×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Aereo Tries to Distance Itself From Rival’s Legal Losses

FilmOn X, which offers digital streams of broadcast signals, lost in court again on Thursday, with more signs that a string of legal defeats may affect not just its business but that of its rival, Aereo.

U.S. District Judge Rosemary M. Collyer refused FilmOn X’s request to set aside an injunction as it pursues an appeal or to roll back the scope of her order prohibiting the company from offering the unauthorized broadcast station feeds in almost the entire U.S. Last week, Collyer ruled that the offerings of FilmOn X’s D.C. service were public performances in violation of the Copyright Act, and she extended an injunction not just in the nation’s capital but in all other jurisdictions save New York.

While her order applies just to FilmOn X, she also seemed to suggest that Aereo will have future legal troubles outside the New York area, where courts so far have held that its service doesn’t violate copyright by offering broadcast feeds to customers assigned tiny, dime-sized antennas.

In her latest ruling rejecting FilmOn X’s arguments, Collyer wrote that Aereo was “a similar service that also appears to infringe” on broadcasters’ copyrights. That may set up a roadblock to Aereo’s plans to enter the D.C. market. A district judge in Los Angeles, George Wu, ruled against FilmOn X late last year, and Aereo has stayed away from the Southern California market even as it set up an aggressive plan of expansion in other markets. Wu’s decision is on appeal.

As they watched Aereo score legal victories in New York, the networks’ legal teams have adopted a strategy of isolating the company elsewhere, confident that the language of the Copyright Act was on their side. The next chapter will be in Boston, where a federal judge is holding a hearing next week on whether Aereo is infringing copyrights in that market. Aware of the FilmOn X rulings, Aereo’s attorneys on Wednesday filed a brief in the Boston court arguing that Collyer relied on a “misinterpretation of the Copyright Act and its legislative history.”

“Only transmissions ‘to the public’ constitute public performance,” Aereo said in its filing. “The undisputed facts establish that an Aereo member may only transmit her own individual copy to herself. That is the performance at issue and it is not ‘to the public.'” It also argues that the rationale adopted by the 2nd Circuit in New York — which emphasized the control that a user had over the technology — was applied by the Ninth Circuit when it upheld Dish Network’s use of an automatic ad-skipping and recording technology.

Conflicting federal circuit court opinions could well spur the Supreme Court to pick up one or several cases — and some are predicting that is just what will ultimately happen. But at least in the last couple of weeks, the broadcast networks have some glimmers of hope that the march of this Internet streaming technology will be kept in check.

More TV

  • Supergirl -- "Crisis on Infinite Earths:

    'Crisis on Infinite Earths' Recap: A 'Titans' Cameo and a Fallen Hero

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched “Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part One,” the premiere of the 2019 “Arrowverse” crossover. Bringing “Crisis on Infinite Earths” to the small screen has been years in the making, so it’s no surprise the epic five-part crossover kicked off with plenty of action on Sunday night [...]

  • Supergirl -- "Crisis on Infinite Earths:

    'Arrowverse' Team on 'Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part One' Loss and Crossover Stakes (SPOILERS)

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched “Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part One,” the premiere of the 2019 “Arrowverse” crossover event on the CW. The “Arrowverse” “Crisis on Infinite Earths” crossover kicked off with a bang: Oliver Queen aka the Green Arrow’s (Stephen Amell) death. With “Crisis” finally here, Harbinger (Audrey Marie [...]

  • Caroll Spinney & The Grouch36th Annual

    Caroll Spinney: Henson Family, 'Sesame Street' Colleagues Salute Muppet Performer

    Caroll Spinney, the puppet performer behind “Sesame Street’s” indelible Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch, was remembered by friends and colleagues as a gifted artist who dedicated his professional life to the show’s mission of educating pre-schoolers. Spinney died Sunday at his home in Connecticut at the age of 85. He limned the Big Bird [...]

  • Rene Auberjonois at the International Myeloma

    René Auberjonois, 'Star Trek' and 'Boston Legal' Actor, Dies at 79

    René Auberjonois, best known for his roles in “Boston Legal” and “Star Trek: Deep Space Nine,” died at his home in Los Angeles due to metastatic lung cancer. He was 79. His son Rèmy-Luc confirmed the news to the Associated Press. Auberjonois was a prolific television actor, appearing as Paul Lewiston in 71 episodes of [...]

  • Caroll Spinney, with "Oscar the Grouch,"

    Caroll Spinney, Puppeteer Behind Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch, Dies at 85

    Caroll Spinney, the puppeteer who played Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch for 49 years at “Sesame Street,” died Sunday in Connecticut after living with dystonia. He was 85. Sesame Workshop announced his death, calling him an “artistic genius” whose “legacy here at Sesame Workshop and in the cultural firmament will be unending.” Spinney’s death [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content