Falling Flowers

Although resplendently shot and elegantly appointed, this fusty biopic of Chinese novelist Xiao Hong recounts events without exploring the mind of an intellectual woman of her time.

With: Song Jia, Huang Jue, Wang Renjun, Zhang Bo. (Mandarin dialogue)

“Falling Flowers,” Huo Jianqi’s biopic about left-wing Chinese novelist Xiao Hong, charts her struggle against patriarchal feudalism, dire poverty, unwanted pregnancies and Japanese invasion, only to conclude that writing was just an attempt to take her mind off “disappointing lovelives.” Although resplendently shot and elegantly appointed, this fusty melodrama of romanticized destitution and tormented love recounts events without exploring the mind of an intellectual woman of her time. Though it may appeal to auds with a cultural bent, the film is too staid and dated to bloom in any commercial outlets.

Yi Fuhai and Su Xiaowei’s screenplay reflects a bias toward the tragic aspects of Xiao Hong’s life rather than her achievements as a revolutionary female writer who railed against class inequality and oppression of women. The story is bookended by scenes of her last days in 1941 Hong Kong, to which she escaped from the war-torn mainland, only to see the British colony fall to the Japanese. Her husband, Duanmu Hongliang (Wang Renjun), has disappeared, and the only one by her side as she succumbs to fatal illness is adoring young writer Luo Binji (Zhang Bo).

Popular on Variety

The film then flashes back to Hulan, a rural community in Dongbei province where Hong (Song Jia), born Zhang Naiying, grew up in a conservative landowning family. Fighting for the right to an education and against her arranged marriage to rich playboy Wang, she runs away to Beijing in 1931, only to shack up reluctantly with Wang in a boarding house in the provincial city of Harbin. In 1929, pregnant and abandoned by her fiance, she meets journalist Xiao Jun (Huang Jue), who becomes her soulmate and co-author.

The two lovers drift through eight cities as they move from north to south, fleeing Japanese invaders. Some of these cities are depicted with impressively precise period detail and ambience, interspersed with beautiful if gratuitous shots of surrounding scenery. Most scenes, however, are set inside rooming houses and other temporary lodgings that underscore the chaos of the era, as well as of Hong and Jun’s relationship.

Despite leaden pacing and stilted dialogue, there are some scenes that effectively depict Hong’s joy when absorbed in her writing; her first flush of self-confidence, stemming from the mentorship of literary giant Lu Xun during a brief spell in Shanghai, drives the film’s most upbeat and relevant passage. However, any positive image of female intellectuals is dissipated by the film’s ludicrous comparisons of Hong to Ophelia, repped by dolorous images of her floating on a bed of flowers like John Everett Millais’ painting. Song conveys the sturdy build, open heart and unyielding nature characteristic of northeastern women; she also dominates in passionate exchanges with a string of less powerfully portrayed male thesps. Tech credits are polished, especially the lush lensing and production design that viewers have come to expect from the helmer of “A Time to Love” and “The Postman in the Mountains.” Disappointingly, despite the writer’s celebrated depictions of the vast, sweeping Manchurian countryside, nature is not an integrated visual component, except a few splendid shots of the snow-covered fields and icy river at the end.

Falling Flowers


Production: A China Film Group release of a Talent Intl. Film Co. production. (International sales: China Film Group, Beijing.) Produced by Han Sanping, Wu Hongliang. Directed by Huo Jianqi. Screenplay, Yi Fuhai, Su Xiaowei.

Crew: Camera (color/B&W, widescreen), Shi Luan; editor, Yu Xi; music, Chao Jun; music supervisor, Shu Nan; production designer, Lv Feng; costume designer, Cao Li. Reviewed at Shanghai Film Festival (competing), June 20, 2012. Running time: 122 MIN.

With: With: Song Jia, Huang Jue, Wang Renjun, Zhang Bo. (Mandarin dialogue)

More Film

  • Worth

    'Worth': Film Review

    As a child, when future TV host Fred Rogers would see scary images on the news, his mother would tell him, “Look for the heroes.” If Fred were a boy today, she’d add, “Look for Ken Feinberg.” Feinberg, the lawyer at the center of Sara Colangelo’s “Worth,” specializes in putting a price tag on human [...]

  • Mika Ronkainen and Merja Aakko

    ‘All the Sins’ Producers to Broaden Spanish-Language Ties (EXCLUSIVE)

    GÖTEBORG, Sweden: “All the Sins”’ Finnish co-writers and creators Mika Ronkainen and Merja Aakko, winners of last year’s Nordisk Film & TV Fond Prize for outstanding Nordic screenplay, are developing for MRK Matila Röhr Productions an adoption drama set between Finland and Guatemala. Based on a true story, the six-part series “Act of Telling” (a [...]

  • A still from Vivos by Ai

    'Vivos': Film Review

    To the individual enduring it, sorrow seems a lonely, defenseless emotion, one from which others are too quick to look away. Shared and felt en masse, however, it can become something different: a galvanizing force, a wall, not diminished in pain but not diminished by it either. Ai Weiwei’s stirring new documentary “Vivos” runs on [...]

  • Jumbo

    'Jumbo': Film Review

    Tall, dark and handsome? The crush that Noémie Merlant’s character, Jeanne, explores in “Jumbo” is one out of three: a 25-foot-tall carnival ride who seduces the amusement park janitor as she spit-cleans his bulbs. During the night shift, Jumbo literally lights up Jeanne’s life, and while he’s not handsome in the traditional sense — especially [...]

  • Ironbark

    'Ironbark': Film Review

    Movie spies typically fall into one of two categories. There are the butterflies — flamboyant secret agents like James Bond or “Atomic Blonde” who behave as conspicuously as possible. And then there are the moth-like kind, who do their best to blend in. The character Benedict Cumberbatch plays in “Ironbark” belongs to the latter variety, [...]

  • Miss Juneteenth review

    'Miss Juneteenth': Film Review

    “Miss Juneteenth” richly captures the slow pace of ebbing small-town Texas life, even if you might wish there were a bit more narrative momentum to pick up the slack in writer-director Channing Godfrey Peoples’ first feature. She’s got a very relatable heroine in Nicole Beharie’s Turquoise, an erstwhile local beauty queen whose crown proved the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content