You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

In Piracy War, Google Seen as Unwilling Ally

Media firms gripe that the search engine remains rife with illicit links

Google styles itself as the apolitical digital librarian of the Internet age — simply connecting people to information they’re seeking. But owners of intellectual property say the search leader isn’t doing enough to curb the growing hordes of pirates stealing their content.

Last August, Google disclosed a change in how its search engine would operate: Sites with a high number of copyright-removal complaints would be ranked lower than those with fewer grievances against them. Theoretically, that would make piracy websites harder to find.

Hollywood and other content industries cautiously cheered the Internet giant’s plan, hopeful that a shift in the way billions of people worldwide find material online would help turn the tide in the sea of illegal activity.

SEE MORE: View All Stories from Our Special Report on Google

But nearly a year later, virtually nothing has changed, according to execs in the media biz — with the same repeat infringers still showing up high in Google’s results.

Yet other companies that intersect with what might be termed “the pirate economy” have made tangible advances in the past year toward starving rogue websites, said Rick Cotton, NBCUniversal’s exec VP and general counsel. Those include payment processors, ad networks and Internet service providers.

By comparison, Google hasn’t made the same kind of progress on search. “The search sector is the furthest behind by far” in addressing piracy, Cotton said. “For legitimate sites to flourish, the ecosystem has to make those easier to find than illegitimate content.”

SEE MORE: Google’s Clout on Capitol Hill Concerns Hollywood

The Motion Picture Assn. of America similarly said it’s seen very little meaningful difference in Google’s search results, with pirate sites generating new links once those flagged as illegal are removed. “Google’s domination of the search market means that consumers need to be able to rely on it to return legitimate results,” a spokeswoman said.

But Google says that completely blocking sites from its index — even those known to traffic in illegal content, like the Pirate Bay or isoHunt — is not the answer to piracy. Even for sites with a large number of removal requests, links to alleged illegal content account for less than 1% of the total pages, the company claims. Blacklisting them would punish them for only a small amount of piracy.

In addition, Google maintains that copyright owners already have powers nobody else is afforded: effectively a lineitem veto removing any search result they don’t like. The company says it responds in less than eight hours to those takedown requests. Moreover, for “clean” searches (that is, queries that don’t intentionally seek out pirated content with verbiage that includes the words “watch free”), Google says the demotion program is in fact working as advertised.

Google argues that it’s attacking piracy where it counts — cutting off advertising money to such sites. The company says its DoubleClick ad network unit has a policy of shunning rogue operators.

Finally, Google says it’s helping rights-holders with YouTube’s Content ID system, which lets content owners opt to place ads against user-uploaded material instead of blocking it.

“Google has taken a leadership role in partnering with the industry to cut off the flow of money to piracy sites, and has invested heavily in copyright tools for content owners,” the company said in a statement. “In addition, Google’s growing partnerships and distribution deals with the content industry benefit both creators and users, and generate hundreds of millions of dollars for the industry each year.”

None of that, however, mollifies entertainment industry execs who want to see Google take a forceful stand on search technology in eliminating pirates.

“Plainly, Google can and should develop and implement stronger filters,” said Miles Feldman, an IP attorney with Raines Feldman, whose clients include Hollywood studios.

While he acknowledged that there appear to have been incremental improvements in Google searches for popular media, Feldman said the difference is “not nearly enough.”

Related Stories: Special Report on Google

More Biz

  • Plume of black smoke rising from

    Lawsuit Expected Next Week in Response to Universal Music Fire

    A Los Angeles law firm representing several Universal Music recording artists affected by the 2008 fire that destroyed a huge number of master recordings is expected to file a lawsuit as early as next week. King told Variety that he expects to sue for negligence and other torts. He declined to identify his clients, saying [...]

  • Nicholas Sparks

    Nicholas Sparks Responds as LGBT Discrimination Claim Resurfaces

    Nicholas Sparks, the prolific author of romance novels, is facing renewed allegations that he discriminated against gay students at his Christian school in North Carolina. The allegations were first leveled by Saul Benjamin, the former headmaster of the Epiphany School of Global Studies, in a wrongful termination suit he filed in 2014. Benjamin’s suit alleged [...]

  • Tyler the Creator and DJ Khaled

    Inside the DJ Khaled-Tyler, the Creator Chart Battle

    The controversy surrounding the recent chart battle between DJ Khaled and Tyler the Creator — in which a bundle promoting Khaled’s album was disqualified from adding to its sales tally for the May 24 Billboard 200 album chart, allowing the No. 1 spot to go to Tyler’s “Igor” — has been a first-class problem for [...]

  • Cuba Gooding Jr. Diversity

    Cuba Gooding Jr. Charged with Misdemeanor Forcible Touching

    Actor Cuba Gooding, Jr., has been charged with a misdemeanor count of forcible touching following an incident at a nightclub, the New York Police Department said Thursday. Gooding turned himself in to NYPD detectives on Thursday, surrounded by a throng of media. Later in the day, he was arraigned in front of Judge Herb Moses. [...]

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    CAA Challenges Writers Guild of America's Legal Standing in Packaging Fee Lawsuit

    CAA has challenged the Writers Guild of America’s legal standing for bringing forth the lawsuit against Hollywood’s four largest talent agencies over the issue of packaging fees. CAA’s latest legal response to the suit filed by the WGA in Los Angeles Superior Court in April asserts that the guild does not have the right to [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content