×

Song of Silence

A plaintive ballad about a hearing-impaired teenager trying to find her place in a fractured family.

With:
With: Yin Yaning, Wu Bingbin, Li Qiang, Yu Xuan, Tang Hui, Feng Zhaofa, Xie Zhihong.

“Song of Silence” is a plaintive ballad about a hearing-impaired teenager trying to find her place in a fractured family. First-time helmer Chen Zhuo demonstrates tact and perceptiveness when exploring his protag’s fragile inner world as she stumbles to make sense of and assert her blossoming sexuality. Regrettably, however, the film’s crass stylistic pretensions frequently jar with the low-key realism achieved by his quietly engaging characters, finely tuned non-professional perfs and vividly evoked southern-central Chinese setting, muffling the helmer’s message and individual voice. Pic is unlikely to blossom beyond fest play.

Hearing-impaired Jing (Yin Yaning) attends a regular school in a fishing village and is being raised by her single mother (Tang Hui), but doesn’t get along with Mom’s new b.f. When Jing is deemed inappropriately close to her mentally challenged uncle (Yu Xuan), she is sent to live temporarily with her estranged father, policeman Zhang Haoyang (Li Qiang). Neither Zhang nor Mei (Wu Bingbin), his pregnant club-singer g.f., is thrilled to have her around, though the awkward thawing of the trio’s relations is played out to riveting and moving effect in scenes that include angry brawls, meaningful silences and songs full of longing.

Popular on Variety

Proud and petulant, yet at times revealing flashes of deep love and tenderness, Jing is a complex character, yet she could be any girl on the cusp of womanhood. Neither focusing on her disability nor painting her as an object of pity, Yin allows Jing to bloom by developing a range of emotions and non-verbal self-expression. Meanwhile, Mei, a sexually bold misfit, turns out to be needier and more childlike than Jing; Wu contrasts strongly with her mute counterpart in a self-centered role that avoids tipping over into obnoxiousness.

Drawing on a real incident, Chen clearly gets under his characters’ skin, but his use of the kind of one-size-fits-all lensing and editing techniques typical of China’s independent filmmakers proves a poor fit with the non-pro cast’s excellent, naturalistic playing. Unable to find his own voice, the helmer forces in magical elements, like recurring images of dead goldfish and a tacky dream sequence.

Shot in Chen’s native Changsha (capital of Hunan province) and Xiangtan (Mao Zedong’s hometown), lenser Shi Yue juxtaposes the city’s urban buzz with reposeful images of Yangmeizhou (the pic’s Chinese title), the lone isle in the center of the mist-cloaked Xiang River. Tech credits are passable.

Song of Silence

China

Production: A Harvest Films release of a Beijing Tiger Entertainment and Media Co. presentation and production in association with Harvest Films Prod. Co. Produced by Liu Gang. Executive producer, Lai Yifan. Co-producer, Ouyang Sijie. Co-executive producer, Yu Zhong. Directed, edited by Chen Zhuo. Screenplay, Chen Haoyang, Zeng Peilin, Chen.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Shi Yue; music, Jiang Anqing; music supervisor, Li Xiang; art director, Zhang Xiaodi; costume designer, Wang Hailong; sound (Digital 5.1 stereo), Gao Yu, Song Tianxiang; supervising sound editor, Hu Tinglan; re-recording mixers, Huang Hao, Liang Dan; visual effects, Tiger Entertainment and Media Co, Homeboy Effects; line producer, Chen Zhuo; assistant director, Zeng Peilin. Reviewed at Udine Far East Film Festival, April 23, 2012. Running time: 114 MIN.

With: With: Yin Yaning, Wu Bingbin, Li Qiang, Yu Xuan, Tang Hui, Feng Zhaofa, Xie Zhihong.

More Film

  • Ventana Sur

    Ventana Sur Sets 2020 Dates, a New Venue

    BERLIN —   Ventana Sur, the biggest film-TV industry event in Latin America – and bulwarked by a hugely popular Cannes Film Week hosted by Thierry Fremaux – has set dates for its 12th edition, and announced a new venue in Buenos Aires. Running Monday Nov. 30 to Friday Dec. 4, this year’s 12th Ventana [...]

  • Cannes VR

    Cannes Film Festival Plots Major Expansion to VR Program

    Cannes XR, the Marché du Film’s program dedicated to immersive and augmented reality content, is set to expand. For its second edition, Cannes XR has partnered with tech creator Positron and Brogent Technologies to introduce a new VR theater, dedicated space and competition. While keeping its 700-square meter exhibition space in the basement of Cannes’ [...]

  • The Italian Recipe

    Europe-China Co-Prod 'The Italian Recipe' Immune to Coronavirus (EXCLUSIVE)

    With production in China suffering a coronavirus-imposed slowdown, “The Italian Recipe” is one co-production between Europe and China that is poised to potentially capitalize on the resulting dearth of Chinese content. It is positioned to advance European cinema’s efforts to make inroads in China. “The Italian Recipe,” in which a famous Chinese pop singer travels [...]

  • Csaba Kael

    Hungarian Film Commissioner Csaba Kael on His Ambitious Plans for 'Hollywood on the Danube'

    Just months after assuming the role of Hungarian film commissioner, Csaba Káel has designs on revamping the film and television industries to boost content development and production, expand already formidable studio facilities and become a lynchpin for film and TV production and servicing that extends far beyond Budapest. Káel took up his post in September, [...]

  • Claire Denis attends the 32nd European

    Claire Denis and Phedon Papamichael Join Doha Film Institute's Qumra Lineup

    The Doha Film Institute has added French auteur Claire Denis and Oscar-nominated cinematographer Phedon Papamichael (“Nebraska”) to the lineup of star talent who will act as mentors for the Qumra Masters program during its upcoming Qumra event dedicated to fostering fresh Arab film fare that is opening up to TV projects. They join previously announced [...]

  • Persian Lessons Russian Cinema

    'Persian Lessons': Film Review

    In “Schindler’s List,” most of the actors spoke English, using accents to indicate their characters’ origins. In “Son of Saul,” the cast struggles to communicate in a mish-mosh of languages, as Jews of different nationalities were thrown together in Auschwitz-Birkenau. Stories about the Holocaust — so vital in trying to reconcile the horrors of the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content