×

Aereo Tries to Distance Itself From Rival’s Legal Losses

FilmOn X, which offers digital streams of broadcast signals, lost in court again on Thursday, with more signs that a string of legal defeats may affect not just its business but that of its rival, Aereo.

U.S. District Judge Rosemary M. Collyer refused FilmOn X’s request to set aside an injunction as it pursues an appeal or to roll back the scope of her order prohibiting the company from offering the unauthorized broadcast station feeds in almost the entire U.S. Last week, Collyer ruled that the offerings of FilmOn X’s D.C. service were public performances in violation of the Copyright Act, and she extended an injunction not just in the nation’s capital but in all other jurisdictions save New York.

While her order applies just to FilmOn X, she also seemed to suggest that Aereo will have future legal troubles outside the New York area, where courts so far have held that its service doesn’t violate copyright by offering broadcast feeds to customers assigned tiny, dime-sized antennas.

In her latest ruling rejecting FilmOn X’s arguments, Collyer wrote that Aereo was “a similar service that also appears to infringe” on broadcasters’ copyrights. That may set up a roadblock to Aereo’s plans to enter the D.C. market. A district judge in Los Angeles, George Wu, ruled against FilmOn X late last year, and Aereo has stayed away from the Southern California market even as it set up an aggressive plan of expansion in other markets. Wu’s decision is on appeal.

As they watched Aereo score legal victories in New York, the networks’ legal teams have adopted a strategy of isolating the company elsewhere, confident that the language of the Copyright Act was on their side. The next chapter will be in Boston, where a federal judge is holding a hearing next week on whether Aereo is infringing copyrights in that market. Aware of the FilmOn X rulings, Aereo’s attorneys on Wednesday filed a brief in the Boston court arguing that Collyer relied on a “misinterpretation of the Copyright Act and its legislative history.”

“Only transmissions ‘to the public’ constitute public performance,” Aereo said in its filing. “The undisputed facts establish that an Aereo member may only transmit her own individual copy to herself. That is the performance at issue and it is not ‘to the public.'” It also argues that the rationale adopted by the 2nd Circuit in New York — which emphasized the control that a user had over the technology — was applied by the Ninth Circuit when it upheld Dish Network’s use of an automatic ad-skipping and recording technology.

Conflicting federal circuit court opinions could well spur the Supreme Court to pick up one or several cases — and some are predicting that is just what will ultimately happen. But at least in the last couple of weeks, the broadcast networks have some glimmers of hope that the march of this Internet streaming technology will be kept in check.

More TV

  • Bob GreenblattCreating Great Characters: Dick Wolf

    Bob Greenblatt on WarnerMedia Streaming Strategy: 'The Assets are Undeniable'

    CANNES — AT&T is ready for battle in the streaming wars. The new parent company of HBO and Warner Bros. has moved quickly to respond to consumer demand by marshaling its forces behind the launch next spring of HBO Max, WarnerMedia Entertainment chairman Bob Greenblatt told a crowd of international TV and digital executives here [...]

  • Roberto Gomez Bolanos Mexican actor Roberto

    Chespirito Media Universe in Development from Grupo Chespirito, Thr3 Media Group

    Mexican production companies Grupo Chespirito and Thr3 Media Group have come to terms on a deal to co-produce multi-media content and create the Chespirito Media Universe based on the characters and world of Mexico and Latin America’s most iconic TV creator, director, producer and actor, Chespirito. Thr3 Media Group was launched in January 2018 by [...]

  • Bastian-and-Fabienne_2btube-Office-1

    2btube Adds Lacoproductora to Facebook, YouTube Originals Alliances

    CANNES —  Fast-driving from a huge digital media publishing base into the creation and production of premium content for global platforms and beyond, top Spanish-language digital native media group 2btube has clinched a wide-ranging production partnership with José Miguel Contreras’ Madrid-based Lacoproductora. The deal comes fast on the heels of 2btube’s production alliance with Facebook [...]

  • LA-CHICA-QUE-LIMPIA-PICTURE

    Spain's Fasten Films Nabs Remake Rights to Argentine Series 'The Cleaning Lady' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Barcelona-based company Fasten Films has optioned Spanish and Portuguese adaptation rights to Argentine suspense series “La chica que limpia” (“The Cleaning Lady”). The deal was negotiated with Argentine distributors RM Vistar and GlowStar, who jointly handle the format’s international sales. A Mexican remake of the series is being produced by Turner Latin America, alongside BTF [...]

  • Motiv: Max ConzeFoto: © ProSiebenSat.1/Martin SaumweberDieses

    ProSiebenSat.1 Boss Max Conze Unfazed By the Invasion of the Digital Streaming Giants

    Max Conze, CEO of German broadcast company ProSiebenSat.1 since June last year, appeared relatively relaxed about the prospect of the coming invasion of new subscription streaming players like Disney Plus into his territory when speaking to journalists at TV market and conference Mipcom in Cannes Tuesday. “Disney will not lock away all their content,” he [...]

  • Irmaos Freitas

    Amazon Prime Video takes Turner’s ‘Freitas Brothers’

    CANNES — In yet another – and significant – Latin America distribution deal for the now highly active OTT giant, Amazon Prime Video has acquired Brazilian and pan-Spanish-speaking Latin American SVOD rights to Turner Latin America’s highly anticipated “Freitas Brothers.” The announcement was made late Tuesday by Turner Latin America at Cannes Mipcom TV and [...]

  • Tulsi Gabbard, Tom Steyer, Cory Booker,

    Nonsense Ellen DeGeneres Question Derails an Otherwise Substantive Democratic Debate (Column)

    The fourth Democratic debate was dangerously close to being substantive. For almost three (3!) hours, the twelve (12!) candidates onstage tackled questions on foreign policy, reproductive rights, health care, gun control, big tech, and the opioid crisis. While the other debates — and indeed, the entire 2016 presidential campaign — have been marked by meme-able [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content