You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Major Crimes

For viewers, the real mystery in "Major Crimes" is why this spinoff of "The Closer" -- which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass -- even warrants a new name.

With:
Capt. Sharon Raydor - Mary McDonnell
Lt. Provenza - G.W. Bailey
Lt. Andy Flynn - Tony Denison
Lt. Mike Tao - Michael Paul Chan
Det. Julio Sanchez - Raymond Cruz
Buzz Watson - Philip P. Keene
Det. Amy Sykes - Kearran Giovanni
Rusty Beck - Graham Patrick Martin
With: Robert Gossett, Jon Tenney.

For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, there’s barely a dime’s worth of difference between them, down to the holdover cast and stylistic similarities. On past copshows (think “Law & Order”), people left and life went on. Here, it’s really just serving old wine with a new label.

Creator James Duff has said “Major Crimes” will be “very much its own show,” which is like saying “Transformers 2” was its own movie.

Granted, McDonnell’s understated, schoolmarmish approach to the role of Capt. Raydor, who thanks to Dep. Chief Brenda Lee Johnson’s exit and department politics winds up taking over the Major Crimes Unit, proves to be an acquired taste. Frequently speaking in hushed tones, she’s a source of calm amid the day’s crisis, yes, but also risks lulling viewers into a kind of trance.

Most of the fireworks, rather, come from her holdover squad, many of whom do not take kindly to the shift in stewardship, particularly the crusty Lt. Provenza (G.W. Bailey), who snarls his disapproval at new-fangled methods of doing things during every available opportunity.

Raydor responds to this brazen insubordination with detachment, to the point where McDonnell at times seems to be channeling her character from “Battlestar Galactica,” who had the excuse of being gravely ill.

The procedural aspects of these shows is such that even Brenda spends most of her swan-song working on finding a serial killer, and Raydor exposes dollops of character as she works a grocery-store robbery and shooting during the premiere, with a murdered personal trainer in the second episode. She also picks up a surly teenager (Graham Patrick Martin) who needs to stay with her while hoping to find his missing mom, which is every bit as much fun as that sounds.

In short, the business questions related to “Major Crimes” (starting with whatever financial considerations went into tackling Sedgwick’s departure by rebooting in this fashion) are generally more interesting than the show itself.

Those who enjoyed “The Closer” will still find something, if probably not as much, to like about this closer, too. Or really, “Closer 2.”

Major Crimes

TNT, Mon. Aug. 13, 10 p.m.

Production: Filmed in Los Angeles by the Shephard/Robin Co., in association with Warner Bros. Television. Executive producers, James Duff, Greer Shephard, Michael M. Robin, Rick Wallace; director, Robin; writer, Duff.

Crew: Camera, David Harp; production designer, Paul Eads; editor, Butch Wertman; music, Jimmy Levine; casting, Bruce H. Newberg. 60 MIN.

Cast: Capt. Sharon Raydor - Mary McDonnell
Lt. Provenza - G.W. Bailey
Lt. Andy Flynn - Tony Denison
Lt. Mike Tao - Michael Paul Chan
Det. Julio Sanchez - Raymond Cruz
Buzz Watson - Philip P. Keene
Det. Amy Sykes - Kearran Giovanni
Rusty Beck - Graham Patrick Martin
With: Robert Gossett, Jon Tenney.

More TV

  • Jimmy Fallon Hosting 2016 Golden Globes

    NBC Aims to Bolster 'Tonight Show' Producing Team With Veteran Executive

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • MANIFEST -- "Turbulence" Episode 103 --

    Live+7 Ratings for Week of Oct. 8: 'Manifest' Doubles In Week 3

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • Michael Kelly and Robin Wright'House of

    'House of Cards': Robin Wright on Returning to Work Without Kevin Spacey

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon - The

    'Walking Dead' Ratings Hold Mostly Steady, Still Slips to Another Low

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • Netflix Elite season 1

    Netflix's 'Elite' Subverts Teen Drama Tropes With Style

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • Bradley Whitford

    Bradley Whitford to Produce Church Choir Comedy in the Works at NBC

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

  • ‘Teddy Pendergrass - If You Don't Know

    'Teddy Pendergrass - If You Don't Know Me' Lands at BBC, Showtime, Sky (EXCLUSIVE)

    For viewers, the real mystery in “Major Crimes” is why this spinoff of “The Closer” — which officially closes its books leading into the debut, in what amounts to a smooth baton pass — even warrants a new name. Other than the permanent addition of Mary McDonnell as a replacement for Kyra Sedgwick’s Emmy-winning crime-solver, […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content