You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Every tuner’s a miracle

Music for Screens: Winter 2012

No genre gives studio executives greater pause than the musical. Given the expense, scope and spotty track record at the box office, tuners pose some of the riskiest undertakings for the already risk-averse studio topper.

Still, thanks to a long storied history with the genre that has resulted in such classics as “The Sound of Music,” “West Side Story” and “Cabaret,” Hollywood continues to try to hit the right note with the increasingly rarified form. Though 2011 produced just one tuner, Disney’s “The Muppets,” the multiplex will be teeming with song in 2012 as a handful of musicals are set to unspool over the coming months, led by big-budget entrants “Rock of Ages” and “Les Miserables.”

“It’s cyclical,” explains helmer Phyllida Lloyd, whose “Mamma Mia!” (2008) became the highest-grossing tuner of all time with a $610 million worldwide tally and sparked the latest craze. “There’s a big success on the screen, and then everyone says, ‘Wow, we must do musicals.’ It takes a few years to generate them. They’re incredibly complex to put together.”

First up for the sing-along theatergoer is Warner Bros.’ “Joyful Noise,” a $32 million production fully financed by Alcon. Directed by musical veteran Todd Graff, who helmed “Camp” and penned several drafts of “Dreamgirls” before Bill Condon took the reins, the film opens Jan. 13 and marks Dolly Parton’s return to the bigscreen after a two-decade absence.

“We saw this as an opportunity to use music amid a very uplifting story — the kind of story we are known for,” says Alcon topper Andrew Kosove of gospel-inspired tuner, which marks the first foray into the genre for the company behind “The Blind Side.” “We see it as something we can make a lot of money on and be creatively stimulating at the same time.”

Though Alcon bought the “Joyful Noise” pitch in the room, Graff says he met with plenty of resistance when shopping the project, which also stars Queen Latifah and Keke Palmer.

“Disney never passed; they never even responded,” quips Graff of the typical response he received. “It’s sad to say, but the thing we kept hearing was, ‘African-American films don’t translate internationally.’ I said, ‘I think a great African-American film will translate internationally.’ Beyond that, I don’t think of this as an African-American film. But it was really difficult to get studios over that hump.”

Like musicals in general, musicals with African-American leads have shown varying degrees of success at the box-office. Rob Marshall’s $45 million “Chicago,” which featured black cast members Latifah and Taye Diggs, became one of the most successful musicals of all time, earning $307 worldwide and a best picture Oscar. Condon’s “Dreamgirls” performed well domestically ($103 million), but only so-so internationally ($52 million). And the Andre Benjamin vehicle “Idlewild” nabbed a mere $13 million at the box office, almost all of it domestically.

Like Alcon, Sony bucked Hollywood convention by green-lighting the African American-led “Sparkle” remake, which it will release Aug. 10 through its TriStar label. The film, which aims to revive Whitney Houston’s career, poses a relatively modest risk for the studio, costing $10 million. Likewise, the studio says it is high on — though hasn’t yet greenlit — a big-budget “Annie” remake, which would mark a teaming of producers Will Smith and Jay-Z and star Smith’s daughter, Willow.

Still, the genre has posed nothing but headaches for Sony in recent years. A pricey big-screen adaptation of Broadway hit “Rent” earned just $32 million worldwide and Beatles tuner “Across the Universe” mustered up a mere $29 million globally. Similarly, the Christina Aguilera-Cher topliner “Burlesque” cost $55 million and made less than $90 million worldwide.

Meanwhile, New Line/Warner Bros. and Universal are swinging for the fences with their respective tuners, “Rock of Ages” and “Les Miserables.”

Directed by Adam Shankman, the $70 million “Rock of Ages” features an A-list cast led by Tom Cruise and Amy Adams and beloved tunes, a la “Mamma Mia!” Warner Bros. has carved out a prime June 1 slot for the pic, which is already testing extremely well, according to a source.

“I have giant movie stars in ’80s drag singing classic rock karaoke in a giant party setting,” jokes Shankman, who directed the surprise hit “Hairspray” for New Line, a film that earned $203 million worldwide. “Trying to teach audiences new songs is always a little bit challenging. That’s why ‘Mamma Mia!’ and, fingers crossed, ‘Rock of Ages’ work.”

Shankman says despite Hollywood’s love-hate relationship with the genre, the time is right for an influx of musicals.

“If you look at what’s successful in television right now, it’s escapism,” explains Shankman, who has tuners set up all around town including a hip-hop “Bye Bye Birdie” at Sony. “I think musicals allow the ultimate in escapism.”

Likewise, Universal has assembled an all-star team with “Les Miserables,” which will hit screens Dec. 7. The project marks director Tom Hooper’s follow-up to “The King’s Speech” and will star Hugh Jackman, Anne Hathaway and Russell Crowe. Other A-list stars are vying for key open roles for the pic, which is scheduled to begin lensing in March.

Despite such build-ups, big-name casts and directors with proven track records still can’t guarantee a hit musical. Marshall’s “Nine,” inspired by Fellini’s “8 1/2,” featured no less than five Oscar winners led by Daniel Day-Lewis, Nicole Kidman and Marion Cotillard at a cost of $80 million. Largely financed by Relativity and released by the Weinstein Co., the much-vaunted extravaganza imploded at the boxoffice with a paltry $54 million worldwide.

Similarly, the Tim Burton-helmed Johnny Depp-topliner “Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street,” about a murderous barber and his meat-pie-making accomplice, earned $53 million domestically, a far cry from their next collaboration, “Alice in Wonderland” (more than $1 billion worldwide).

Lloyd says today’s audiences crave a relatable story, like “Mamma Mia!” and “Rock of Ages.”

“‘Mamma Mia!’ wasn’t about characters who were a size zero who could put their legs behind their heads and then wrap them around the back of their neck,” she jokes. “It was about you and me, women of a certain age running around the streets when they’ve had too much to drink and put on an ABBA record.”

Meanwhile, Shankman contends that though studios remain skittish about musicals, they can be swayed by a director with a clear understanding of the intended audience.

“Every studio is suspect about making the right one,” he says. “Not every one is a slam dunk, especially originals. But if a filmmaker can look you in the eye and say, ‘I get this. I know who this appeals to. I know how to sell this,’ (that’s essential).”

And despite its recent musical disappointments like “The Producers,” which cost $45 million and made only $38 million worldwide, Universal remains Hollywood’s most bullish studio when it comes to musicals, with such projects in development as “Wicked,” “American Idiot,” “Carmen,” “Jesus Christ Superstar,” a “Mamma Mia!” sequel and a remake of the Parton hit “The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas” (though Universal put the Tony Award-winning musical “In the Heights” into turnaround). The studio will release the year’s fifth tuner with the $18 million “Pitch Perfect,”

“Universal is killing themselves to make ‘Wicked’ right now, but it’s not done with the theatrical run yet,” notes Shankman. “But who wouldn’t want to make it? It’s a huge international property.”


More Music

  • Mary J. Blige and Rihanna

    Rihanna Presents Mary J. Blige With BET Lifetime Achievement Award

    Rihanna took the Microsoft Theater stage on June 23 to present Mary J. Blige with the BET Lifetime Achievement Award. Hailing the legendary singer for her style and sound, Rihanna also made mention of Blige’s history-making two Oscar nominations in the same year, for best actress and original song for “Mudbound.” Accepting the trophy, Blige [...]

  • Offset, Takeoff and Quavo of MigosBET

    BET Awards' Carpet Colored Blue in Honor of Late Nipsey Hussle

    The 2019 edition of the BET Awards doubled as a celebration of late rapper Nipsey Hussle, who was killed in March outside of his Marathon clothing store in Los Angeles. In honor of the man affectionately known as “Nip,” the carpet was colored blue. “The marathon continues” was a common refrain on the carpet (as [...]

  • Cardi B accepts the album of

    BET Awards 2019: The Complete Winners List

    The 2019 BET Awards kicked off with a performance by Cardi B, who came into the night leading with 7 nominations and, not surprisingly, picked up the award for album of the year for her “Invasion of Privacy.” Other top nominees included Drake with 5, and Beyonce, Travis Scott and J. Cole, each with four. [...]


    Quality Control's Coach K Says Abortion Ban Has Already Impacted Business in Atlanta

    A who’s who of black entertainment and tech filled the Beverly Hilton Hotel ballroom on June 22 for the 4th annual Culture Creators Innovators and Leaders Awards brunch. Honorees included Byron Allen, who received the Icon Award; actress and executive producer Marsai Martin, who was named Innovator of the Year; and Quality Control Music founders [...]

  • Juice WRLD Talks Next Album, Streaming

    Juice WRLD Talks Next Album, Audiomack Award at Private BET Weekend Dinner

    On the Saturday evening of BET Weekend, Juice WRLD held an exclusive private dinner and celebration for his Best New Artist nomination at Sunday’s 2019 BET Awards. Presented by Audiomack and BMG, select friends and top executives from Interscope, BMG and GradeA Productions conjoined at BOA Steakhouse on Sunset Blvd. in West Hollywood to congratulate [...]

  • Raconteurs Salute Beatles With 'Butcher Cover'

    Raconteurs Salute Beatles With 'Butcher Cover' Parody Hidden Within New LP Sleeve

    Raconteurs fans who thought they heard a hint of the Beatles embedded within the group’s new album, “Help Us Stranger,” may have been more intuitive than they realized. There’s a more blatant homage to the Fab Four in the LP that was sent out to Third Man Vault subscribers, but it’s not in the grooves [...]

  • Musician Dave Bartholomew on stage at

    Dave Bartholomew, Rock and Roll Hall of Famer, Dies at 100

    Dave Bartholomew, a New Orleans music pioneer best known for his songs with R&B legend Fat Domino, has died. He was 100. Bartholomew, who co-wrote and produced such hits as “Ain’t That a Shame,” ″I’m Walkin’” and “Let the Four Winds Blow,” died Sunday in a New Orleans hospital, his eldest son Dave Bartholomew Jr. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content