Aereo Notches Another Legal Win Against Broadcasters

Aereo, the startup that streams broadcast TV signals over the Internet, scored another victory in federal court Thursday when a district court judge in Massachusetts denied Hearst Television’s request to shut the service down — potentially leading to a showdown between broadcasters and Aereo before the Supreme Court.

The court, however, denied Aereo’s request to move the case to New York, where the startup is facing another lawsuit against major broadcasters.

“The court was right to keep this case in Boston, the home of WCVB-TV,” a station rep said in a statement. “We will immediately appeal the court’s decision that allows Aereo to continue to engage in a commercial business that unlawfully profits by using WCVB’s copyrighted broadcasts and shows. We expect to prevail in this case.”

In a statement, Aereo CEO Chet Kanojia said, “Today’s victory belongs to the consumer and today’s decision, makes clear that that there is no reason that consumers should be limited to 1950s technology to access over-the-air broadcast television. Using Aereo, a consumer can simply and easily use an individual remote antenna and cloud DVR via the Internet to record and watch-over-the air program.”

As Variety first reported, major broadcasters that are suing Aereo for copyright infringement plan to petition the U.S. Supreme Court by Oct. 15 to review lower court rulings denying their bid to stop Aereo from distributing their programming.

Heart’s ABC affiliate WCVB filed suit in U.S. District Court in Massachusetts against Aereo in July, claiming copyright infringement in that Aereo “intentionally induces and encourages its subscribers to directly infringe WCVB’s copyrights by reproducing programming without authorization.” In the ruling Thursday, District Court Judge Nathaniel M. Gorton denied Heart’s request for a preliminary injunction that would have blocked Aereo, saying the broadcaster did not make its case that it would be likely to succeed on the merits of its claims.

SEE ALSO: Why Aereo Didn’t Try to Exploit CBS-Time Warner Cable Fight

The latest ruling comes after broadcasters were denied requests to block Aereo by a New York district court last year. In July, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals refused to reconsider the ruling.

Aereo has prevailed, so far, by relying on a court decision upholding the legality of Cablevision’s network-based DVR system. Like the Cablevision system, Aereo has argued, it is simply hosting antennas and DVR storage infrastructure that its users control remotely. Broadcasters contend Aereo must pay retransmission fees just like cable, satellite and telco TV providers.

Meanwhile, Aereo faces another lawsuit in Utah. In that complaint, as in other previous challenges, three local broadcasters and Fox Broadcasting allege that Aereo violates the public performance clause of the Copyright Act.

Aereo separately said it plans to introduce an Android-based app for accessing the service on Oct. 22.

To date, Aereo — whose backers include IAC chairman Barry Diller — has rolled out service in New York City, Boston, Atlanta, Salt Lake City, Miami, Houston and Dallas. In addition, Aereo plans to expand to four more cities — Columbus and Cincinnati, Ohio; Indianapolis, Indiana; and San Antonio, Texas — with launch dates for those markets to be announced.

Aereo, which has just over 100 employees, has raised $63 million from investors including IAC, FirstMark Capital, First Round Capital, Highland Capital Partners and High Line Venture Partners.

More TV

  • Jim Jefferies

    NBC Orders Comedy Pilots From Jim Jefferies, 'Superstore' Creator Justin Spitzer

    NBC has picked up a pair of comedy pilots for the 2020-2021 season. The first is the multi-cam “Jefferies,” which will star Australian comedian Jim Jefferies as a fictionalized version of himself. Jefferies will also write and executive produce along with Suzanne Martin. Sean Hayes and Todd Milliner of Hazy Mills will also executive produce [...]

  • Kari Lizer

    ABC Orders Comedy Pilot From 'New Adventures of Old Christine' Creator

    ABC has picked up the multi-cam comedy pilot “My Village” from Kari Lizer. The project follows an empty-nester mom who wonders how she ended up alone while her children live their best lives thousands of miles away. She decides her place is with her family and as she reinserts herself into their lives, her kids [...]

  • Chuck Lorre77th Annual Golden Globe Awards,

    Chuck Lorre Comedy Pilot 'B Positive' Ordered at CBS

    Chuck Lorre is working on yet another project at CBS. The legendary “Big Band Theory” creator is an executive producer on the multi-cam comedy “B Positive,” which has received a pilot order at CBS. “B Positive” centers around newly divorced dad Drew, who is at the end of his rope when face when finding a [...]

  • Author Gill Hornby gives a talk

    Steve Coogan, Christine Langan's Baby Cow Options Gill Hornby Novel ‘Miss Austen’

    Steve Coogan and Christine Langan’s U.K. company Baby Cow Productions has optioned television rights to Gill Hornby’s new novel, “Miss Austen.” The critically acclaimed book – already lauded as one of the best novels of 2020 by The Times of London, Financial Times and BBC Online – follows the lives and loves of sisters Cassandra [...]

  • Shay MitchellHulu 'Dollface' TV Show panel,

    'Pretty Little Liars' Alum Shay Mitchell Sets Mob Drama Pilot 'The Cleaning Lady' at Fox

    Fox is adding a mob drama about a cleaning lady to its development slate. The network has issued a pilot order for “The Cleaning Lady,” a one-hour drama which hails from “Pretty Little Liars,” “Dollface” and “You” star Shay Mitchell via her Amore & Vita Productions banner. Based on the original Argentine series “La Chica [...]

  • Jim Lehrer

    Jim Lehrer, Longtime PBS Anchor, Dies at 85

    Jim Lehrer, the legendary journalist who helped set a high bar for TV journalism via his long-running program on PBS, died on Thursday at his home, according to the network. He was 85 years old. Lehrer was a correspondent for the Dallas Morning News who moved to TV reporting for the local public TV station, [...]

  • Peter Logreco

    Peter LoGreco Inks Overall Deal With Intellectual Property Corporation (EXCLUSIVE)

    Documentarian Peter LoGreco has signed an overall deal with the Intellectual Property Corporation (IPC). LoGreco is a documentary showrunner, director, and producer. Under the deal, he will collaborate with IPC’s CEO, Eli Holzman, and president, Aaron Saidman, to develop original series and showrun series for IPC. LoGreco previously served as showrunner and director for the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content