You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Talk of TV’s golden age misses big picture

Quality shows abound, but so do Kardashians

Occasionally, a thought permeates the cultural ether and causes media elites — often belatedly — to simultaneously notice some trend or big idea.

A recent example involves acknowledging the burgeoning quality of television, and daring to broach whether TV has eclipsed its elder, bigger brother, movies, in cultural influence or quality.

So the New Yorker is sponsoring an event this week titled “Is Television the New Cinema?” And on the other coast, Zocalo Public Square is hosting an event this month asking “Is This the Golden Age of Television?”

Well, is it? And why do panels like these have to be framed in the form of a question, anyway?

Such queries have a tendency to simplify — make that terribly over-simplify — years of content evolution. Yes, there’s an embarrassment of TV riches right now, and a fuzzy batch of Oscar contenders. It’s complicated, however, distilling those elements into an “Is TV better than movies?” debate, the kind of phallic face-off tailor-made for a splashy Web headline and to catch the attention of Hollywood, which always appreciates putting things in “Who’s bigger?” terms.

Alas, however pithy the question, a genuine answer won’t fit neatly on a postage stamp.

For television, this indeed represents the best and worst of times — a Golden Age and Pyrite Period all at once.

Let’s dispense with the latter first. While the unscripted genre is too diverse to speak in sweeping generalities, it’s fair to say the basest reality TV shows plumb disheartening levels of abuse and humiliation, while spawning a generation of “stars” (see the Kardashians) whose only discernible talent is becoming famous. As evidence, flip through any copy of Us Weekly, preferably before eating.

Obviously there’s room for entertainment of both high and low varieties, though tellingly, ratings for programs represented on TV’s honor roll seldom rival top unscripted hits. This conveniently allows execs to hide behind the old “The public made us do it” excuse.

At the same time, it seems irrefutable there has never before been such an array or abundance of great dramas, flanked by enough first-class comedies to at least prevent that diminished art from being laughed out of the conversation.

Clearly, fans of great television — the kind that has, for many, replaced trips to the theatrical art house — owe a huge debt to HBO, which gave even elite snobs license to watch TV. The channel’s old “It’s not TV. It’s HBO” slogan perfectly captured this mentality, enabling New Yorker and New York Times readers (and critics) to proudly reference “The Wire” or “The Sopranos.”

In hindsight, though, the pivotal moment in the modern quality explosion can be traced to the introduction of “Nip/Tuck” in 2003.

Created by Ryan Murphy, the FX drama’s early years proved basic cable could aspire to a level of artistic ambition rivaling their pay brethren — while pushing content boundaries as vigorously as advertisers would allow. Programs like “Mad Men” and “Damages” followed, and network shows that would have once met untimely deaths (see NBC’s “Friday Night Lights” and “Southland”) found second lives thanks to cable.

Somewhat perversely, the TV movie’s decline also funneled additional resources into episodic drama, as channels like Showtime realized signature hits could lure viewers back week after week, unlike one-shot telecasts.

Of course, not every seed of “Nip/Tuck’s” legacy has been quite so creatively fruitful, as evidenced by the latest Murphy/FX collaboration, “American Horror Story,” which reflects TV’s anything-to-get-noticed impulses.

It’s also easy to forget there’s simply more of, well, everything — both good and bad, international (see “Downton Abbey”) and domestic. How could there not be, when earlier references to TV’s “golden age” denoted a time when greatness consisted of a mere handful of channels?

Ultimately, all today’s terrific stuff can’t reverse the first law of television — namely, gems will always be buried in mounds of dreck — but those with discerning palates, patience and a DVR needn’t look far to find tantalizing delights.

So yes, there’s plenty of gold spilling out of the TV, and more goodies to squander one’s time than ever before. Yet while the TV is literally bigger and brighter, an old adage still applies: All that glitters is not gold.

More TV

  • Joel Kinnaman Mireille Enos Esme Creed

    Amazon's 'Hanna,' New Season of 'False Flag' Lead Strong Berlinale Series Lineup

    Amazon Prime Video’s upcoming high-concept thriller “Hanna” will debut at the 2019 Berlinale Series, with its stars – Esme Creed-Miles, Joel Kinnaman and Mireille Enos – expected in Berlin for its premiere. Netflix also features in the lineup and will debut “Quicksand,” its first Swedish original. A roster of seven shows also includes big-ticket Sky [...]

  • China’s ‘Boonie Bears’ Reach Korea With

    China’s ‘Boonie Bears’ Reach Korea With Animated Series and Movie

    Two seasons of the hit Chinese animation series “Boonie Bears” have been licensed for release in South Korea. The deal was struck by animation studio Fantawild with content distributor Media to Media. The broker has acquired IPTV and VOD rights to “Boonie Bears: Four Seasons” and “Sunsational Summer and Snow Daze,” a total of 104 [...]

  • Mike Royce24th Annual Critics' Choice Awards,

    CBS Orders Comedy Pilot 'Story of Us' From 'One Day at a Time' Co-Creator Mike Royce

    CBS has ordered a pilot for the comedy “The Story of Us” from writer and executive producer Mike Royce. The hybrid comedy tells the story of how an unlikely couple becomes a family through interviews and vignettes spanning 10 years. In addition to Royce, Nick Stoller and Conor Welch will serve as executive producers. Sony [...]

  • 'Schitt's Creek' Stars Reveal Dream Guest

    'Schitt's Creek' Cast Reveals Dream Guest Stars: Oprah, Beyonce and ...

    “Schitt’s Creek” has big dreams. Dan Levy, who stars as David on the series, says his wish list of guest stars includes Oprah, Beyonce, Mariah Carey and Gwyneth Paltrow. “All for different reasons, none of whom we’ll get,” he cracked at the Critics’ Choice Awards. For those who haven’t caught on to the “Schitt’s Creek” [...]

  • Bob Costas Olympics Mike Tirico

    Bob Costas Officially Out at NBC After Nearly 40 Years

    Bob Costas has formally parted ways with NBC after nearly 40 years as a sportscaster for the Peacock. Costas and NBC have been negotiating an exit agreement for months. Word surfaced last summer that he was preparing to end his tenure with the network. Costas confirmed the news in an interview with the New York [...]

  • Happy

    TV Roundup: Syfy Drops First Trailer for Season 2 of 'Happy!'

    In today’s TV News Roundup, Syfy drops the first trailer for the second season of “Happy!” and Imagine Kids & Family sets a partnership with Four M Studios.  FIRST LOOKS Syfy has dropped the first trailer for season two of “Happy!” starring Christopher Meloni and Patton Oswalt. The new season premieres Wednesday, March 27 at 10/9c [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content