×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Tune deaf

Eye on the Oscars: The Music

It wouldn’t be Oscar season if the Academy’s music branch didn’t drum up some kind of controversy. This year the group invited more bad press for its collective decision to nominate only two songs (from “Muppets” and “Rio”) — the lowest number since Oscar started rewarding songwriters in 1934.

Reactions ranged from disgust (studio music chiefs) to outrage (music critics) to mystified (John Q. Public). And following on a series of widely perceived missteps (snubbing, among others, the Cher song from 2010’s “Burlesque,” the Springsteen song from 2008’s “The Wrestler” and a clutch of Eddie Vedder songs from 2007’s “Into the Wild”), the branch now faces a crisis.

Many observers — including some high-profile songwriter members — are calling for a re-thinking of the rules to eliminate the 7-year-old grading system and simply nominate the five top vote-getters. Says one top music exec: “Let’s get a branch and a rulebook that knows how to nominate awards with integrity and that can be respected as the pinnacle of the craft, not as an irrelevant punchline.”

There were plenty of candidates. Thirty-nine songs were deemed eligible this year, among them award-worthy tunes from “Gnomeo and Juliet,” “The Help,” “Albert Nobbs,” “Winnie the Pooh,” “Captain America,” “Hugo” and “Footloose.”

Only two (“Man or Muppet” and “Real in Rio”) received the necessary 8.25 average among voters who chose to participate in the song balloting — and if you’ve entered a song of your own, you’re not allowed to participate, another rule with which some members have a problem.

There was far less controversy in the score category, although the early disqualification of scores that included Cliff Martinez’s talked-about “Drive” music and Conrad Pope’s well-liked “My Week With Marilyn” themes caused a stir in December.

The big news when the noms were announced Jan. 24 was the crowning of five-time Oscar winner John Williams with a new all-time mark of 47 noms, which topped Alfred Newman’s 45, a record that had stood since 1970. Williams is now the most-nominated living individual and second-most overall (behind Walt Disney).

Most of the score noms were predictable, as veterans Williams, Howard Shore and Alberto Iglesias were joined by first-timer Ludovic Bource for his wall-to-wall score for the mostly silent “The Artist.”

It’s also an international crowd: the U.S.-born Williams joined by Canadian-born Shore, Spanish-born Iglesias and French-born Bource.

That doesn’t mean there weren’t surprises, however. Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, who won last year for “The Social Network,” were overlooked for their edgy synth score for “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo”; Thomas Newman wasn’t nominated for “The Help”; and the prolific Alexandre Desplat missed out despite 2011 scores for “The Ides of March,” “Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close” and the “Harry Potter” finale.

There are 232 voting members in the music branch, according to Acad execs; they are all composers, songwriters or music editors. Studio music execs and music supervisors are generally excluded from the process.

Eye on the Oscars: The Music
Tune deaf
The nominees:
Score | Song

More Music

  • Huey Lewis

    BMG Signs Huey Lewis and the News

    Huey Lewis and the News, the band that soundtracked much of the 1980s, will return with a new album in 2019. The group has signed with BMG, the company announced today (Jan. 18), setting the stage for the tenth studio album and the first time they’re releasing original music in 18 years. Formed by Lewis [...]

  • Jordan Feldstein

    Roc Nation Seeks $11 Million From Insurer in Jordan Feldstein's Death

    Roc Nation filed a federal lawsuit Friday seeking $11 million from its insurance carrier following the death of Maroon 5 manager Jordan Feldstein. Roc Nation, a joint venture of Jay-Z and Live Nation Entertainment, partnered with Feldstein’s Career Artist Management in 2016. At the time, Roc Nation says it took out a “key man” life [...]

  • mike-posner

    Album Review: Mike Posner's 'A Real Good Kid'

    From the tone of such hits as his 2010 debut “Cooler Than Me” and 2015’s  “I Took A Pill In Ibiza,” singing, songwriting pop-hop beardo Mike Posner had a seemingly breezy take on life, love and responsibility. If you could have squeezed together the two Justins — Timberlake and Bieber (Posner has written for the latter) [...]

  • neyla pekarek

    Neyla Pekarek on Leaving the Lumineers and Her 'Women-Empowering' Solo Debut

    “I feel really liberated to be releasing my own record and my own music,” says cellist and singer Neyla Pekarek, who, in October, announced her departure from folk band the Lumineers. Now signed to S-Curve Records as a solo artist, her debut album “Rattlesnake” drops Friday. “I would definitely call this record a feminist record, a [...]

  • Fyre Festival Documentaries: The 10 Most

    Fyre Festival Documentaries: The 10 Most Outrageous Moments

    It is perhaps only fitting that two documentaries about the disastrous Fyre Festival, one of the most high-profile fraudulent failures in history, would arrive during the same week — a fitting cap on a tragicomedy of errors that, as both films outline in excruciating detail, unfolded like a slow-motion plane crash in the spring of [...]

  • Oscars Predictions 2018 Illustration

    Academy Awards: Final Oscar Predictions in All Categories

    Nominations for the 91st Academy Awards will be announced on Tuesday, Jan. 22. Below are In Contention’s final predictions in all 24 categories. Bradley Cooper’s “A Star Is Born” and Alfonso Cuarón’s “Roma” lead the way with 10 expected nominations apiece, while we forecast eight for Yorgos Lanthimos’ “The Favourite” and seven each for Damien [...]

  • Nick Redman

    Nick Redman, Documentary Filmmaker and Soundtrack Producer, Dies at 63

    Nick Redman, Oscar-nominated documentary filmmaker, award-winning soundtrack producer and co-founder of the Twilight Time video label, died Thursday afternoon, Jan. 17, at a Santa Monica Hospital, after a two-year battle with cancer. He was 63. He was nominated for an Academy Award as producer of the 1996 documentary “The Wild Bunch: An Album in Montage,” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content