New Delhi lawsuit challenges ratings data

Mipcom 2012

In August, news network New Delhi Television (NDTV) took the somewhat unprecedented legal action of suing Television Audience Measurement Media Research India — a joint venture of the Nielsen Co. and Kantar Media — by claiming $810 million in advertising revenue was lost over eight years because of alleged manipulation and corruption of viewership data.

“People have always questioned Nielsen,” says Erwin Ephron, a veteran media research advertising exec who worked for Nielsen and now runs the New York-based Ephron Consultancy. “But no one gets to the point of suing them.”

These days, Ephron says there is much more oversight when it comes to TV viewer data in the U.S. and around the world.

For example, in the U.S., he says, “There are around 100 research companies all competing with each other. They have a very good idea of what the data responds to.”

The U.S. also has an ombudsman, the Media Ratings Council.

NDTV has subscribed to TAM Media India since 1998. The ratings agency has been a key part in helping the territory achieve its $2.3 billion TV advertising market.

India has a population of 1.2 billion, with an estimated 129 million homes with TV services.

TAM Media India says it is among the top five data measuring services in the world, with the largest sample size comprising 36,000 individuals across 162 cities and towns, covered by 8,150 people meters, according to its website.

But NDTV says these figures are too low and that TAM Media India continues to publish ratings despite repeated recommendations to raise the sample size.

Typically, securing a bigger viewership sample means getting more money from TV networks.

“It’s up to Nielsen and the market stakeholders to determine what level of service can be provided for what reasonable price,” says Todd Juenger, media analyst for investment research firm Bernstein Research. “I’m sure Nielsen would be happy to add to the sample if it was paid more.”

Nielsen execs wouldn’t comment about the case, but WPP Group — the advertising agency holding company that owns Kantar — filed legal papers to dismiss the suit for a number of reasons, including that the filing was done in the wrong jurisdiction (New York) and that NDTV’s lawsuit erroneously names business units of Kantar and Nielsen and personnel that aren’t involved in the TAM Media India service.

WPP says NDTV’s legal efforts are driven by declining ratings.

“The case is nothing more than a desperate attempt by the defendant, a television station in New Delhi, to drum up media coverage and divert attention from the real reasons its programs have had low ratings and its financial performance has been abysmal for the last five years,” says WPP in its legal filing.

“It has gotten publicity and it’s on my radar,” says Brad Adgate, senior VP of New York-based media agency Horizon Media. “But I don’t think it’ll have any effect in the U.S.,” he adds.

Ephron says, “Marketers can be more impressed with the data than the effect. Nielsen numbers are intermediaries. The data alone doesn’t mean anything. The question is, how much does the advertising deliver?”

A rare lawsuit recently filed by an India-based TV group against a local TV rating service for alleged viewer data malpractice doesn’t look like it’s going to change the way media buyers and sellers operate, say analysts.

More TV


    Marvin Kren on His Upcoming Netflix Original Thriller Series ‘Freud’

    “Freud,” Netflix’s upcoming mystery thriller from director by Marvin Kren, places a young Sigmund, before his establishment as a worldwide medical icon, in the middle of a brutal 19th century murder case in Vienna. A Vienna native himself, Kren won numerous awards for his work in TV (“Four Blocks”) and film (“Rammbock,” “Blood Glacier”). In addition [...]

  • Heide Schwochow, Constantin Lieb and Christian

    ‘Transitniki’ Wins Trip to Lille’s Series Mania at Berlin CoPro Series 2020

    Reciprocating an exchange which saw Series Mania 2019 Co-Pro Pitching winner “Capturing Big Mouth” participate at this year’s Berlin CoPro Series, German project “Transitniki” will make the return trip to Lille next month, having been selected by Series Mania representatives in Berlin. From Germany’s Rohfilm Factory, “Transitniki” is set in 1985, behind the Iron Curtain, [...]


    Endemol Shine’s Lars Blomgren Talks Growth in Scripted, the New Drama Series Landscape

    BERLIN — In the run-up to the Berlinale Series Market, the Endemol Shine Group announced the launch of a new and powerful scripted label in Berlin, MadeFor Film, headed by joint CEOs, Nanni Erben and Gunnar Juncken. Here, “The Bridge” executive producer Lars Blomgren, who was appointed Endemol Shine head of scripted, EMEA in June [...]

  • Mystery Road 2

    Berlin: New Wave of Australian Series Brings Indigenous Stories Into Focus

    A new wave of Australian drama series has shined a light on Indigenous cultures, with Aboriginal-led productions reshaping the domestic market while finding a global platform for Indigenous stories. What that might mean for Indigenous Australians was the focus of “Mainstream, Genre and Indigenous Perspectives: New Wave Australian Series,” a panel that took place Tuesday [...]

  • Branka Katic Branka Katic, a cast

    Beta Film Drives into Europe’s Adria Region, Investing in Drugi Plan (EXCLUSIVE)

    BERLIN — Underscoring its ambitions for Central and Eastern Europe, “Babylon Berlin” and “Gomorrah’s” Beta Film has just taken a majority stake in Zagreb-based Drugi Plan, producers of Netflix pick-up “The Paper” and “Success,” HBO Europe’s first HBO Adria original. The investment builds on Beta Film owner Jan Mojto’s determination to plow ever more into [...]

  • From left, Democratic presidential candidates, former

    CBS News Throws a Chaotic Democratic Debate (Column)

    Some of the blame for CBS News’s chaotic, messy Democratic Party primary debate Tuesday night can be laid at the feet of the party itself — to a degree, CBS was depicting the chaos and mess of a party badly divided in the midst of a bruising campaign. But a share of ignominy also goes [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content