You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Appeals court rules for Touchstone in Sheridan case

Actress can still file complaint on Labor Code violation

A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed.

That is a key legal point that Touchstone has advanced in the aftermath, earlier this year, of a deadlocked jury trial in which Sheridan claimed that she was dropped from the show in retaliation for an incident in which the show’s creator, Marc Cherry, struck her on the set. He claimed that he was giving her direction for a scene.

But Sheridan still has another avenue to pursue her case. In a 10-page opinion issued on Thursday, the three-judge panel said Sheridan could still file an amended complaint alleging a Labor Code violation in the claim that Touchstone retaliated against her for complaining about unsafe working conditions.

As she set a date for a new trial, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Elizabeth Allen White rejected Touchstone’s motion for a “directed” verdict on the grounds that Sheridan could not be wrongfully terminated because the company simply decided not to renew her contract. The appellate court, however, disagreed with White’s assessment.

“In this instance, there is no termination of employment but, instead, an expiration of a fixed-term contract,” the appellate judges wrote in an opinion. “To hold otherwise would require the creation of a new tort of nonrenewal of fixed term employment contract in violation of public policy.”

More TV

  • Justin Theroux'Maniac' TV Show premiere, London,

    Justin Theroux Binge-Watched 'The Hills' While Making Netflix's 'Maniac'

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • Cary Fukunaga Maniac

    Cary Fukunaga Says He Wouldn't Return to Direct 'Maniac' Season 2

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • Kenan Thompson

    Kenan Thompson to Star in Single Dad Comedy Series in the Works at NBC

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • Jim Donnelly and Dan Shear

    Universal TV Promotes Comedy Execs Jim Donnelly, Dan Shear

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • 'American Horror Story's' Leslie Grossman on

    'American Horror Story's' Leslie Grossman Teases the 'Layers' of Her 'Apocalypse' Character

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • Mariska Hargitay Ice-T

    'Law & Order: SVU' Star Ice-T on #MeToo, Show's Relevance in 20th Season

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

  • Johnny Galecki First Time in Variety

    Johnny Galecki on Working With Harriet Nelson, Dick Butkus, Chevy Chase as a Child Actor

    A three-judge panel of the California state Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Touchstone Television’s contention that a verdict in the Nicollette Sheridan wrongful termination trial should be entered in its favor, concluding that the “Desperate Housewives” actress was not fired from the show but that her option simply was not renewed. That is […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content