through Debt to Fund Massive Content Spending

    Netflix, burning boatloads of cash with a projected $15 billion content budget for 2019, is adding to its debt load once again. On Monday (Oct. 21), Netflix announced plans to offer approximately $2.0 billion aggregate principal amount of junk bonds, in both U.S dollar and euro denominations. As of Sept. 30, Netflix reported $12.43 billion [...]

  • Bristol, CT - July 26, 2018

    Mina Kimes Helps ESPN Kick Off 'Daily' Podcast

    Mina Kimes is preparing to take ESPN into a new frontier. The sports-media giant has launched a “SportsCenter” for Snapchat and tested baseball telecasts for kids. Now it’s hoping to set up shop in another media venue. Starting tomorrow, the Disney-backed company launches “ESPN Daily,” a weekday morning podcast that aims to tap its vast [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content