Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Dispute Over ‘Raging Bull’

The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.”

The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the way that lower courts dismissed Paula Petrella’s case against MGM. A district court and the 9th Circuit argued that she waited too long to bring the case — something called the doctrine of laches — but Petrella’s legal team argued that other circuits have rendered opposite judgments of whether such reasoning should apply.

The case has implications for entertainment because laches has been a way for studios to have certain claims of copyright ownership easily dismissed, particularly in the 9th Circuit which covers western states.

“If this laches defense is upheld, it is a very formidable defense that the studios would have to hoist if someone came out of the word work, so to speak,” said Jonathan B. Sokol, partner at Greenberg Glusker.

Petrella’s father, Frank “Peter” Petrella, worked in the early 60s and 70s on a book and two screenplays depicting LaMotta’s story, including projects called “The Raging Bull.” The elder Petrella died in 1981, but Paula Petrella in 1991 renewed the copyright to his 1963 screenplay. Yet she did not a copyright infringement claim against MGM until 2009. There is a three-year statute of limitations on copyright infringement claims, but lower courts dismissed the case, supporting the laches defense. At the heart of such a defense is the notion that a plaintiff can’t wait until a property starts making money — in this case, homevideo — to file a claim against an entity that has invested years of money and effort in exploiting it.

Petrella’s legal team, led by Stephanos Bibas, argued that the Supreme Court should hear the case because other circuit courts have concluded that a defense of laches cannot bar a copyright claim brought within the statute of limitations.

MGM had no comment, as did Petrella and her attorney, Bibas.

More Biz

  • Richard Simmons

    Prosecutors Charge Private Eye With Illegal Spying on Richard Simmons

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.” The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the […]

  • Lionsgate General Counsel Left Amid Allegations

    Lionsgate General Counsel Left Amid Allegations of Sexual Abuse

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.” The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the […]

  • 'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New

    'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New York Television Festival

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.” The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the […]

  • Radiohead Coachella

    Radiohead Demands Answers in Drum Technician's Death

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.” The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the […]

  • Kevin Durant LeBron James

    Kevin Durant Praises LeBron James' Lakers Move

    The Supreme Court on Tuesday said that it would hear a case involving the rights to “Raging Bull.” The case before the high court — brought by the daughter of one of Jake LaMotta’s friends and co-authors — isn’t about who owns the rights to the acclaimed story. Instead, it is a challenge to the […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content