×

VFX Industry Rescue Could Come From WTO Rules

U.S. f/x industry could benefit from existing anti-subsidy duties

Foreign subsidies on visual-effects work may be enough to trigger World Trade Organization “anti-subsidy duty” rules that would impose a tariff on those vfx when they’re imported into the U.S., according to a panel presentation at the Siggraph conference on Thursday.

Lawyer David A. Yocis of  Picard Kentz & Rowe of Washington, D.C., presented the findings of a feasibility study looking at the idea of using WTO rules to end or limit the foreign subsidies that have decimated the visual effects business in California and turned its much of its workforce into global nomads. Yocis said that if the domestic vfx industry chooses to pursue such a remedy, the best route is the use of “countervailing duties,” or CVDs.

WTO rules permit member governments to impose those duties when they find that foreign governments have subsidized their own producers and caused injury or threaten to injure domestic producers. Such injury can include loss of jobs.

Subsidies for vfx work have built up f/x companies in the U.K., Canada, Australia and New Zealand, among other territories, while their U.S. counterparts have struggled. The dutiess would counteract the benefit of those subsidies for producers, reducing their incentive to take work outside the U.S.

However, Yocis warned the law “was not designed for a digital world” and would be hard to use. It would cost the industry hundreds of thousands of dollars, perhaps millions, in legal fees, he said, and would not provide a long-term, comprehensive solution to the problem of subsidies.

But, he said, “We think that if you want to try to take a trade law approach, this is the way to do it. This could change the incentives … and could really open the door to working out some more comprehensive arrangement going forward.”

“The most important question is ‘Does the law even apply? Does it apply to digital products made overseas, where the value is not in the digital file but to the copyright attached to it?’ That’s something that has never come up before,” Yocis said. “We think the answer is yes.”

The advantage of the CVD approach, he said, is that if the government conducts an investigation and finds that the foreign subsidies injure the domestic vfx industry, the duties are triggered automatically. The  laws and treaties for the duties are already in place; no new act of Congress would be needed. Collecting the duty might prove difficult, he said, “But the thing to remember is that if you get to that point, you’ve succeeded. The goal isn’t to have a tax to be collected, it’s to change behavior.”

The American vfx industry would have to present a united front to the government in favor of an investigation and countervailing duties. However, such a duty would almost surely increase the cost of production, since studios and producers would lose the benefit of those vfx subsidies. Therefore the AMPTP and its member companies would likely lobby against such an effort.

Moreover, two major American vfx companies are owned by studios: Sony Pictures Imageworks and Industrial Light & Magic (Disney). That wouldn’t doom the effort, however, Yocis noted. ” If someone in the U.S. industry is opposing it because they’re getting the subsidy and benefiting from it in some way, the government has the option to disregard that.”

And those corporations might find some dissension in their own ranks if they oppose a CVD investigation. An exec from one of those studio-owned vfx companies told Variety after the meeting “I wouldn’t oppose that.”

Read the full feasibility study here.

Popular on Variety

More Biz

  • Two bull statues are displayed outside

    Alibaba Delays Hong Kong Share Listing (Report)

    Against a background of political tension in Hong Kong, Chinese tech and entertainment giant Alibaba is reported to have delayed its planned share listing in the Asian financial capital. Reuters cited two unnamed sources in a report Wednesday on the decision to postpone. One said that the delay was approved at a board meeting the [...]

  • Mass Appeal and Universal Launch Hip-Hop

    Nas, Mass Appeal and Universal Music Launch Hip-Hop Label in India, Sign Divine

    Mass Appeal and Universal Music Group today announced the launch of Mass Appeal India – a new label dedicated to amplifying India’s burgeoning hip-hop culture on a global scale. The new label’s operations will be based Universal Music India’s headquarters in Mumbai and will function as a multi-channel partnership between the two companies. According to the announcement, Mass Appeal India will sign and [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein, center, arrives to court

    Weinstein's Attorneys Seek to Move Trial to Long Island or Albany

    Harvey Weinstein’s attorneys want his rape trial moved to Long Island or Albany, citing the “circus-like atmosphere” surrounding the courthouse in Manhattan. Weinstein is set to go on trial on Sept. 9 on five charges of rape and sexual assault. The disgraced producer faces a potential life term if convicted. In a motion to the [...]

  • Edge, left, Adam Clayton, and Bono

    New York’s PlayStation Theater to Close (EXCLUSIVE)

    New York’s PlayStation Theater, a 2,100-capacity venue located in Times Square and operated by Bowery Presents, will close at the end of 2019, a source close to the situation tells Variety. The venue will close with a New Year’s series of shows from the Disco Biscuits. The theater, which is located two stories beneath the [...]

  • Courtesy of Earwolf

    How Lauren Lapkus Tossed the Script and Created a Podcasting Hit

    Lauren Lapkus has tossed the script on what makes most podcasts a hit. At a time when many of the most downloaded shows are true crime investigations or celebrity interviews, she’s doing something entirely different on each episode of “With Special Guest Lauren Lapkus.” Each hour-long installment is a free-wheeling, completely improvised ride. One show [...]

  • WWE NXT

    WWE's 'NXT' Moves to USA Network as Wrestling Competition Heats Up

    WWE has struck a deal to move its “NXT” franchise focusing on rising stars to USA Network starting next month. “NXT” will shift to USA from the WWE Network subscription streaming service as of Sept. 18. The deal comes as USA is about to lose WWE’s “SmackDown” showcase to Fox starting in October. USA is [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content