Aereo CEO: Lawmakers Won’t Let Networks Shift to Cable Model

The CEO and founder of Aereo suggested that lawmakers will step in if TV networks follow through with threats to move programming from the free airwaves to cable TV as a response to courts allowing digital streams of broadcast station signals.

Chet Kanojia (pictured) says in an interview with C-SPAN’s “The Communicators,” to be shown on Saturday, that if Fox and other broadcasters convert to a cable model, “I have a very difficult time believing that lawmakers are going to sit idle while this develops and as … consumers [don’t] have access to broadcast TV. I don’t think that’s in the future of the United States.”

News Corp. COO Chase Carey said in April that moving Fox to a pay TV model would be an option if Aereo’s service is allowed to continue to offer streams of their signals without compensation to broadcasters. They argue that Aereo undermines their ability to collect retransmission fees from cable and satellite operators, which pay hefty sums to carry stations while Aereo pays nothing.

Yet the networks and other broadcasters have so far lost in courtroom attempts to put an immediate stop to Aereo. On Tuesday, the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals refused to reconsider the networks’ appeal of a district court judge’s refusal to issue an injunction against Aereo.

Fox said that it is considering options, including whether to take its challenge to the Supreme Court.

Just as Kanojia suggests that Congress would try to prevent broadcasters from switching to a cable model, there also is a presumption among some Wall Street analysts that lawmakers would step in to clarify the Copyright Act to prevent Aereo or any other upstart from providing broadcast signals without falling under restransmission consent rules.

Kanojia, however, said in the interview that he thinks “there is a desire [in Congress] to support innovation. I think there is a desure to create competition. I think there is a desire to have choice.”

Launched last year in New York, Aereo this year has expanded to Boston and Atlanta, and has ambitious expansion plans to launch in nearly two dozen more cities, including Washington.

While other services offering digital broadcast streams have been shut down by the courts, Aereo keeps a farm of thousands of dime-sized antennas for its subscribers, the idea being that each subscriber is still capturing his or her own signal as they would if they had an antenna on their rooftop. The legal rationale is based in part on a 2008 2nd Circuit decision that allowed Cablevision to offer a remote DVR, the idea being that because consumers are still in control of what and when they are watching, it is still a private use and not a violation of the public performance provisions of the Copyright Act.

“It is a very discreet, distinct, one-to-one relationship,” Kanojia said in the interview.

Denny Chin, an appellate judge who dissented with the majority in the Aereo decision, called it a “Rube Goldberg-like contrivance” and wrote that the company was “engineering technology to fit within the law.”

Kanojia defended how the company was set up, comparing it to drivers operating within the speed limit.

“We are taking advantage of the guardrails that the law has set up,” he said, adding, “I think that is a perfectly fine thing to do.”

He declined to say how many subscribers Aereo has. He said that the reaction from broadcasters was a “default reaction of the industry to keep everyone out, to stop innovation.”

He also rejected the notion that Aereo should be paying retrans fees to broadcasters, saying that “trying to levy that regime on equipment providers makes absolutely no sense.”

He said that broadcasters’ predictions of doom if Aereo goes forward is “saber rattling,” noting that more than 50 million people get TV via antennas.

“How is it that people can do that and there is no harm and life is going great, and a little company Aereo is suddenly going to mean the death of you?”

He said that the “reality” is that there has been agenda among broadcasters that they “would rather just be cable, and just essentially have the dual protected revenue stream.”

“The problem with that is, the intent in Congress in granting the spectrum was public convenience, the right of people to get this programming for free using a technology is important,” he said. “That is the basis of the spectrum grant, and that needs to be protected.”

More Biz

  • Nick Cannon Drew Barrymore Lauren Lake

    NATPE 2020: Industryites Hope Marquee Names Help Drive Daytime Turnaround

    A little momentum goes a long way in daytime. After a long slump, the first-run syndication market has come back to life this year with several high-profile new talk shows headed for this year’s NATPE conference in Miami, which runs Jan. 21-23. Nick Cannon is extending his multimedia endeavors into daytime. So is actor-entrepreneur Drew [...]

  • Mandatory Credit: Photo by Richard Sowersby/REX/Shutterstock

    Joint Sky & NBC News Channel Confirmed, Set To Rival CNN & Bloomberg

    Comcast confirmed plans to launch a global news platform with Sky News at the launch of its highly anticipated streaming offering Peacock. Variety understands that the channel will be a brand new service that exists independent of Sky News and NBC News, with bases likely to be set up in London and New York and a [...]

  • Recording Academy President/CEO Deborah Dugan participates

    Grammy Shocker: Deborah Dugan Ouster Was a ‘Coup,’ Insiders Say

    As the music industry reeled in the wake of Deborah Dugan’s sudden removal from her post as president/CEO of the Recording Academy on Thursday — a mere five months after she’d taken charge, and just ten days before the Grammy Awards — even insiders were stunned by the abruptness of the move and perplexed by [...]

  • Peacock Launch: NBCUniversal Tries New Way

    Peacock Launch: NBCUniversal Tries New Way to Deliver Old-Fashioned Bundle of TV

    In the big unveiling Thursday on the “Saturday Night Live” stage at 30 Rock, NBCUniversal leaders described Peacock as a 21st century iteration of a broadcast network. For sure, the Comcast answer to the streaming wars is taking a broadcasters’ approach to programming and distributing the service that Comcast hopes might eventually represent the next [...]

  • Maoyan Entertainment

    FountainVest Buys Stake in China's Maoyan Entertainment

    Asian private equity firm, FountainVest Partners has acquired a significant minority stake in Chinese film ticketing and distribution firm Maoyan Entertainment in a deal worth about $134 million dollars. Maoyan listed its shares on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange in an IPO last year. FountainVest owns 92.6% of shares in Interstellar Investment, which in turn [...]

  • Weinstein Trial

    D.A. Accuses Weinstein Defense of Excluding White Female Jurors

    A prosecutor accused Harvey Weinstein’s defense team on Thursday of systematically excluding young white women from the jury. Seven jurors have been selected so far, but none of them are white women. On Thursday afternoon, the defense eliminated at least seven white women from two panels of prospective jurors. Joan Illuzzi, the lead prosecutor, made [...]

  • Artist Partner Group Promotes Miles Beard

    Artist Partner Group Promotes Miles Beard to Senior VP, Powers up Leadership Team

    Artist Partner Group (APG) has strengthened its senior leadership team with several staff promotions, including: Miles Beard to SVP of A&R; Eli Piccarreta to VP of A&R; Jessica Kelm to VP of Digital Marketing; while Nikisha Bailey has been hired as VP of A&R Admin & Operations. Beard, Piccarreta, and Bailey will report to CEO Mike Caren, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content