×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

FilmOn X, Rival to Aereo, Argues to Appellate Court That Its “Innovation” Is Legal

As the broadcast networks have so far tried and failed to shut down Aereo in east coast federal courts, they have had success in curbing a similar startup in the west.

The latest chapter came on Tuesday, as Beverly Hills-based FilmOn X sought to overturn a district court’s preliminary injunction, which bars it from offering digital streams of broadcast signals, made possible via remote antennas assigned to each subscriber. The company is perhaps just as well known for its former name, Aereokiller, given to it by its colorful founder, Alki David.

An attorney for the company, Ryan Baker of Baker Marquart, argued to a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals that it should adopt the same rationale that the 2nd Circuit did earlier this year in allowing Aereo to continue.

Users of FilmOn X’s service get a “discrete, unique antenna” that make the transmissions of the broadcast signals private, and not a violation of the public performance clause of the Copyright Act of 1976, Baker said. He suggested that it was little different than a consumer going to Best Buy to buy an antenna to make such digital streams possible, only this time subscribers who rent the remote devices “have the option to pay a lot less per month.”

But one of the appellate judges, Brian M. Cogan, gave a wry reading of FilmOn X, calling it “pretty darn clever” and calling it “innovation arrived at for the sole purpose of avoiding the statute.”

Nevertheless, Baker said that FilmOn X still “complies with the literal terms of the statute,” noting that the transmit clause of the Copyright Act makes a distinction between public and private performances. “It is innovation,” he said.

Late last year, U.S. District Judge George Wu granted an injunction preventing FilmOn from transmitting the station signals in California and other states, although he refused to extend the ban nationwide. In his decision, Wu ruled that what FilmOn was doing was a public performance, even if there were one-to-one transmissions to private homes.

Paul Smith of Jenner & Block, representing Fox, argued that the Copyright Act even contemplates such “unique transmissions,” and that Congress’ intent was that they would still be public performances.

“They are in the live transmission business, exactly like a cable company,” he said.

Robert Garrett of Arnold & Porter, representing NBC Universal, noted that Congress wrote in a clause that a public performance includes one that is transmitted “by means of any device or process.” He said that as new technologies have come on the scene, like satellite and telco services, they have been required to obtain licenses to transmit broadcast signals.

Yet Judge Diarmuid Fionntain O’Scannlain noted that was before a 2008 2nd Circuit decision upholding the legality of Cablevision’s remote DVR, paving the way for the creation of Aereo.

That Cablevision decision, Garrett said, was “wrong.”

“Alright,” O’Scannlain said, chuckling at the abrupt answer.

He questioned where the line was drawn from when a transmission goes from private to public.

The FilmOn X case has potential implications as to whether the Supreme Court decides to review the issue of unauthorized transmissions of broadcast signals. If the 9th Circuit sides with the networks, it would set up a split in the appellate circuits, making such a review all the more likely. But Fox may seek a high court review of the 2nd Circuit’s Aereo decision before an opinion is issued in the FilmOn case.

 

 

Popular on Variety

More Biz

  • Harvey Weinstein

    Weinstein Can Get a Fair Trial in Manhattan, Says D.A.

    The Manhattan District Attorney’s office argued on Friday that Harvey Weinstein can get a fair trial in Manhattan, and blamed the producer’s defense team for much of the pre-trial publicity in the case. Weinstein’s attorneys have asked an appellate court to transfer the case — which is set to begin on Sept. 9 — to [...]

  • Leonardo DiCaprio Madonna

    Leonardo DiCaprio, Madonna Call for Action on Amazon Wildfires

    As wildfires rage at an alarming rate in Brazil’s Amazon rain forest, celebrities are using their platforms to bring awareness to the deforestation’s impact and to call for action. In the past week, stars like Leonardo DiCaprio, Madonna, Cara Delevingne and Ariana Grande have taken to Instagram to express their frustration with the lack of [...]

  • 'The Durrells' TV Show

    Greece Sweetens Production Incentives as Struggling Country's Economy Rebounds

    It’s taken the better part of a decade for Greece to show signs of recovery from the crippling crisis that almost pushed it out of the Eurozone. Now, with the economy slowly on the mend, the government is doubling down on efforts to jump-start the local film industry, giving a dramatic overhaul to the incentive [...]

  • Warner Music Group Partners With Audiomack

    Warner Music Group Partners With Audiomack

    Warner Music Group announced it has entered a partnership with the music streaming and discovery service Audiomack, marking the platform’s first licensing deal with a major label. According to the announcement, the two companies will work together on content concepts and explore ways to break emerging artists, connecting music fans with rising talent before they [...]

  • Scooter Braun Congratulates Taylor Swift on

    Scooter Braun Congratulates Taylor Swift on ‘Brilliant’ Album and Campaign

    Two days after Taylor Swift fired off the latest salvo in her battle with Scooter Braun, the manager congratulated the singer on the campaign around her “brilliant” new album, “Lover,” which arrived last night. The message came after Swift said she will be re-recording songs from her first six albums, which are now owned by [...]

  • David Koch Obit

    David Koch, Libertarian Activist and Billionaire Philanthropist, Dies at 79

    David Koch, brother of Charles Koch and one of the owners of Koch Industries, the second-largest private company in the U.S., has died at 79. According to the New York Times, Charles Koch announced the news of his brother’s death in a statement. Though he did not attribute to David’s death to a particular cause, [...]

  • Beverly Hills Realtor Accused of Stealing

    Beverly Hills Realtor Accused of Stealing From Usher, Adam Lambert

    A Beverly Hills real estate agent has been arrested on charges of stealing from the homes of celebrities, including Usher, Adam Lambert and “Real Housewives” star Dorit Kemsley. Jason Emil Yaselli, 32, is accused of encouraging an accomplice, Benjamin Ackerman, to enter homes during open houses in order to steal from them. Ackerman allegedly sold [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content