×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Imposter

With production values aplenty, "The Imposter" uses atmospheric reenactments and stark, soul-bearing interviews to explore a mind-boggling case of false identity.

With:
With: Frederic Bourdin, Carey Gibson, Beverly Dollarhide, Charlie Parker, Nancy Fisher, Bruce Perry, Philip French. Cast: Adam O'Brian, Anna Ruben, Cathy Dresbach, Alan Teichman, Ivan Villanueva, Maria Jesus Hoyos.

“For as long as I can remember, I wanted to be someone else.” So begins the twisty tale of a French conman who duped a Texas family into believing he was their long-lost son — or did he? With production values aplenty, “The Imposter” makes slick work of its wily subject, using atmospheric reenactments and stark, soul-baring interviews to explore a mind-boggling case of false identity. The compelling treatment suggests a reasonable chance at theatrical play; pay cablers and VOD labels could also run with this title, which crackles with the open-ended intrigue of a good “Unsolved Mysteries” episode.

Swarthy, heavily accented 23-year-old Frederic Bourdin looks nothing like Nicholas Barclay, who disappeared from a rural San Antonio-area community at age 13. But that didn’t stop the compulsive missing-child impersonator from adopting the teen’s identity in a case so strange, it has inspired countless news stories and even a previous film adaptation, “The Chameleon.” Whereas that pic (made last year by Jean-Paul Salome) approached the subject from the point of view of the family, whose tragedy was amplified by the discovery that this interloper was not their long-lost son, “The Imposter” focuses on Bourdin, making clear from the get-go that his ploy was a scam.

In taking this approach, director Bart Layton respects his audience’s intelligence, shaping the narrative like a classic thriller while leaving plenty of room for us to supply our own psychological detective work. How could the family ignore the obvious differences between Nicholas and his doppelganger? The standard story holds that they were so desperate to reunite with their son, they would have believed anything. But that doesn’t gel, as testimony from neighbors and fresh clues dug up by a private investigator suggest that Nicholas was often at odds with his family.

A long, seemingly candid interview with Bourdin serves as the pic’s backbone, feeding seamlessly into staged versions of the stories he relays. One moment, the wickedly smug imposter is describing his long-running tactic of passing himself off as an orphan in order to be placed in a children’s home, the next, a startlingly similar-looking actor is finishing his sentences within a reenactment scene. The effect is not only slick, but unsettling, drawing attention to the fact that the film, like the incidents it depicts, involves a certain bending of the truth.

With a magician’s skill, Layton introduces complications in the story where they will deliver maximum impact. The first twist comes as the opening title appears, following an early round of testimony from the key players (who include Nicholas’ mother and sister, later joined by a number of authorities and investigators): In Linares, Spain, police receive a call from a man claiming to have found a missing kid, only the caller is himself the “child” in question. This early feint preps us for the many unpredictable turns in the road ahead, which range from speculating what might happen should the real Nicholas return to the filmmaker actually participating in a hunt for the poor boy’s grave.

Launched at Sundance two years after “Catfish,” this unnerving portrait of identity manipulation proves rich enough to inspire a wide range of debates over the motives of the various characters involved. Though the prospect of familial affection, not fame, seems to have been the primary driver for his deception, given a sociopath of Bourdin’s caliber, the most gratifying form of reward is surely being made the star of such a film.

The Imposter

Docu - U.K.

Production: An A&E Indie Films, Film 4, Channel 4 presentation of a RAW production in association with Red Box Films and Passion Pictures. (International sales: Protagonist Pictures, London) Produced by Dimitri Doganis. Executive producers, Molly Thompson, Robert Debitetto, Robert Sharenow, Katherine Butler, Tabitha Jackson. Co-producer, Poppy Dixon. Directed by Bart Layton.

Crew: Camera (color, HD), Erik Alexander Wilson, Lydna Hall, editor, Andrew Hulme; music, Anne Nikitin; music supervisors, Liz Gallacher, Kathleen Hasay; production designer, Marcia Carols; art directors, Mariona Julbe, Vanesa Monreal, Sonia Aranzabal; set decorator, Jon Oswald; sound (Dolby Digital), Nick Walker, Kaye Charles Cruz, Brian Albritten, Allen Green, Mike Cooper, Charles Ethridge; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Andrew Stirk; sound designer, Paul Davies; line producer, Vanessa Tovell; casting, Cecilia Bayonas, Danielle Thompson. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (World Cinema -- competing), Jan. 23, 2012. Running time: 95 MIN.

Cast: With: Frederic Bourdin, Carey Gibson, Beverly Dollarhide, Charlie Parker, Nancy Fisher, Bruce Perry, Philip French. Cast: Adam O'Brian, Anna Ruben, Cathy Dresbach, Alan Teichman, Ivan Villanueva, Maria Jesus Hoyos.

More Scene

  • Director Peter JacksonWarner Bros. Pictures THEY

    Peter Jackson Talks Transition From 'Hobbit' Movies to World War I Documentary

    Peter Jackson remains a bit astounded at his transition four years ago from the Shire of Middle Earth to the French battlefields of World War I. Jackson introduced his documentary “They Shall Not Grow Old” Friday night at the Linwood Dunn Theatre in Hollywood, four weeks after it aired on Armistice Day on the BBC. [...]

  • Hillary Clinton'Network' play opening night, New

    Hillary Clinton Attends Opening of Broadway's 'Network'

    A 1976 film might not be expected to translate seamlessly to Broadway in 2018, but for the cast and creative team behind “Network,” which premiered Thursday night with Hillary Clinton in the audience, the story still feels uncomfortably close to home. “It was a satire then, and now it’s documentary realism,” said Lee Hall, who [...]

  • Children's Defense Fund

    Angela Bassett, Conan O'Brien Honor Young Students at Children's Defense Fund Gala

    Awards season may be right around the corner, but on Thursday, Hollywood took a break from the glitz and glam to celebrate five high school students who have excelled academically despite facing extreme adversity both at home and in the classroom. The 29th annual Beat the Odds Awards ceremony at the Skirball Cultural Center featured [...]

  • Dolly Parton attends the world premiere

    Dolly Parton Hopes to Perform 'Dumplin'' Song at the Golden Globes

    It’s not easy to upstage Jennifer Aniston. But everyone at Thursday night’s premiere of her new Netflix flick, “Dumplin’,” seemed to be singing the praises of Dolly Parton, who earlier in the day received a Golden Globe nomination for “Girl in the Movies,” one of half a dozen new songs she wrote for the film. [...]

  • Lena WaitheVariety's Power of Women, Arrivals,

    Who Lena Waithe Thinks Should Replace Kevin Hart as Oscar Host

    Lena Waithe thinks Kevin Hart could have handled his Oscar debacle in a much better way. “I kind of wish that he would have taken a moment to let it be a teachable moment and to say, ‘Hey, what I said wasn’t right and I want to make that right,’ not just to keep the [...]

  • Christie Brinkley32nd Annual Footwear News Achievement

    Christie Brinkley at 64: 'Women My Age Cannot Allow the Numbers to Define Them'

    Christie Brinkley may be turning 65 next year, but don’t you dare try to tell her what she should — or shouldn’t — wear. “I think women my age cannot allow the numbers to define them. We need to constantly redefine the number,” Brinkley told Variety on Tuesday at the Footwear News Achievement Awards in New [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content