You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Critic says ‘MASH’ top show of character

Emmy Commemorative 2012

“Which shows had the greatest collection of characters of all time?”

That was the question I agreed to tackle, and it seemed simple enough — at least, until the elimination game began, and settling on criteria became an issue.

The best characters, or the best cast? Comedy or drama? Volume or quality? How to distinguish characters from the overall show? Could a program with a great couple of leads — say, Felix and Oscar — overcome a brilliant ensemble, such as “Cheers,” “Frasier” or “Everybody Loves Raymond,” where every player delivered laughs? Normally, a full house (but not the “Full House”) beats a pair of aces.

Then there’s the question of nostalgia, or how one could even begin to compare the current century with beloved programs birthed in the 1950s or ’60s, much less the quality explosion that occurred in the ’70s and ’80s. In terms of complexity, there’s simply no Watergate-era equivalent of “Breaking Bad,” “Lost” or “Mad Men.”

Finally, there’s the little matter of longevity, and — in some instances — weathering a shifting assortment of characters. Should “MASH” earn extra credit for replacing personalities like Trapper John and Henry Blake with the equally appealing B.J. Hunnicutt and Sherman Potter? And what about “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” siring all those spinoffs?

If this sort of barroom exercise can’t really produce a “right” answer, it seems easy enough to come up with a lot of wrong ones. And frankly, trying to pick from among series like “All in the Family,” “The Honeymooners” and “The Dick Van Dyke Show” is one of those decisions that could change daily, in the same way preferring Willie Mays or Henry Aaron might change depending on mood, or the theoretical needs of one’s fictional baseball team.

So rather than argue pros and cons — or seek to convince fans of “The Wire” and “The Sopranos,” or “The West Wing” and “Hill Street Blues,” why those dramatic titans shouldn’t top the list — here’s a brief case for the show that does. (Regarding the great HBO shows, one can argue the sheer tonnage of certain casts actually dilutes the characters for these purposes.)

Aside from running 11 seasons, “MASH” popularized the concept of “dramedy” — effortlessly shifting between comedy and drama — before the term was even coined. Anchored by Alan Alda, the cast was deep, distinguished and survived considerable turnover.

Although not as fruitful as “Mary Tyler Moore” (which amounts to a sort-of runner-up) in begetting spinoffs, even the broadest characters on “MASH” were allowed moments of genuine pathos, and the backdrop of the Korean war — overlapping with Vietnam — gave a resonance to the silliness.

“MASH” also featured some of TV’s most memorable exits, offering a poignant reminder that life, combat and the series itself marched on.

The show’s finale, of course, reigned for years as the most-watched event in TV history before rising population levels caught up with it, but the rating and share (more than 60% of U.S. homes tuned in) remain unassailable.

There was a reason for that. A lot of great TV characters have come and gone, but “MASH” finally gets the edge over the rest. It was a class act, with a cast that could uniformly point to the show as the best work of their careers — right until that helicopter made its last ride over the horizon.

So there it is. Final answer.

Just don’t hold me to it.

Emmy Commemorative 2012
Critic says ‘MASH’ top show of character
Anti-heroes | At your service | Authorities | Crimesolvers | Father Figures | Goundbreakers | Height of Hijinx | Heroes | Inseparable Duos | Journeyers | Ones of a kind

More TV

  • El Pájaro Amarillo

    ‘The Yellow Bird’ Takes Off from Pamplona’s Conecta Fiction

    PAMPLONA, Spain — Actor-turned-producer Antonio Resines attended this year’s Conecta Fiction TV co-production and networking event with his proposed series “The Yellow Bird,” based on a true story. In the 1920s aviation was in its infancy, and scores of pilots dedicated their lives to crashing through seemingly unbreakable barriers. Among them, Armand Lotti, a young [...]

  • THE MASKED SINGER: L-R: Terry Bradshaw

    Fox Sets Fall Premiere Dates for 'Empire' Final Season, 'Masked Singer' Season 2

    Fox has officially set its fall premiere dates for the 2019-2020 season. As was previously announced, the 71st Emmy Awards will air live on Fox on Sunday, Sept. 22. “9-1-1” returns for its third season on Monday, Sept. 23, leading in to the series premiere of the new Fox drama series “Prodigal Son.” Tuesday, Sept. [...]

  • FX Announces 'American Horror Story: 1984'

    FX Announces 'American Horror Story: 1984' Premiere Date

    “American Horror Story: 1984” will premiere on September 18 at 10 p.m., FX announced Monday. The cabler also announced the returns of “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia,” “Mayans MC” and “Mr. Inbetween.” “1984” is the ninth installment of Ryan Murphy’s horror drama. The uber-producer previously unveiled a teaser for the season, stylized in the vein [...]

  • The Loudest Voice Review

    TV Shows to Watch the Week of June 24, 2019: 'The Loudest Voice' Premieres on Showtime

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “The Loudest Voice” premieres on Showtime and Ramy Youssef’s stand-up special drops on [...]

  • Ultratumba

    ‘From the Dead’ Tops Conecta Fiction’s Pitch Digiseries Session

    PAMPLONA, Spain — This year’s Conecta Fiction, Spain’s upstart international TV co-pro and networking event now in its third year, hosted a Pitch Digiseries session, an hour-long event which saw five ambitious short-form projects pitch to industry professionals gathered in the northern city of Pamplona. While drama may be the name of the game among [...]


    Conecta Fiction: Colombia’s Rhayuela Films Advances on ‘Casting,’ ‘Agencia de Detectives’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    PAMPLONA, Spain  —  Now in post-production on HBO Latin America’s action horror thriller “Mil Colmillos,” one of the biggest series the pay TV operator has made out of Latin America, Colombia’s Rhayuela is advancing on development of two new TV dramas:“Agencia de Detectives” and “Casting.” Set in an unidentified Latin American country, and based on [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content