Apple’s ‘California’ Ads Don’t Put Tech Titan In Golden State

Ad analysis: Tech giant seizes upon old talking points to warm up to fickle consumers

The Cupertino, Calif., behemoth behind the iPad and the iPhone is digging out an old advertising recipe in hopes of making a splash while consumers wait for its Next Big iThing.

Fueled by sales of its iPhones and iPads, Apple is a corporate giant and technology titan. In the second quarter, Apple notched revenue of $43.6 billion and net profit of $9.5 billion. Compare that to the New York Times Co., which generated just under $2 billion for all of 2012.

Yet Apple is strumming on its roots in a new ad campaign that creates the impression the colossus is merely a small, sophisticated cadre of well-meaning folks who just happen to create magical devices that transform our lives. In doing so, Apple nods to an earlier era when it was seen as an upstart, not an entrenched player that dominated markets and consumer sentiment.

“We’re engineers and artists. Craftsmen and inventors,” reads the copy accompanying one of the print ads in the new campaign. “We sign our work. You may rarely look at it. But you’ll always feel it.” The tagline: “Designed by Apple in California.” As if anyone could just stumble upon the company’s campus and wade into the glory. A spokeswoman for Apple’s ad agency, TBWA\Media Arts Lab, declined to comment.

Apple is offering up a new twist on an old ploy: Talking small and thinking big. Apple seized the nation’s fancy wayyyyy back in 1984 when it ran a Super Bowl commercial depicting an athlete hurling a large hammer at a screen broadcasting the numbing jargon of a Big Brother-type figure. The spot was seen as a jab against tech behemoth IBM, which Apple hoped to take on with its new Macintosh. Later, in 2006, Apple tilted at Microsoft with a humorous series of “Mac vs. PC” ads that featured actor Justin Long as a hip, easygoing Mac showing up a fussy, doddering PC played by John Hodgman.

There’s no way in this day and age Apple can be considered a start-up. So why is the company acting as if it is?

During a period when Apple has little product news with which to overwhelm Twitter, burnishing its reputation may be the way to go, suggests Gene Munster, a Piper Jaffray analyst who has followed the tech concern for years. Munster says the “California” campaign reinforces the notion that well-made devices take time – a nice note for investors who know Apple’s stock tends to grow when it has a brand-spanking-new gadget to draw the public notice and generate buzz for its wares. With talk of an Apple TV and some sort of iWatch in the offing, the current ad effort may simply be something thrown out to the masses to mull as they wait for new iGizmos, Munster said.

Others view the campaign as a defensive maneuver. According to Munster, Apple’s youth appeal, while significant, isn’t growing as it once did. So the company has to appeal to a broader swath of customers, some of whom may be turned off by pokes at tech giants by another tech giant (a reason why we have yet to see an Apple ad take a smack at rival Samsung). Rather than putting IBM or Microsoft in its sights, Apple is simply burnishing its rebellious history in a gather-round-the-campfire kind of way. “These commercials make them more mainstream—softer and friendlier,” said Jim Marra, a professor of advertising at Philadelphia’s Temple University. “They say, ‘You can count on us, we have the reputation.'”

If only Apple had something new to sell, too! “The marketplace has not seen significant game-changers since [Steve] Jobs,” noted Mark Faust, a corporate strategist who counsels companies on how to grow.

The emphasis on “California” also brings to mind a campaign from another big advertiser who found itself needing to curry public favor. Chrysler was on the outs after the recent recession, and snatched up two minutes in the 2011 Super Bowl to tell viewers – with the backing of an Eminem song – that its cars were “Imported from Detroit” (even though the company is these days owned by Italian automaker Fiat). Is Apple also trying to convey the thought that its products are designed by Americans (albeit manufactured byt the Chinese) in hopes of wooing away support from Samsung, its South Korean rival?

Apple advertising once captured the imagination and was universally considered cool. The “California” effort is the latest in a series of wild swings that have the company in one instance using celebrities like Zooey Deschanel and Samuel L. Jackson to sell its voice-operated Siri assistant, and in another offering an awkward “Genius” character from its stores to help solve technical dilemmas. These ads are a far cry from the company’s bewitching animated iPod spots, its “Think Different” campaign or its iPod blurb offering a sneak preview of U2 singing “Vertigo.”

Now Apple is as likely to produce commercial misfires as anyone with a smokeless ashtray to sell. Maybe that’s by dint of the fact that it’s producing more commercials these days in order to sell more products.

Whatever it is Apple designs in California, it’s not clear that any of it will hypnotize the public the way its commercials did in an earlier, more innocent time.

More TV

  • Game of Thrones finale

    Emmys 2019: Nominations Scorecard by Program and TV Platform

    “Game of Thrones” dominated nominations for the 71st annual Emmy Awards, earning a record 32 nominations and putting HBO on top again. The series, which recently aired its final season, was the most-nominated program, followed by Amazon’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” (20), HBO’s “Chernobyl” (19), NBC’s “Saturday Night Live” (18), HBO’s “Barry” (17), FX’s “Fosse/Verdon” [...]

  • Peter Dinklage Game of Thrones

    Emmys 2019 Nominations: HBO Back at the Top, As 'Game of Thrones' Makes History

    HBO’s back — and the Television Academy has finally got its Schitt together. The Emmy nominations failed to disappoint on Tuesday morning, recognizing critically acclaimed series such as “Schitt’s Creek” and “Fleabag,” and giving TV juggernaut “Game of Thrones” a rousing farewell. “Thrones” broke the record books this year, scoring an astounding 32 nominations — [...]

  • Game of Thrones finale

    'Game of Thrones' Breaks Emmys Record for Most Nominations in a Single Season

    “Game of Thrones” is going out with a bang. For its final run, the HBO fantasy epic scored 32 nominations for the Emmy Awards Tuesday morning, the most for any program in a single season. That record was previously held by “NYPD Blue,” which scored 26 nominations in 1994. Over its full eight seasons, “Game [...]

  • Emmy Nominations Snubs and Surprises 2019

    Emmy Nominations 2019: Biggest Snubs and Surprises

    Landmark series such as HBO’s “Game of Thrones” and “Veep” came to an end earlier this year, marking the last time the respective drama and comedy awards magnets would be eligible at the Emmys. While it seemed inevitable that those would score a number of noms on the 71st annual ballot, there were a lot [...]

  • Emmy Nominations Placeholder

    Emmys: 'Game of Thrones' Helps HBO Retake Nomination Lead Over Netflix

    The 32 Emmy nominations earned by “Game of Thrones” — the most for any program in a single season — put HBO back in the No. 1 spot for most nominations by platform this year, giving it a total of 137 and easily beating Netflix’s 117. Both platforms had a forceful presence in each category. [...]

  • AtmosphereCreative Arts Emmy Awards, Governors Ball,

    Emmys 2019: List of Nominations

    Nominations for the 71st annual Emmy Awards were announced Tuesday morning , and “Game of Thrones” and “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” dominated nods for TV’s top honors. The buzzy final season of HBO’s epic fantasy season picked up a leading 32 nominations, but “Game of Thrones” isn’t the only top contender in the drama category. [...]

  • An Emmy statue stands outside the

    How to Watch the 2019 Emmy Nominations

    Ken Jeong and D’Arcy Carden are gearing up to present 71st Primetime Emmy Awards nominations, and cord cutters can still tune in to find out who might take home TV’s top honors. The nomination ceremony will begin on Tuesday at 8:30 a.m. PT/ 11:30 a.m. ET from the Saban Media Center in Los Angeles. Jeong [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content