You will be redirected back to your article in seconds


Thinking outside the box has long been a touchstone of the bookings for the Allen Room's New American Songbook Series, but seldom has "outside" been taken more literally than at this perf – which actually ended across the street in Central Park, via a Mardi Gras styled parade led by Tuneyards' leader Merrill Garbus.

Thinking outside the box has long been a touchstone of the bookings for the Allen Room’s New American Songbook Series, but seldom has “outside” been taken more literally than at this perf – which actually ended across the street in Central Park, via a Mardi Gras styled parade led by Tuneyards’ leader Merrill Garbus.

The gig’s finale, a combination of joyous celebration and political agitation, found the charismatic Garbus perched atop a statue at the park’s fringe, holding an “occupy” banner and delivering an impassioned, seemingly improvised speech about equality, which gave way to an a capella rendition of her song “Bizness.”

That presentation gave the song an extra relevance boost, but the entire program proved an excellent showcase for Garbus’s envelope pushing tendencies, which extend to both content and context – a conscious-yet-comic array of observations set to jarring rhythms that veer from pan-African to extra-terrestrial.

Most of the set was drawn from Tuneyards’ 2011 album “Whokill” (which won multiple year-end raves, including an album of the year win in the Village Voice’s prestigious Pazz and Jop poll). Her own triggered percussion loops provided the bulk of the backing for her ululations, which often lapsed into wordlessness but never lost their emotive grip.

Garbus’s playful attitude imbued songs like “Gangsta” (which re-imagines Taxi Driver with Yoko Ono as Travis Bickle) with a sense of confrontational loopiness. But instead of a threatened roundhouse right, she delivers something more akin to a quizzical gentle chuck to the shoulder – a reminder that she thinks of herself as a peer to aud members, rather than a budding icon.

Even so, she had the capacity crowd, and, at evening’s end, the non-paying onlookers who joined in the park portion of the program, eating out of her hand. Yes, by the time Gotham cops arrived to check out the commotion, she and her cohorts were long gone, but the memory would certainly linger for just about everyone in attendance


(Allen Room; 453 capacity; $100 top)

Production: Presented in house. Band: Merrill Garbus, Nate Brenner, Matt Nelson, Noah Bernstein-Hanley. Reviewed February 9th, 2012.

More Music

  • Kacey Musgraves Cardi B Janelle Monae

    The Best Albums of 2018

    Even by recent standards, these are times that try human souls. And not surprisingly, that was reflected in the music of 2018: Whether metaphorically responding to the political realities of America (“Black Panther), mimicking the ADD nature of modern culture (Terra Whack) or simply providing a distraction, however brief, from too much reality (take your [...]

  • Kamasi Washington Alejandro Escovedo Janelle Monae

    Chris Morris' 10 Best Albums of 2018

    Kamasi Washington, “Heaven and Earth” Washington has proven to be an unclassifiable asset, both in his own name and as a contributor to Kendrick Lamar’s albums, including the Pulitzer-winning “DAMN.” This second three-CD set in three years (which encompasses the “hidden” EP “The Choice”) demonstrates the tenor saxophonist’s towering ambition and further breaks down the [...]

  • Elvis Costello Brandi Carlile Father John

    Chris Willman's 20 Best Albums of 2018

    Elvis Costello & the Imposters, “Look Now” (Concord) There are other Rock & Roll Hall of Famers who are Costello’s songwriting equal — blokes named Bob and Bruce come to mind — but none who’ve maintained such a consistently high level of lyrical and melodic invention over four decades or more. As a record-maker, Costello had pretty [...]

  • Kacey Musgraves Kamasi Washington Pusha T

    Andrew Barker's 10 Best Albums of 2018

    1. Kacey Musgraves, “Golden Hour” “Golden Hour” is, hands-down, the greatest stoner-pop-country-folk-disco album ever recorded. And the fact that it’s the only album that matches that description shouldn’t diminish the accomplishment – it simply shows how, three albums into her career, Musgraves is following her arrow further away from Nashville’s comfort zone than anyone would have reasonably [...]

  • Jem Aswad's 20 Best Albums of

    Jem Aswad's 20 Best Albums of 2018

    For music critics, your year-end list is like a combination of a masters’ thesis and an I.D. — something labored over that defines you, if only in one moment, because all of us would redo the list within the next hour, year or decade. I always try to make these lists an honest representation of [...]

  • Ariana Grande Drops New Song, ‘Imagine’

    Ariana Grande Drops New Song, ‘Imagine’ (Listen)

    Ariana Grande continued the march to her next album, “Thank U, Next,” by dropping a new single called “Imagine” late Thursday. The song is the second she’s released since she dropped her “Sweetener” album in August, following the chart-topping title track to her next album. Unlike “Thank U, Next,” “Imagine” is a ballad, a soulful [...]

  • Nancy Wilson

    Nancy Wilson, Grammy-Winning Jazz Singer and TV Personality, Dies at 81

    Nancy Wilson, one of the most revered jazz singers of the 20th century, has died, her manager told the Associated Press. She was 81. The singer passed away at her home in Pioneertown, a small California community north of Palm Springs, after a long illness, according to manager Devra Hall. Wilson’s three Grammy awards spanned a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content