Judge upholds Par’s rights to ‘Godfather’

Denies Puzo estate's bid to scrap studio's 1969 pact with author

A New York federal judge has refused to sever Paramount’s rights to future “Godfather” film projects as part of an ongoing dispute over the ability of the estate of Mario Puzo to license literary sequels to the Corleone saga.

U.S. District Judge Alison J. Nathan dismissed the estate’s effort to cancel and rescind a 1969 agreement between Puzo and Paramount, which led to the classic “Godfather” films, because the studio sought to prevent the estate from publishing “The Family Corleone,” a sequel novel released earlier this year. In her decision issued Wednesday, she also rejected claims of tortious interference, but ruled that the estate can continue to pursue its claim for breach of contract.

The legal dispute started in February, when Paramount sued Puzo’s son and executor of his estate, Anthony, claiming that the pending publication of “The Family Corleone” and the 2006 publication of “The Godfather’s Revenge” violated its copyright and trademark in “The Godfather.”

But the Puzo estate, represented by Bert Fields, fought back by filing its own countersuit, charging that Paramount was claiming rights that it did not have. In doing so, the estate argued, Par interfered with publishing contracts. The result was a breach of the 1969 agreement, the estate claimed, as it had an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. “The Family Corleone” was published this year, but under an interim settlement agreement with Paramount in which funds that the estate received were placed into escrow.

Nathan noted that the 1969 agreement contained “no express contractual provision in which Paramount agreed to refrain from litigation or from contesting the estate’s interpretation of the rights granted and reserved under the contract.” She noted that Paramount’s “only express obligations under the contract” were to pay Puzo $50,000 plus a possible $25,000 depending on sales of the novel, and credit in the film.

Nathan did not render a decision on whether the estate or Paramount owns the book publishing rights to “Godfather” sequels. Central to the dispute, she noted, is language that was struck from the 1969 agreement that would have given Paramount the right to “publish said work and/or any versions or adaptations thereof, or any part or parts thereof, and to vend copies thereof.”

Paramount contends that the language was excised because Puzo already published “The Godfather,” and aside from rights to publish the original novel, retained no other rights in the saga. The estate claims the striking of the language meant that the author was reserving all book publishing rights to sequels and followups.

Nathan has scheduled a status conference in the case on Jan. 11.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Mick Jagger, Donald Sutherland. Actors Mick

    'The Burnt Orange Heresy' With Mick Jagger, Donald Sutherland Sells Worldwide

    HanWay Films has closed out worldwide sales on “The Burnt Orange Heresy,” the art-heist film that screened in Venice and Toronto. The movie stars Mick Jagger, Claes Bang, and Donald Sutherland. It closed the Venice Film Festival. In addition to North America, where Giuseppe Capotondi’s film will open in spring 2020, SPC has acquired rights [...]

  • Between Worlds Nicolas Cage

    Nicolas Cage, Alex Wolff to Star in Pulse Films’ Truffle Hunter Movie ‘Pig’

    Nicolas Cage is a truffle hunter who wants his pig back in “Pig,” which started production Monday in Oregon. The film, which Michael Sarnoski will direct from his own script, will also star Alex Wolff (“Hereditary”). Pulse Films, BlockBox Entertainment, Valparaiso Pictures and Cage’s Saturn Pictures are producing in association with Escape Artists and Sweet [...]

  • Sid Haig Dies Devil's Rejects

    Sid Haig, Horror Actor in Rob Zombie Trilogy, Dies at 80

    Sid Haig, known for his role as Captain Spaulding in Rob Zombie’s “House of 1000 Corpses” trilogy, died Saturday. He was 80. His wife announced the news on Instagram. Haig had a fall several weeks ago and suffered serious breathing complications after arriving at the hospital. He died of a lung infection. “On Saturday, September [...]

  • France Boasts Europe's Highest Number of

    France Still Boasts Europe's Highest Number of Theater Screens Per Capita

    France, Europe’s No. 1 movie-going nation, still boasts the continent’s highest number of screens per capita, according to a new study conducted by the French National Film Board (CNC). As of last year, France had 2,040 theaters and 6,000 screens – 69 more screens than in 2017. Out of the 2,040 theaters, 226 are multiplexes. [...]

  • Arab Genre Film

    Arab Genre Films Get Boost From Beirut's Maskoon Lab (EXCLUSIVE)

    Just as Netflix tries to gain traction in the Middle East by backing local genre series, such as its first Arab original, “Jinn,” from Jordan, and Egypt’s upcoming “Paranormal,” Beirut’s Maskoon Fantastic Film Festival is launching the region’s first platform dedicated to genre films. Five Arabic-language projects, ranging from a zombie comedy to a supernatural [...]

  • Simon Yam in "Little Q"

    China Box Office: Hong Kong Dog Film 'Little Q' Leads the Pack

    As China gears up for a big political anniversary and national holiday, its box office has been dominated by innocuous animal films and local fare capable of keeping censors happy but unable to make that huge of a splash. None of the top four weekend titles has scored more than 7 out of 10 on [...]

  • Vendrá-la-muerte-y-tendrá-tus-ojos

    Watch Trailer for ‘Death Will Come and Shall Have Your Eyes’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    SAN SEBASTIAN — “Death Will Come And Shall Have Your Eyes” Italy’s Cesare Pavese wrote memorably in a poem that enchanted Chilean film director José Luis Torres Leiva a decade or so back. Now he delivers a film of that title which world premieres at San Sebastian in main competition and talks about death without, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content