×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Next Leap for the Man of Steel: Who Owns Rights to Ads and Superboy?

DC Comics, creators' heirs expand rights dispute to include promotional material created before debut of Action Comics No. 1.

Depending on whether you believe DC Comics (a unit of Warner Bros.) or the heirs to the creators of Superman, their long battle over the rights to the Man of Steel is either nearing a conclusion or just entering another phase.

The former is apt to believe that everything is winding down, with recent court decisions making it clear that it controls the rights. The latter is appealing those decisions but also looking toward some unresolved questions about the rights.

U.S. District Judge Otis Wright is looking at who owns the rights to promotions that appeared in two separate publications weeks before the April 18, 1938 debut of Superman in Action Comics No. 1. The ad promotions — which appeared in More Fun Comics and Detective Comics — included a black-and-white image of the cover of Action Comics, in which the Man of Steel is using his superhuman strength to hold up a vehicle. At least technically, this was the first published appearance of Superman, not Action Comics.

When the heirs to Superman co-creator Jerome Siegel in 1997 invoked a provision of the Copyright Act allowing them to reclaim rights to the character, a process known as copyright termination, they did not list the publications in which the ads appeared. DC Comics argued that because of this, it retained the ads, dangling the prospect that it still had a hold on some of the early rights. U.S. District Judge Stephen Larson ruled in 2008 that the Siegels had recaptured the rights to Action Comics No. 1 and other key early Superman works, but he said the ads were not included.

So last year, Siegel’s daughter, Laura Siegel Larson, filed a termination notice for the ads. Not surprisingly, DC Comics said that it owns them, and will still own them after termination date next year. They rely on a 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision from January that largely reversed Larson’s decision, ruling that even though the Siegels filed notices of termination for the Superman works in 1997, they signed a binding agreement in 2001that gave DC Comics the rights. DC says that the 2001 agreement are broad grants that cover the ads, as well as rights to Superboy, the rights to which are the subject of a related dispute.

In recently filed court documents, the attorney for the Siegel heirs, Marc Toberoff, suggests that DC Comics is reversing its logic over the ownership of the ads. Where once DC argued that it had always owned the rights to the ads, it is now arguing that the Siegels signed away rights to them in the 2001 agreement.

For its part, DC argues that the Siegels took advantage of their termination right in 1997 and “made a deal with DC in 2001,” but that Siegel’s daughter “cannot re-trade on it now.” The company claims that even though she filed a termination notice for the ads last year, the 2001 agreement still covers those works. Its attorney, Daniel Petrocelli, argues that case law allows for an agreement that “revokes and replaces” all prior copyright grants and, in doing so, bars future termination claims. But Toberoff says that the 2001 agreement doesn’t “expressly” revoke and replace those rights.

The ads depict a person with extraordinary strength who wears a black-and-white leotard and a cape, with the “S’ logo only vaguely visible, so there’s some question as to what, if anything, could be done with the rights. The litigation over the ads is not about doing anything with a limited version of the character, but for the leverage that may ultimately lead to some kind of final resolution.

More Biz

  • Stephen Colbert Julia Louis-Dreyfus

    Julia Louis-Dreyfus Talks 'Seinfeld,' 'Sexist' Environment at 'SNL' in Q&A With Stephen Colbert

    Stephen Colbert and Julia Louis-Dreyfus swapped stories about “Saturday Night Live,” Northwestern University, “Seinfeld” and the possibility of running for office during a Q&A held Saturday as part of Montclair Film Festival’s annual “Evening with Stephen Colbert” fundraiser. Colbert, a Montclair resident, has long been a booster of the festival, which is going into its [...]

  • 2019 Kennedy Center Honoree singer Linda

    Linda Ronstadt to Mike Pompeo: Stop 'Enabling' Donald Trump

    WASHINGTON, D.C. — Linda Ronstadt, one of this year’s Kennedy Center Honorees, had sharp words for Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Saturday night during a State Department reception for the Kennedy Center kudos. Ronstadt and Pompeo faced off in the U.S. State Department’s ornate diplomatic greeting rooms at the traditional event that precedes Sunday’s [...]

  • pharrell brain child show

    'Blurred Lines' Flares Up Again - Marvin Gaye Family Claims Pharrell Perjured Himself

    Like a zombie that just won’t stay dead, the “Blurred Lines” case keeps coming back. While the 2015 verdict, in which Pharrell Williams, Robin Thicke and the song’s publisher were ordered to pay nearly $5 million to Marvin Gaye’s family for infringing upon the late singer’s 1977 hit “Got to Give It Up,” was basically [...]

  • WGA Agency Packaging Fight Placeholder Writer

    WGA-Agency Showdown: Role of Showrunners at Heart of Legal Arguments

    The Los Angeles courtroom of U.S. District Judge Andre Birotte was packed with well-dressed lawyers on Friday morning, eager to watch a high-stakes brawl between Hollywood’s largest talent agencies and the Writers Guild of America. Birotte allowed only four lawyers from each side to sit at each table, leaving the vast majority of the attorneys [...]

  • 700700 + Ted Turner Dedication. December

    Ted Turner Tributes Established With WarnerMedia Gift to University of Georgia

    WarnerMedia has established a scholarship, internship program and exhibition hall at the University of Georgia to be named after maverick media mogul Ted Turner. The company has gifted $550,000 to the university to create the Ted Turner Scholarship Fund, for students attending the school’s Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication, which is also the [...]

  • WGA Agents Contract Tug of War

    Judge Leans Toward Agencies' Position in Writers Guild Antitrust Suit

    A federal judge indicated on Friday that he will allow the three major agencies to pursue their antitrust lawsuit against the Writers Guild of America. The WGA has urged U.S. District Judge Andre Birotte to throw out the suit, arguing that its actions in its ongoing battle with the agencies are protected under antitrust law. [...]

  • Keli LeeStep Up Women Network 9th

    Keli Lee Exits ABC Studios International as Disney Considers Division's Fate (EXCLUSIVE)

    ABC veteran Keli Lee has left the international arm of ABC Studios as Disney considers the future of the London-based content unit, Variety has learned. Sources said Disney has told the creative community that there “has been a re-evaluation of ABC Studios International” and that it is re-assessing “the creative direction” of the business. There [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content