×

Arrow

Although the title is a little less overtly colorful than its comicbook origins would imply, "Arrow" is really just a surrogate for a TV version of another superhero -- namely, Batman.

With:
Oliver Queen - Stephen Amell
Tommy - Colin Donnelll
Laurel Lance - Katie Cassidyl
John Diggle - David Ramseyl
Thea Queen - Willa Hollandl
Moira Queen - Susanna Thompsonl
Det. Quentin Lance - Paul Blackthorne

Although the title is a little less overtly colorful than its comicbook origins would imply, “Arrow” is really just a surrogate for a TV version of another superhero — namely, Batman. A brooding billionaire vigilante with a bad attitude, lawyer girlfriend and dazzling set of toys, this CW pilot bears only a marginal resemblance to the incarnation of DC Comics’ Green Arrow featured in “Smallville,” so much so that the temptation is to say, “lighten up.” As is, the handsome but rather stiff premiere plays like a pale shade of Green.

Tinkering with the superhero’s origin in what amounts to a “Castaway” riff, billionaire Oliver Queen (Stephen Amell of “Private Practice” and “Hung”) is vacationing on a yacht with his father (Jamey Sheridan) when a terrible storm hits, sinking the boat. Thanks largely to dad’s noble sacrifice, Oliver survives by making it to an island, where his struggle against nature hones his body and teaches him a thing or two about handling a bow. (To be fair, at least this hero carried a quiver before “Hunger Games” made it such a fashionable accessory.)

Eventually Oliver is rescued, but a lot has changed back home in the time he’s been absent. For starters, his mom (Susanna Thompson) appears to have a new gentlemen friend, and one-time girlfriend Laurel (Katie Cassidy), the aforementioned lawyer, can’t forgive him for having been frolicking with her sister, who died in the accident.

Oliver also discovers all is not well in Gotham — oops, make that Starling City — and decides to clean up the place, donning a green hood and heading into the night to thwart evil.

Produced by Greg Berlanti (who didn’t particularly buttress his comicbook cred with the theatrical version of another emerald DC hero, Green Lantern), the action is liberal and reasonably gritty, and Amell — out of costume — certainly has the kind of abs to make one you-know-what with envy.

Still, it’s hard to escape a nagging sense that this take on Green Arrow is really Dark Knight lite, vulnerable to the uphill climb facing all second-tier comicbook characters when they brave the battle for mainstream appeal.

“Arrow” certainly looks polished (having David Nutter direct a pilot virtually insures that), but there’s only so much action an hourlong drama can afford, and the characters necessary to sustain the series are, initially, strictly two-dimensional, even with the island as a go-to flashback.

Ratings expectations won’t be unreasonably high, which is an advantage. Still, based on the pilot with which CW has fired “Arrow” into the air, barring sharper execution, where it lands, most need not care.

Arrow

CW, Wed. Oct. 10, 8 p.m.

Production: Filmed in Vancouver by Berlanti Prods. in association with Warner Bros. Television. Executive producers, Greg Berlanti, Marc Guggenheim, Andrew Kreisberg, David Nutter; co-executive producer, Melissa Kellner Berman; director, Nutter; writers, Kreisberg, Guggenheim; story, Berlanti, Guggenheim. 60 MIN.

Cast: Oliver Queen - Stephen Amell
Tommy - Colin Donnelll
Laurel Lance - Katie Cassidyl
John Diggle - David Ramseyl
Thea Queen - Willa Hollandl
Moira Queen - Susanna Thompsonl
Det. Quentin Lance - Paul BlackthorneWith: Jamey Sheridan.

More TV

  • SAG-AFTRA HQ

    SAG-AFTRA Health Plan Cuts Premiums by 50% Due to Coronavirus Crisis

    The SAG-AFTRA Health Plan has cut 50% from the cost of premiums for the second quarter in response to the coronavirus crisis. SAG-AFTRA members were notified of the reduction on Wednesday via a message from SAG-AFTRA president Gabrielle Carteris and national executive director David White. They said the cuts would cover participants who had been [...]

  • Adam Schlesinger

    Tom Hanks, Rachel Bloom, Stephen Colbert, Stephen King Pay Tribute to Adam Schlesinger

    Whether it was the snarky but sincere pop of Fountains of Wayne and Ivy, the ‘60s retro of Tom Hanks’ “That Thing You Do!” or the Broadway fare of “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” Adam Schlesinger’s music reached far beyond his public profile. The master songwriter passed away Wednesday morning at the age of 52 from complications related [...]

  • Aline Brosh Mckenna Adam Schlesinger

    'Crazy Ex-Girlfriend' Co-Creator Aline Brosh McKenna Pays Touching Tribute to Adam Schlesinger

    “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend” co-creator Aline Brosh McKenna paid a touching tribute to Adam Schlesinger on Twitter after the Emmy-winning songwriter and singer died Wednesday from coronavirus complications. Brosh McKenna took to the social media platform to fondly recall a moment from the writer’s room, “One day, when Adam, Rachel (Bloom) and Jack (Dolgen) were working, we [...]

  • Rick and Morty HBO Max

    Adult Swim Announces 'Rick and Morty' Season 4 Return Date

    Adult Swim has announced that the second half of Season 4 of “Rick and Morty” will premiere on May 3 at 11:30 p.m. The announcement was made today alongside a new trailer for the season’s remaining five episodes. Set to the upbeat chant of Thin Lizzy’s “The Boys Are Back in Town,” the footage offers [...]

  • Jason Kilar

    New WarnerMedia CEO Jason Kilar on His Vision for the Future of Media

    By tapping Jason Kilar — the co-founder of Hulu and an Amazon veteran — to be its new CEO, AT&T-owned WarnerMedia is sending a signal that its future will be streamed. In a conversation with Variety just hours after the announcement, Kilar himself says as much. Kilar has known AT&T COO and current WarnerMedia CEO [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content