×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

A People Uncounted

Finally addressing at length the issue of an estimated half million Romani people killed by the Nazis during WWII, "A People Uncounted" joins "Paragraph 175" (about homosexuals) and the myriad documentaries related to Jewish persecution in illuminating another facet of Hitler's Final Solution.

With:
With: Hugo Hollenreiner, Ceija Stojka, Romani Rose, Ronald Lee, Ian Hancock, Bill Duna. (English, Romanian, Czech, Russian, German, Hungarian dialogue.)

Finally addressing at length the issue of an estimated half million Romani people killed by the Nazis during WWII, “A People Uncounted” joins “Paragraph 175” (about homosexuals) and the myriad documentaries related to Jewish persecution in illuminating another facet of Hitler’s Final Solution. The first nonfiction feature dedicated to Romani victims, this globe-trotting debut effort by helmer Aaron Yeger and his producing team offers a vivid mix of visual evidence, historical commentary and survivor testimonies. It’s less successful trying to integrate the struggles of today’s Roma, which merits a docu of its own. Broadcast and educational sales are likely.

Known by various names, many of them derogatory, in different territories, Roma people migrated northward from India during the Middle Ages, landing everywhere from Russia to the U.K. In some places they were forbidden to settle or own property (hence the transient image); elsewhere, they were segregated into ghettoes. Vlad the Impaler, Henry VIII and Maximilian I were among those who authorized their exile, persecution or outright murder. Yet somehow, a romantic popular stereotype of footloose freedom persisted, amusingly sketched here in a kitschy clip montage that stretches from 1944 Maria Montez vehicle “Gypsy Wildcat” to Shakira’s heavily Autotuned “Gypsy” musicvideo.

Currently Europe’s largest minority as well as the European Union’s most discriminated against, Roma are widely associated with theft and miscellaneous other misdeeds. That gives right-wing politicians and ethnic nationalist groups a license to brand them undesirables and encourage hate crimes against them. One woman is so afraid her educated, successful children will be tainted by association that she’ll only discuss her heritage while being photographed in silhouette.

Darker skin and social isolation made Roma an easy target for the Nazis, who sought to rub out the “gypsy scourge” in every nation they invaded or held as an ally. Many perished in concentration camps, while countless others were simply shot or starved to death in their homelands. Survivors of this holocaust, which claimed up to 90% of Europe’s Roma population, tell some hair-raising stories here, including one man who was subjected as a boy to Mengele’s experiments.

Yet this catastrophe was little recognized after the war. No Roma testified at the Nuremberg trials, and the minority’s lack of prominent academic and political voices (at least until recently) further obscured a tragic historical chapter. “A People Uncounted” draws parallels to other 20th-century genocides, though it somewhat belabors comparisons between Roma struggles today and the U.S. civil rights movement. The midsection’s emphasis on WWII makes the pic’s late return to current activism seem like an underdeveloped afterthought, raising so many more questions than it answers that one hopes Yeger devotes a subsequent feature to that subject alone.

That structural awkwardness aside, longtime docu editor Kurt Engfehr does a fine job shaping the pic’s narrative flow in both informative and human terms. Other notable contributions include Robi Botos’ original score, a very good standalone animated sequence, and glimpses of Auschwitz survivor Ceija Stojka’s striking paintings of her wartime experience.

Popular on Variety

A People Uncounted

Canada

Production: An Urbinder Films production. (International sales: Urbinder, Toronto.) Produced by Tom Rasky, Marc Swenker, Aaron Yeger, Stephen C. Whitehead. Executive producers, Lenny Binder, Rasky. Directed, written by Aaron Yeger.

Crew: Camera (color, HD), Stephen C. Whitehead; editor, Kurt Engfehr; music, Robi Botos; art directors, Whitehead, Kyle Mowat; sound, Adam Parsons, Scott Brachmayer, Derek Oxley; sound designer, J.R. Fountain; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Matthew Chan. Reviewed at Santa Barbara Film Festival (Social Justice), Feb. 3, 2012. (Also in Montreal World Film Festival.) Running time: 99 MIN.

With: With: Hugo Hollenreiner, Ceija Stojka, Romani Rose, Ronald Lee, Ian Hancock, Bill Duna. (English, Romanian, Czech, Russian, German, Hungarian dialogue.)

More Film

  • Johnnie To Quits Taiwan Golden Horse

    Johnnie To Quits Golden Horse Awards as China Builds Pressure

    Leading Hong Kong film maker Johnnie To has dropped out of the Golden Horse Awards, where he was set to be president of the jury deciding the prize winners. The awards, which take place and are organized from Taiwan, have long been considered the most prestigious prized in Chinese-language cinema. However they are currently under [...]

  • Zeroville

    Film Review: 'Zeroville'

    I’m tired of hearing how some novels are “impossible to adapt.” Balderdash! Just because some books don’t lend themselves to being translated from page to screen doesn’t mean that the attempt ought not to be made. Just ask James Franco, who’s shown a speed freak’s determination to tackle some of the unlikeliest literary adaptations of [...]

  • Red Penguins review

    Toronto Film Review: 'Red Penguins'

    “Red Penguins” is a cautionary tale with particular resonance in the context of our current bizarre intertwining with Russia, the country that interfered in the last U.S. presidential election and is led by the POTUS’ apparent BFF. This wild tale of attempted transnational commerce just after the demise of the USSR in the 1990s chronicles [...]

  • Danny Ramirez'On My Block' TV show

    Danny Ramirez to Star in Film Adaptation of 'Root Letter' Video Game (EXCLUSIVE)

    An English-language film adaptation of Japanese video game “Root Letter,” starring Danny Ramirez, is in production in the U.S. through Akatsuki Entertainment USA. Besides Ramirez (“Top Gun: Maverick,” “Assassination Nation”), the film stars Keana Marie (“Huge in France,” “Live in Pieces”) and Lydia Hearst (“The Haunting of Sharon Tate,” “Z Nation”). With a screenplay by [...]

  • Screen writer Beau WillimonMary Queen of

    Beau Willimon Re-Elected as President of Writers Guild of America East

    Beau Willimon, the playwright and showrunner who launched Netflix’s “House of Cards,” has been re-elected without opposition to a two-year term as president of the Writers Guild of America East. Willimon also ran unopposed in 2017 to succeed Michael Winship. Kathy McGee was elected to the vice president slot over Phil Pilato. Secretary-treasurer Bob Schneider [...]

  • Running With the Devil review

    Film Review: 'Running With the Devil'

    A retired Navy SEAL who for a time was a military advisor on the Colombian drug trade, Jason Cabell conceived his first solo feature as writer-director to tell the story of that particular commerce “from the point of view of the drugs.” The result isn’t exactly a docudrama indictment like “Traffic,” a thriller a la [...]

  • Sweetheart review

    Blumhouse's 'Sweetheart' Sets October Digital Release From Universal (EXCLUSIVE)

    After making waves at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, the Blumhouse project “Sweetheart” is set to hit digital and on demand platforms. Universal Pictures Home Entertainment will offer the film on all major streaming hubs and paid video on demand come Oct. 22, unleashing the creature feature which stars Kiersey Clemons in a harrowing tale [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content