×

Sony Rejects Third Point Offer to Spin Off Entertainment Assets

Sony has rejected Third Point’s proposal that it spinoff as much as 20% of its studio and other entertainment assets, saying that a “rights or public offering is not consistent with the company’s strategy for achieving sustained growth in profitability and shareholder value.”

Sony CEO Kazuo Hirai said in a four-page letter to Third Point’s Daniel Loeb that its Board of Directors “unanimously concluded that continuing to own 100% of our entertainment business is the best path forward and is integral to Sony’s strategy.”

Addressing concerns of Loeb that the performance of the entertainment assets are obscured by the overall company results, Sony said that it would increase disclosure of its entertainment business holdings, and said that it was in the midst of boosting profits in its film division. But he said that one of the rationales for spinning off the unit — to raise capital — could be done in other ways.

Hirai said that the additional disclosures would be made in the second quarter of its current fiscal year, and would be for certain categories within Sony Pictures and Sony Music, along with information so investors to calculate adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, or EBITDA.

Reports surfaced last week that Sony was poised to reject Loeb’s proposal.

Loeb personally delivered a letter to Hirai in May, calling for such a spinoff as a way of boosting transparency, improving performance and margins in the entertainment division. Last week, Loeb stepped up his criticisms of Sony Pictures Entertainment chairman and CEO Michael Lynton and co-chairman Amy Pascal, calling into question their choices of recent box office misfires “After Earth” and “White House Down,” and calling the studio itself “underexposed, undervalued and underperforming.”

A spokeswoman for Third Point did not immediately respond to a request for comment. With a reputation as an activist investor, Loeb has been initially turned back by boards of companies like Yahoo, only to press forward and, in the case of Yahoo, succeed in getting the company to overhaul their operations. Third Point owns almost 7% of Sony stock.

That Sony even considered the proposal, rather than rejecting it out of hand, was viewed by some analysts as a sign of the changing business culture in Tokyo, albeit there is not the same tradition of brash, activist investors as there is in the United States.

In his letter, Hirai wrote that “many of your observations regarding our entertainment businesses, and in particular [Sony Pictures], are not consistent with the businesses that I know.”

The rejection of Third Point’s proposal is not a huge surprise, even if it proved unsettling to the studio. In an interview with Deadline on Friday, actor George Clooney blasted Loeb as “dangerous to our industry” because of his bottom line approach to a creative and cyclical business. (Third Point is a minority stakeholder in Variety Media, along with majority owner Penske Media Corporation, which also owns Deadline.)

In his letter, Hirai wrote that Sony Pictures and Sony Music “are critical elements of our strategy and fundamental drivers of Sony’s growth for the future. We expect that our strategy will result in increasing profitability through investing in high-growth, high-margin businesses, particularly in television production and international networks.” He cited investments in its global television business and the growth of international cable networks, more than doubling in revenue over the past five years.

Loeb had focused particular criticism on the film studio, claiming that it was not achieving the margins of other studios, and even said that if entertainment assets “achieved peer margins,” EBITDA would “increase nearly $800 million to just over $2 billion.”

Hirai, however, said that they were “very focused on increasing margins” in its feature division, and that they were “reducing costs.”

“While we believe our theatrical marketing costs have been and continue to be in line with our competitors, and that our margins are generally comparable to some other major studios, we recognize that our margins should be higher,” Hirai wrote. He cited efforts to “tighten controls and reduce costs,” and said that they have deployed “an even more exacting ‘green light’ process for film production, focusing more intensively on overall slate profitability as well as per film returns-on-investment.”

He also defended the compensation structure in the movie and music divisions, saying that it is linked to financial performance. Another argument made by Third Point was that a spinoff would free up capital, allowing Sony to invest in other businesses. But Hirai said that “should we require capital, or in the event of unanticipated events, our priority would be to raise it without selling a portion of an asset fundamental to our growth strategy, and without unnecessarily burdening Sony’s ability to execute our business strategy for both entertainment and electronics.”

Loeb also was critical of Sony for not taking greater advantage of synergies across divisions, but Hirai wrote that collaboration across divisions was increasing, and “a rights or public offering would put obstacles in our strategic path, creating the need for otherwise unnecessary and burdensome arm’s length intercompany relationships and for consideration of minority shareholder rights, thereby limiting our control and strategic flexibility.”

A copy of Hirai’s letter is here.

More Biz

  • Picture by Simon Wilkinson/SWpix.com 22/01/2020 -

    Tartikoff Honorees Call for Commitment to Diversity and Protection of Press Freedom

    MIAMI — Jeff Zucker didn’t mince words. “Nothing is as important than what I’m doing now,” the CNN Worldwide chief said of his long career in media as he was feted Wednesday night as one of five Brandon Tartikoff Award honorees. Zucker, president of CNN Worldwide and chairman of WarnerMedia News and Sports, sounded the [...]

  • How Deborah Dugan Sealed Her Fate

    How Deborah Dugan Sealed Her Fate at the Recording Academy

    Deborah Dugan’s ouster from the top job at the Recording Academy, just ten days before the Grammy Awards, was a shock to nearly everyone not directly involved in the decision. But according to multiple sources and the bombshell complaint her attorneys filed on Tuesday, she and the Academy establishment were working at cross purposes almost [...]

  • The Crown Season 3 Oliva Colman

    Record Intl. Growth Sees Netflix Beat Q4 Earnings Forecast

    Fast growth in international markets, contrasting with only sluggish subscriber gains in North America, was a major factor behind streaming giant Netflix’s better than forecast growth in the last quarter of 2019. The company is set on keeping up that international momentum. Globally Netflix added 8.76 million new customers in the three months to December [...]

  • Harvey WeinsteinHarvey Weinstein court hearing, New

    Weinstein Trial: Everything We Know About the Three Supporting Witnesses

    The prosecution laid out its rape case against Harvey Weinstein on Wednesday morning, spelling out the allegations in detail for the first time. In her opening argument, Assistant District Attorney Meghan Hast also described the testimony of three “prior bad acts” witnesses. Such testimony was critical in the prosecution of comedian Bill Cosby, and it [...]

  • Donna Rotunno, Harvey WeinsteinHarvey Weinstein court

    Harvey Weinstein's Defense Focuses on Emails in Bid to Discredit Accusers

    Harvey Weinstein’s defense attorney showed jurors friendly emails between their client and his accusers in an opening statement on Wednesday, arguing that the accusers are trying to “have it both ways.” Attorney Damon Cheronis asked the jury to rely on their “God-given New York City common sense,” and to find that the women had consensual [...]

  • Mark Cuban Andrew Wallenstein Variety CES

    Listen: Mark Cuban Is Bullish on AI, 5G, TikTok and ... Movie Theaters!?

    As a serial entrepreneur with a taste for tech, Mark Cuban has built a multibillion-dollar career by trusting his well-developed instincts. So when he says it’s time to pay attention to any particular innovation, it’s best to listen up. On the latest episode of the “Strictly Business” podcast, recorded at CES earlier this month in [...]

  • Harvey WeinsteinHarvey Weinstein court hearing, New

    Harvey Weinstein Was a 'Predator and a Rapist,' D.A. Tells Jurors

    A prosecutor told jurors on Wednesday that Harvey Weinstein wielded his immense power in Hollywood to rape vulnerable young women and then to keep them silent. Assistant District Attorney Meghan Hast gave jurors a vivid recounting of multiple sexual assaults, including the story of Jessica Mann, a witness who has not previously been identified. She [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content