×

The Dead and the Living

A young German woman learns the past is not as black-and-white as she thought.

With:
With: Anna Fischer, August Zirner, Hanns Schussnig, Daniela Sea, Itay Tiran, Winfried Glatzeder. (German, English dialogue)

A young German woman learns the past is not as black-and-white as she thought in “The Dead and the Living,” another offshoot from the I-don’t-know-what-my-family-did-during-the-war tradition. Less eye-catching than Barbara Albert’s previous work, this is an efficient if dramatically monotonous tale of a twentysomething’s journey into her family’s past. Nevertheless, the pic explores Germany’s guilt-ridden relationship with its own history with an engaging directness and simplicity that seems calculated to enlighten younger auds. “Dead” will live on in tube and fest slots, but also has real educational value.

The Dead and the Living

Twenty-five-year-old Austro-Rumanian Sita (Anna Fischer, who looks younger) is a TV production assistant and student. After attending the 95th birthday party of her grandfather (Hanns Schussnig), she finds a torn-up photo of him in SS uniform, and is dismissively told by her father (August Zirner) that the old man only went to a “training camp” during the war. However, further inquiries show there was no such camp.

After starting a relationship with Israeli Jocquin (Itay Tiran) — the script not always subtly picks up the available connections between past and present — Sita starts a journey that will take her to Vienna and Warsaw, where she befriends environmental activist Silver (Daniela Sea). Continuing her research despite the protestations of her father, Sita ends up in Auschwitz, where she learns her grandfather was in fact an SS lieutenant colonel.

Dramatically, the pic is pretty thin. Sita’s on/off relationship with Jocquin is driven by ideas rather than drama, and there’s only so much mileage to be had from watching someone anxiously visiting research centers. The film’s subsequent developments also make it that much harder to believe that such a bright, inquisitive person as Sita would have taken so long to find the truth.

The script strains too obviously for significance, as when the small holes in Sita’s ventricles are meant to suggest she literally has a broken heart. That said, Albert’s script at least complicates the simple “Nazis bad/everyone else good” dichotomy by supplying enough historical context: This family, like the helmer’s own, has Transylvanian roots, and historical forces meant that the Transylvanian Saxons were both perpetrators and victims during the war. All this is explored via a thought-provoking monologue movingly played by Schussnig.

Perfs are strong throughout, with Fischer doing good work as a fundamentally fragile young woman out of her depth. Often-handheld lensing and an edgy soundtrack combine to suggest the protag’s restless energy.

Popular on Variety

The Dead and the Living

Austria

Production: A Coop99 Filmproduktion, Komplizenfilm production. (International sales: Films Distribution, Paris.) Produced by Bruno Wagner, Barbara Albert. Co-producers, Alex Stern, Maren Ade, Jonas Dornbach, Janine Jackowski. Directed, written by Barbara Albert.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Bogumil Godfrejow; editor, Monika Willi; music, Lorenz Dangel; production designer, Enid Loeser; costume designer, Veronika Albert; sound (Dolby Digital), Dietmar Zuson, Tobias Fleig; assistant director, Valentin Hitz, Melani Murkovic; casting, Lisa Olah. Reviewed at San Sebastian Film Festival (competing), Sept. 23, 2012. Running time: 110 MIN.

Cast: With: Anna Fischer, August Zirner, Hanns Schussnig, Daniela Sea, Itay Tiran, Winfried Glatzeder. (German, English dialogue)

More Scene

  • Michael Shannon Benedict Cumberbatch Tuppence Middleton

    How Martin Scorsese Saved 'Current War' From Harvey Weinstein

    Director Alfonso Gomez-Rejon finally gets to release his version of his long-in-the-making “The Current War.” The film, about the competition between Thomas Edison and George Westinghouse, was originally set to be distributed by the Weinstein Company after Harvey Weinstein recut it, much to Gomez-Rejon’s chagrin. To make matters worse, Weinstein premiered the movie at the [...]

  • Law Roach Kiki Layne

    Law Roach, Kiki Layne Highlight the Serious Side of Fashion at InStyle Awards

    “I’m not supposed to be here,” stylist of the year honoree Law Roach told the well-heeled guests assembled Monday night for the 5th annual InStyle Awards. “Where I’m from, no one makes it to these rooms…and I stand here for two reasons right? One, that someone told me I was special; and two, that somebody [...]

  • Debra-Messing-Donald-Trump

    Debra Messing Lampoons Donald Trump in Play Based on Mueller Report

    Debra Messing portrayed President Donald Trump in an all-star play based on the Mueller report on Monday at Beverly Hills’ Saban Theatre. Wearing a light pant suit and sitting with legs spread confidently, Messing nailed Trump’s mannerisms in the one-night-only play, “You Can’t Make This Sh*t Up,” which raised funds for a Barbara Boxer-led PAC [...]

  • Kathryn Hahn Mrs. Fletcher

    Kathryn Hahn Talks Working With an Intimacy Coordinator on 'Mrs. Fletcher'

    HBO’s new comedy “Mrs. Fletcher” follows the journey of an empty-nester divorcee who embarks on a journey of self-discovery and sexual exploration following her son’s departure for college. At the series premiere on Monday night at the Avalon Hollywood in Los Angeles, Kathryn Hahn discussed playing the titular role of Eve Fletcher, a middle-aged woman [...]

  • Taika Waititi Natalie Portman SDCC 2019

    Natalie Portman Weighs in on 'Thor: Love and Thunder's' Possible Breast Cancer Storyline

    Natalie Portman doesn’t know if “Thor: Love and Thunder” will include a breast cancer storyline for her character Jane Foster, but she’s definitely intrigued by the possibility. “It’s just very rare that these kinds of big entertainment films look at more serious, real-life issues,” she told Variety at L.A. Dance Project’s 8th annual fundraising gala [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content