Why YouTube Offline Videos Won’t Be a Game-Changer

Starting in November, Internet video site will let users download content for playback within 48-hour period

Soon you’ll be able to order YouTube to go — and be able to watch videos even when you’re disconnected.

Starting in November, a new feature for Google’s YouTube mobile apps will let users watch videos offline for up to 48 hours when they don’t have an Internet connection.

The development promises to be a win for YouTube fans, who will now be able to watch content while they’re, say, trapped on a plane 30,000 feet in the air without Wi-Fi. But many industry execs are doubtful the feature will move the needle in terms of total views — or ad dollars, especially given the growth in high-speed wireless Internet connectivity.

The offline-viewing feature is “a welcome innovation… but likely not a huge game-changer,” said a top executive at a large YouTube multichannel networks, who requested anonymity because YouTube is a major partner. That said, the exec added, “mobile YouTube viewing is exploding and this will certainly help add fuel to that fire.”

YouTube says viewing on smartphones and tablets currently comprises more than 25% of users’ global watch time, representing more than 1 billion total views a day. The offline-viewing capability is aimed at pushing that even higher.

Popular on Variety

“This upcoming feature will allow people to add videos to their device to watch for a short period when an Internet connection is unavailable,” YouTube said in a blog post late Tuesday. “So your fans’ ability to enjoy your videos no longer has to be interrupted by something as commonplace as a morning commute.”

YouTube reps declined to comment beyond what it announced in the post.

According to sources familiar with the initiative, YouTube has notified a large group of partners to give them an opportunity to opt out if they so choose. Google in-­stream ads will play in offline content, and the views will be added to total view counts.

Not everyone thinks YouTube’s disconnected viewing will make much of a difference. “I think it’s a nice bonus, but probably not earth-shattering unless the download is for more of a long-form experience,” VideoNuze analyst Will Richmond said.

Meanwhile, YouTube’s offline-viewing feature won’t support discovery of new content through social and sharing “which happens ‘in the moment’ with a live connection,” said Larry Tanz, CEO of digital studio Vuguru. On the other hand, it might let YouTube charge higher CPMs (cost per thousand impressions) if it can show the downloading audience is more engaged, he added.

More broadly, a bigger issue for YouTube is the unhappiness content creators have with the terms of the advertising-revenue split: YouTube takes 45%, an arrangement many partners complain about.

One observer who’s upbeat on the potential for YouTube offline viewing is Peter Csathy, CEO of consulting and investment group Manatt Digital Media Ventures. He argued that the feature will let YouTube and partners fill the “gaping hole” when users are disconnected.

Reaching users cut off from the Internet is “the perfect time to engage with us with video — so a great opportunity for content creators and marketeers,” he said.

More Digital

  • Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren,

    How to Watch the Nevada Democratic Debate Online

    The ninth Democratic presidential debate will take place Wednesday as six hopeful candidates take the stage ahead of the Nevada caucus on Feb. 22. NBC and MSNBC will broadcast the debate on their networks from 6 p.m. PT/ 9 p.m. ET to 8 p.m. PT/ 10 p.m. ET. Those wanting to tune in can also [...]

  • Reed Hastings seen on day one

    Netflix CEO Reed Hastings' New Book Title, Release Date Announced

    Reed Hastings promises to share the untold story about how Netflix’s culture helped it pivot from a DVD-by-mail company to a streaming giant more than a decade ago in a new book due out this spring. “No Rules Rules: Netflix and the Culture of Reinvention,” is set to be released May 12, 2020. The 320-page [...]

  • A-ha - Take On Me Video

    A-ha's 'Take on Me' Tops 1 Billion YouTube Views, Second '80s Video to Hit Milestone

    Norwegian synthpop trio A-ha’s “Take On Me” has joined YouTube’s billion-views club. The iconic video from A-ha, which combines live action with pencil-sketch animation, is only the second song from the 1980s to reach the elite YouTube milestone, after Guns N’ Roses’ “Sweet Child O’ Mine” crested the one-billion-views mark last fall (and currently has [...]

  • Terms and Conditions

    YouTube Drives Into Feature Doc Space With Brian Hill's 'Terms and Conditions' (EXCLUSIVE)

    YouTube is driving into the feature documentary space with a bold new film on drill music from one of the U.K.’s most celebrated documentarians. The controversial genre represented in the Brian Hill-directed “Terms and Conditions: A U.K. Drill Story” has become inadvertently associated with violence and knife-crime in the U.K., and marks a daring step [...]

  • America Ferrera Gentrified Variety

    With ‘Gentefied,’ America Ferrera Brings a Series Unlike Any Other to Netflix

    America Ferrera had directed before, but not like this. She and her crew were shooting scenes from a massive burner party — think a miniature Burning Man, complete with drugs and costumes and bad dancing — for Netflix’s upcoming series “Gentefied.” Though she wouldn’t appear on camera, Ferrera was dressed for the occasion in a [...]

  • Alamo Drafthouse LA

    Alamo Drafthouse Unveils Monthly Subscription Service

    Alamo Drafthouse, the Texas-based cinema chain that popularized in-theater dining, is offering a subscription service to rival the AMCs and Regals of the exhibition industry. The company unveiled Season Pass, a monthly program that will be available to patrons in its 41 locations across the country. Season Pass will provide one regularly priced ticket per [...]

  • TV Decline Pay TV Placeholder

    Traditional Pay-TV Operators Lost 6 Million Subscribers in 2019 as Cord-Cutting Picks Up Speed

    The U.S. satellite and cable TV business declined at an unprecedented rate last year — with traditional pay-TV providers dropping a staggering 6 million customers, a 7% year-over-year decline. In the fourth quarter of 2019 alone, traditional TV distributors lost around 1.5 million subs, dropping to about 83 million total at year-end, according to estimates [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content