Judges scrutinize Aereo as nets press case

Appeals panel hears arguments in challenge to remote retransmission

A panel of a federal appellate court has expressed skepticism about the legal standing of Aereo, the startup service that streams broadcast signals to subscribers. The major networks have challenged Aereo’s right to offer its service in two separate lawsuits.

At a hearing before a panel of the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals in New York. the networks urged the judges to reverse a lower-court ruling that has allowed Aereo to continue service, even though the broadcasters argue that the company infringes on its right to public performance.

Aereo argues that its service — in which subscribers receive broadcast signals via a farm of thousands of dime-seized antennas assigned to each customer — is merely doing remotely what consumers would otherwise do with their own equipment.

“Is there a legitimate business reason for having all these little itty-bitty antennas?” Judge Denny Chin asked.

“The reason is to comply with the copyright act,” R. David Hosp, attorney for Aereo, responded.

Another judge, John Gleeson, asked whether Aereo’s business model is akin to “constructing a business to avoid taxes.”

In July, U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan sided with Aereo when she refused the broadcasters’ motion to immediately halt the service, citing a 2008 2nd Circuit opinion that upheld Cablevision’s plan for a remote DVR service.

“Congress expressly and deliberately exempted ‘private’ performances from copyright protection,” Aereo argued in an appellate brief. “Further, consumers have a right of access to local, over-the-air broadcast television.”

They compared their service not just to the Cablevision remote DVR, but to Slingbox, which allows users to access DVR recordings over the Internet via mobile devices. Aereo noted that the networks challenge the legality of Slingbox, which is still in operation.

Aereo’s service, with backing from Barry Diller, allows subscribers to access the remote antenna to their TVs, computers and mobile devices. It provides a remote DVR, in which viewers can watch those live broadcasts yet still pause and forward.

Aereo’s streaming of signals threatens to undermine the networks’ ability to collect retransmission fees from cable and satellite services, and the broadcasters have successfully fought previous ventures that sought to capitalize on making free, over-the-air TV available to digital devices. But Aereo’s distinction is the use of individual antennas, which it maintains allows it to comply with public performance copyright law.

Networks argue that has little to do with Cablevision’s remote DVR.

Aereo “is a retransmission service, plain and simple,” Bruce Keller, attorney for the broadcasters, told the court. “Super Bowl comes in, Super Bowl goes out, plain and simple.”

In an appellate brief filed by ABC, NBC, CBS and others, the networks counter that Aereo still is retransmitting their signal to the public, violating the transmit clause of the law. Attorneys for the networks wrote that “Aereo’s service is unlike anything a consumer does in the home … and nothing like equipment a consumer can buy. Moreover, commercial retransmitters cannot stand in the shoes of individual consumers.”

More TV

  • New York Post

    Investigation Discovery Plots Two New York Post True-Crime Projects

    The New York Post often runs stories filled with grit, color and melodrama – just the kind of stuff that seems right for TV. Now some of those stories will find their way to a TV network. Investigation Discovery, the Discovery-owned true-crime TV network, will partner with News Corp.’s New York Post on two new [...]


    XFL, Bud Light Work To Shake Up Football Advertising

    The NFL has worked in recent years to take some commercials out of America’s favorite game. The XFL is experimenting with new ways to push them in. Anyone who watched the new league’s St. Louis BattleHawks triumph over the Dallas Renegades in its first week of official play might have noticed ads for Bud Light [...]

  • The Night Manager Network

    Endeavor Content Takes Minority Stake in 'Night Manager' Producer Ink Factory

    Endeavor Content has taken a minority stake in “The Night Manager” producer The Ink Factory. Under the deal, the “Killing Eve” and “Night Manager” distributor is to set up a bespoke development fund for Ink Factory. The pact will specifically target the U.S. market with high-end TV series developed out of Ink Factory’s U.S. outpost [...]

  • Kerry Washington Variety Cover Story

    With 'Little Fires Everywhere,' Kerry Washington Is Ready to Be Heard

    After years of being talked about, Kerry Washington is ready to steer the conversation herself. The 43-year-old actor and producer spent the better part of last decade playing the brilliant Olivia Pope on “Scandal,” Shonda Rhimes’ buzzy political drama that brought Washington into millions of homes. But as the series wound down, she kept a [...]

  • David Coulthard, Sunil Patel, Jake Humphrey

    Sony Pictures Television Takes Minority Stake in U.K. Sports Producer Whisper

    Sony Pictures Television has invested in U.K. sports-focused production outfit Whisper Group. Effective immediately, the business will replace Channel 4’s Indie Growth Fund as a minority stakeholder in Whisper, which has become a leading voice in sports entertainment. Founded by BAFTA-winning CEO Sunil Patel, broadcaster Jake Humphrey and F1 commentator David Coulthard, Whispers covers NFL, [...]

  • Kenan Thompson

    White House Correspondents Dinner Returns to Comedy With Kenan Thompson, Hasan Minhaj

    They’re trying to laugh again at the White House Correspondents Association annual dinner. Long-running “Saturday Night Live” cast member Kenan Thompson will host the event, while comedian Hasan Minhaj will be the featured entertainer for the evening, which has often served as a spotlight on relations between the media and the White House. Last year, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content