The Soul of Bread

"The Soul of Bread" adds little to the stale maxim that anything tastes good when it's made with love.

With: Michelle Chen, Chen Han-tien, Anthony Neely, Liao Chun, Janel Tsai.

Pitting a gourmet Gallic pastry chef against a humble Taiwanese baker in a bun-making contest to see who gets the girl, “The Soul of Bread” adds little to the stale maxim that anything tastes good when it’s made with love. Marred by cheesy definitions of l’amour and stale town-vs.-country value judgments, this effort from helmers Kao Pin-chuan and Lin Chun-yang works best as an extended vehicle for lead thesp Michelle Chen, who became a hot property after Taiwan megahit “You Are the Apple of My Eye.” Chinese-speaking markets and Asian-friendly ancillary will bite.

A cutesy prologue sets the infantile storybook tone of the pic, introducing half-Taiwanese, half-French beefcake Brad (Anthony Neely) as a wildly popular baker with his own TV show. When his mother, Sophie (Janel Tsai) dies, it sends Brad into a tailspin and his ratings plummet. To get over his grief, Brad heads to Sophie’s birthplace in Taiwan and locates a village bakery, the source of the most unforgettable bun his mother ever tasted.

Popular on Variety

Brad pleads with the owner, Mr. Chiu (Liao Chun), to take him on as an apprentice, but he gets distracted by the sight of Chiu’s lovely daughter, Hsiao-ping (Chen). Although Hsiao-ping already has a sweetheart, Gaobing (Chen Han-tien), she longs to flee her provincial cocoon and reach Paris — her dream destination, and something Brad’s passionate courtship could provide. A bread-making contest seems unavoidable.

The least endearing aspect of “Soul” is not its lax attitude toward structure, plot consistency or realism, but rather its unawareness of how corny it is. When Brad sings “La Vie en rose” in Neely’s incongruous American accent, it’s presented without a trace of irony, and auds are expected to ooh-and-ah along with Hsiao-ping. Similarly, to underscore the devotion of Gaobing (the nickname means “cake and biscuit”) to Hsiao-ping, the helmers pile on the declarations of love without even bothering to vary the dialogue to suit the occasion.

To dramatize the male protags’ rivalry, the screenplay has them regress into ever more pea-brained behavior and boorish machismo. Lacking the depth of characterization that would make their strengths and weaknesses distinctive, Hsiao-ping’s indecision doesn’t convey the intended agony or tension.

The screenplay betrays its origins as a 2007 TV movie (also helmed by Kao) by tossing in a plateful of subplots. Some have batty charm, like the village elders treating Brad’s baguettes as phallic talismans, but most of the attempts at quirky humor fall flat. Characters are colorful in that campy, folksy way that’s all the rage in Taiwanese cinema, but the incorporation of crowdpleasing local elements seems forced.

Chen, who had more to express with her sensitively drawn roles in “Apple” and “Hear Me,” is not sufficiently challenged as a conventionally sweet country girl, but she still rises gracefully above the often-ludicrous storyline. Other perfs remain one-note.

On the culinary front, the pic sticks to pure eye-candy, dishing out an exotic array of bread and pastries. These shots convey visual as well as tactile pleasure, something missing in the pic’s depictions of romance.

Aside from kitschy camera tricks, rushed editing and a score drowning in slushy pop songs, tech credits are adequate.

The Soul of Bread


Production: A 20th Century Fox (in Taiwan)/Golden Scene (in Hong Kong) release of a Double Edge Entertainment, Ming Yi Intl. Media presentation of a Double Edge Entertainment production. (International sales: Double Edge Entertainment, Taipei.) Produced by Lei Hui, Chang Yen-chu, Fang Kuo-chien, Lu Yen-ching, Kaohsiung Ren. Executive producers, Michael Tseng, Wolf Chen. Directed by Kao Pin-chuan, Lin Chun-yang. Screenplay, Mu Erh, Kao.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Yang Wei-han; editor, Ku Hsiao-yun; music, Owen Wang; production designer, Tang Wei-Hsuan; art directors, Li Yi-ling, Chao Chen-fa; set decorator, Luo Yu-chuan; costume designer, Chen Yao-chun; sound (Dolby Digital), Tu Duu-chih, supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Tu Duu-chih; visual effects supervisor, Johnny Lin; visual effects, Bulky Animation Studio; stunt coordinator, Yang Chih-lung; food art, Liu Kuan-ting; bread consultant, Li Chun-lung; line producer, Hsu Guo-lun; associate producer, Chuang Chi-hsiang; assistant director, Hsu Chia-chen. Reviewed at Hong Kong Filmart, March 21, 2012. Running time: 113 MIN.

With: With: Michelle Chen, Chen Han-tien, Anthony Neely, Liao Chun, Janel Tsai.(Mandarin, Taiwanese, French, English, Japanese dialogue)

More Film

  • AMC theater

    AMC Entertainment Reports Mixed Fourth-Quarter Results

    AMC Entertainment has reported mixed fourth-quarter results, which saw revenues rise 2.4% to $1.45 billion, despite a 4.4% drop in U.S. attendance to 62.3 million. The exhibitor, owned by Dalian Wanda Group, announced a fourth-quarter loss of $13.5 million, compared to a year-earlier profit of $170.6 million, due to $84.3 million of expense related to [...]

  • 'Straight Up' Review: James Sweeney's Gay

    'Straight Up': Film Review

    There’s a tradition in movies, as vital as a hypnotic action scene or a swooning love scene, of dialogue so witty and nimble and rapid-fire that it comes at you like something out of a stylized dream. I first encountered that brand of high-velocity verbal jousting in “A Hard Day’s Night,” and later on in [...]

  • Cahiers du Cinema

    French Film Magazine Cahiers du Cinema's Staff Quits Over New Ownership

    The future of iconic French film publication Cahiers du Cinéma is in question after the outlet’s entire staff quit in protest over the brand’s new ownership. The 15-member editorial staff has spoken out against a perceived conflict of interest posed by the Cahier’s owners — a group of bankers, tech entrepreneurs and film producers that [...]

  • John Singleton Victoria Mahoney Spike Lee

    In Honor of Black History Month, a Look at Black Directors Who Made History

    In 2019, the USC Annenberg Inclusion Initiative reported that 2018 was a historic year for black filmmakers, noting a “record high when it came to hiring black directors.” The report reflected a significant change, showing the push for diversity both behind and in front of the camera. Though the numbers are increasing, the report also [...]

  • Benh Zeitlin Wendy Movie BTS

    Benh Zeitlin Goes Old-School With Stunts and Puppets for His Peter Pan Film 'Wendy'

    It has taken eight years for Benh Zeitlin to deliver the follow-up to his Oscar-nominated 2012 feature debut “Beasts of the Southern Wild.” But you could say the idea for “Wendy,” which reimagines the classic “Peter Pan” from the viewpoint of his female friend (played by first-time actor Devin France), has been percolating far longer [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content