×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Lawsuits challenge studio homevid accounting practice

Helmers claim they were shortchanged by Fox, Par, Sony and U

Challenging a long-standing profit participation practice, a clutch of filmmakers and the estate of Charles Bronson have filed a class-action lawsuit against four studios over homevideo accounting.

The films at the center of the suit — 1978’s “Foul Play,” 1982’s “The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas,” 1975’s “Hard Times” and 1975’s “Lucky Lady” — were all released before the practice of using 20% of a film’s homevid revenue to account to profit participants became standard practice in the 1980s.

But the profit participants, including “Foul Play” and “Whorehouse” director Colin Higgins and “Lucky Lady” helmer Stanley Donen, allege that they made their respective deals based on 100% of homevideo grosses, and are therefore entitled to profits based on a larger share of the revenue pie.

Higgins sued Paramount and Universal, Donen sued 20th Century Fox and the trustee of Bronson’s estate, Larry Martindale, sued Sony over “Hard Times.”

While the 20% figure has been standard practice in talent deals and guild residual formulas since the ’80s, studios have accounted for older films in much the same way. A source with knowledge of the matter said the plaintiffs had no idea that their royalties were based on the 20% revenue pool.

“(Paramount’s) misconduct offends public policy and is immoral, unscrupulous, unethical, and offensive, and causes substantial injury to consumers,” the complaint against Par alleges.

The outcome of the class-action suit could influence the current discussion surrounding digital platforms, as an ongoing debate brews over whether digital re-use revenues from film and television should be classified as home entertainment.

“This comes up every time there’s a new media,” said Schuyler Moore, a partner at Stroock, Stroock and Lavan. Moore noted that Wednesday’s case had much to do with the wording of the plaintiff’s original agreements, regardless of what may have happened in the 1980s.

“Contract interpretation is not governed by standard practice that develops after the contract is signed,” he said.

The law firms in Wednesday’s case — Johnson and Johnson, LLP; Kiesel and Larson, LLP; and Pearson, Simon, Warshaw and Penny — have experience with profit participation litigation. All three are currently involved in class-action suits against record companies over profits from digital downloads.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Saturday Fiction

    'Saturday Fiction' Yanked From China's Golden Rooster Film Festival on Eve of Debut

    Just a day before its scheduled China debut, director Lou Ye’s latest film, “Saturday Fiction,” has been pulled from its slot as the opener of the mainland’s Golden Rooster Film Festival because of unspecified “internal production problems,” according to Chinese film website Mtime. Speculation has been spreading online that it will also be yanked from [...]

  • DeVon Franklin

    DeVon Franklin Signs First-Look Deal at Paramount Pictures

    DeVon Franklin has signed a first-look producing deal at Paramount Pictures. Under his Franklin Entertainment banner, Franklin previously produced inspirational and faith-based films, including this year’s “Breakthrough,” starring Chrissy Metz, as well as “Miracles From Heaven,” with Jennifer Garner and Queen Latifah, and the animated film “The Star,” toplined by Zachary Levi, Gina Rodriguez, Oprah [...]

  • Harriet Movie BTS

    'Harriet' Costume Designer Paul Tazewell on How He Crafted Harriet Tubman's Look

    For many, Harriet Tubman’s journey is one we’re taught about in school. We know she’s a heroine, an abolitionist who led slaves to their freedom via the underground railroad. Unless you’ve read the books by Kate Clifford Larson or Beverly Lowry, “We didn’t receive the whole story,” says costume designer Paul Tazewell. Until now. Kasi [...]

  • Viacom HQ LA

    ViacomCBS Sets HR and Inclusion Chiefs

    ViacomCBS has named corporate heads of HR and inclusion as the companies prepare for the merger that is set to close early next month. The soon-to-combine Viacom and CBS have tapped Nielsen alum Nancy Phillips to serve as exec VP and chief people officer. Viacom alum Marva Smalls will serve as global head of inclusion, [...]

  • Idris Elba Netflix 'Turn Up Charlie'

    Idris Elba to Star in 'The Harder They Fall' for Netflix

    Idris Elba will star alongside Jonathan Majors in “The Harder They Fall,” a Netflix movie that will be produced by Jay-Z. The film follows outlaw Nat Love (Majors), who discovers that the man (Elba) who killed his parents two decades ago is being released from prison and decides to reunite with his gang to track [...]

  • Laverne Cox Charlie's Angels

    How Laverne Cox Landed a Cameo in Elizabeth Banks' 'Charlie’s Angels'

    Laverne Cox officially earned her wings, scoring a role in Sony’s “Charlie’s Angels.” But she revealed her cameo almost didn’t happen. When the Emmy-nominee heard that Elizabeth Banks was directing the film, the longtime fan of the franchise (and of Banks herself) reached out about being part of the project. Cox had previously worked with [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content