You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Recommendation

Jonathan Caren's world preem "The Recommendation" brings two contrasting, equally charismatic Gatsby-esque strivers onto the Old Globe's arena stage.

Iskinder Iudoku , Brandon Gill, Aaron Feldman, Evan Todd, Dwight Barnes , Jimonn Cole

Nobody reads “The Great Gatsby” to learn all about Nick Carraway. While an outsider may offer perspective, only the main guy in the arena truly commands our attention. Jonathan Caren’s world preem “The Recommendation” brings two contrasting, equally charismatic Gatsby-esque strivers onto the Old Globe’s arena stage. Yet every time they’re on a collision course, a passive, boring narrator sashays in to steal focus and reduce the heat. An otherwise handsome, absorbing production ends up meriting only a qualified recommendation.

Sucking up all the air from every room is golden boy Aaron Feldman (Evan Todd), scion of L.A. wealth who becomes Brown U.’s BMOC. No great scholarly shakes, the dude is all basketball hands and hip-hop argot as he wows the ladies and nurtures his bros, certain his social skills and connections will continue to pave his road with yellow brick en route to a filmmaking career. (Todd is almost too good at this act for comfort.)

Then comes the post-bac bummer, as a random L.A. traffic stop lands him in a holding cell with his cracked-mirror image. Career criminal Dwight Barnes (a mesmerizing Jimonn Cole) ricochets from camaraderie to menace in detailing filmmaking dreams no less grandiose than Aaron’s. “I’m chilling up in my Hollywood bungalow kickin’ it me and Steven…,” he faux-reminisces as a practiced eye takes the terrified kid’s measure.

The ‘rents deny their son bail to teach him a lesson, which he receives in the manic Barnes’ detailed portrait of serious jail time. A bargain is exacted by which pretty-boy’s back will be watched for the duration, and once the cell doors open, a grateful Aaron will open doors to the film industry — details tantalizingly unspecified for the moment.

The alert reader will note the absence of mention, until now, of the dramatic tripod’s third prong. That’s Aaron’s college roomie and acolyte, later accepted to UCLA Law upon the intercession of Feldman Senior. Iskinder (Brandon Gill) is the classic Fitzgeraldian poor kid rendered starry-eyed by privilege, with an insatiable tendency to spell out themes and exposition and his Ethiopian-born father’s gnomic words to live by — “Do not spy with avaricious eyes” — which, of course, he fails to live by at all.

Helmer Jonathan Munby guides Cole and Todd through a series of cat-and-mouse games you enjoy while they’re happening even as they whet your appetite for the next one. Alexander Dodge’s metal-gridded set serves up poolside, lockup and locker room with equal ease, complemented by Philip S. Rosenberg’s supple lighting.

Yet Iskinder is a total drag on the proceedings. Gill lacks any governing attitude toward his narration — he might as well be reciting someone else’s story — and in interactions with the others, he rides one note of earnest confusion. The script specifies he’s a “habitual stoner” with “a mounting anger waiting to be released,” but Munby guides Gill to no hint of either in the entire two hours.

Caren’s press notes identify Iskinder as the main character, his ambivalence about needing and accepting Aaron’s helping hand supposedly the story’s engine. But the guy is remote from the most exciting events en route, windily reflective but only engaged in passing. Eventually he’s dragged unconvincingly into the denouement, almost as an afterthought. It’s actually easy to imagine him cut completely, the better to craft a sizzling two-hander.

Any author is entitled to spell out his themes as he sees fit, but somebody at the Old Globe never got the memo.

The Recommendation

Old Globe, San Diego; 285 seats; $67 top

Production: An Old Globe presentation of a play in two acts by Jonathan Caren. Directed by Jonathan Munby. Sets, Alexander Dodge; costumes, Linda Cho; lighting, Philip S. Rosenberg; original music and sound, Lindsay Jones; movement, Tony Caligagan. Opened Jan. 26, 2012. Reviewed Jan. 28. Runs through Feb. 26. Running time: 2 HOURS.

Cast: Iskinder Iudoku , Brandon Gill, Aaron Feldman, Evan Todd, Dwight Barnes , Jimonn Cole

More Legit

  • Gary review

    Broadway Review: 'Gary: A Sequel to Titus Andronicus' With Nathan Lane

    Nathan Lane and Kristine Nielsen, two of the funniest people on the face of the earth, play street cleaners tasked with carting away the dead after the civil wars that brought down the Roman Empire. Well, a job’s a job, and Gary (Lane) and Janice (Nielsen) go about their disgusting work without complaint. “Long story [...]

  • Laurie Metcalf, John Lithgow'Hillary and Clinton'

    Why John Lithgow Worried About Starring in Broadway's 'Hillary and Clinton'

    When Lucas Hnath first conceived of “Hillary and Clinton” in 2008, he was writing for and about a very different America. Now, a total reimagining of the show has made its way to Broadway with Laurie Metcalf and John Lithgow in the titular roles. At the opening on Thursday night, the cast and creatives talked [...]

  • Three Sisters review

    London Theater Review: 'Three Sisters'

    Ennui has become exhaustion in playwright Cordelia Lynn’s new version of “Three Sisters.” The word recurs and recurs. Everyone on the Prozorov estate is worn out; too “overworked” to do anything but sit around idle. Are they killing time or is time killing them? Either way, a play often framed as a study of boredom [...]

  • Patrick Page, Amber Grey, Eva Noblezada,

    'Hadestown' Took 12 Years to Get to Broadway, but It's More Relevant Than Ever

    When “Hadestown” was first staged as a tiny, DIY theater project in Vermont, those involved could never have predicted that it was the start of a 12-year journey to Broadway — or how painfully relevant it would be when it arrived. At Wednesday night’s opening at the Walter Kerr Theatre, the cast and creatives discussed [...]

  • Hillary and Clinton review

    Broadway Review: Laurie Metcalf and John Lithgow in 'Hillary and Clinton'

    If anyone could play Hillary Clinton, it’s Laurie Metcalf – and here she is, in Lucas Hnath’s “Hillary and Clinton,” giving a performance that feels painfully honest and true. And if anyone could capture Bill Clinton’s feckless but irresistible charm, that would be John Lithgow – and here he is, too. Who better to work [...]

  • Hadestown review

    Broadway Review: 'Hadestown'

    “Hadestown” triggered a lot of buzz when this wholly American show (which came to the stage by way of a concept album) premiered at Off Broadway’s New York Theatre Workshop in 2016. Arriving on Broadway with its earthly delights more or less intact, this perfectly heavenly musical — with book, music and lyrics by Anaïs [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content