You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Great Expectations

Arriving mere months after a miniseries version also presented by the BBC, "Great Expectations" is a passable feature-length adaptation that does little to burnish the estimable screen legacy of a Dickens classic.

Pip - Jeremy Irvine Mr. Jaggers - Robbie Coltrane Miss Havisham - Helena Bonham Carter Magwitch - Ralph Fiennes Wemmick - Ewen Bremner Joe Gargery - Jason Flemyng Estella - Holliday Grainger Uncle Pumblechook - David Walliams Mrs. Joe - Sally Hawkins

Arriving mere months after a miniseries version also presented by the BBC, “Great Expectations” is a passable feature-length adaptation that does little to burnish the estimable screen legacy of a Dickens classic. Working from a tightly compressed screenplay by David Nicholls, director Mike Newell strikes the beats of a deservedly oft-told tale with dour competence but little in the way of dramatic inspiration or visual flair. Still, juicy performances by Helena Bonham Carter and Ralph Fiennes in the designated scene-stealing roles of Miss Havisham and Abel Magwitch should prove enticing enough for arthouse patrons and Anglophiles to respond with favor.


Fiennes and Bonham Carter made a memorably witchy pair as Lord Voldemort and Bellatrix Lestrange in the Harry Potter films (one of which, 2005’s “Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire,” was directed by Newell), and the actors bring their dark gifts to two scarcely less frightening roles here. Once again Fiennes has the task of scaring a little boy in a graveyard, energizing the film’s fog-cloaked opening scenes as an escaped convict who has a fateful encounter with a young orphan named Pip (Toby Irvine).


Popular on Variety

Making a less assaultive but no less vivid impression is Bonham Carter as Miss Havisham, the hard-hearted spinster who has turned her estate into a cobwebbed mausoleum and her pretty adopted daughter, Estella (Helena Barlow), into a weapon against the male sex. Looking not so different from the title role she played in “Tim Burton’s Corpse Bride,” Bonham Carter is an inspired choice for a role that typically skews older; her striking beauty, still plainly visible beneath her ghostly pallor, allows the character’s distant personal tragedy to feel freshly inflicted.


Elsewhere, however, the vitality seems to have been largely drained from this rote retelling. Dickens’ wondrous tapestry of incident, character and detail is reduced to a single thread of one-damned-thing-after-another developments, and the impact of memorable supporting characters such as Pip’s harridan-like older sister (Sally Hawkins) and the odious Uncle Pumblechook (David Walliams) feels particularly truncated. The bigscreen has always demanded a level of narrative concision, especially where Dickens is concerned, but this “Great Expectations” feels disciplined to a fault, lacking either the focused, sparkling intelligence of David Lean’s 1946 version or the bold revisionism of Alfonso Cuaron’s 1993 update, to name two more memorable adaptations.


The picture is on surer footing once Pip grows into a strapping young man (played by Toby Irvine’s older brother Jeremy) and finds himself unexpectedly fast-tracked into the upper echelons of London society. Newell and Nicholls pay careful attention to their protagonist’s persistent sense of social inadequacy; the shifting dynamic between the suddenly haughty Pip and his coarse but loving brother-in-law, Joe Gargery (Jason Flemyng, excellent), represents the film’s most poignant strand. And Pip’s humble origins are not lost on the boorish Bentley Drummle (Ben Lloyd-Hughes), his chief rival for the affections of Estella (Holliday Grainger), now colder and lovelier than ever.


Handsome 21-year-old thesp Irvine, who came to prominence in last year’s “War Horse,” supplies sufficient empathy in the role of Pip, offsetting the character’s fish-out-of-water awkwardness with a fiery impetuousness. Robbie Coltrane (another Potter alum) delivers one of the film’s stronger performances as the formidable Mr. Jaggers, allowing nary a flicker of affection to temper his cold, professional countenance as he oversees Pip’s gentlemanly education.


Although John Mathieson’s widescreen lensing was not seen to its best advantage in digital projection at the Toronto fest screening reviewed, Jim Clay’s production design, Beatrix Aruna Pasztor’s costumes and the impeccably chosen English locations all contribute to an enveloping atmosphere of thick, muddy realism. But the pleasures of this adaptation are ultimately little more than a meager imitation of the riches Dickens achieved on the page. As the story runs its usual course, opening one skeleton closet after another, one senses the filmmakers treating their sacred text as a crutch, rather than something that would actually benefit from being imaginatively interpreted for the screen.

Great Expectations


Production: A Lionsgate release of a BFI, BBC Films and Unison Films presentation in association with HanWay Films and LipSync Post of an Elizabeth Karlsen, Stephen Woolley, Number 9 Films production. (International sales: HanWay Films, London.) Produced by Woolley, Karlsen, Emanuel Michael, David Faigenblum. Executive producers, Zygi Kamasa, Norman Merry, Peter Hampden, Mike Newell, Ed Hart, Jana Edelbaum, Cliff Curtis, Charlotte Larson, Christine Langan. Co-producer, Laurie Borg. Directed by Mike Newell. Screenplay, David Nicholls, based on the novel by Charles Dickens.

Crew: Camera (Technicolor, Panavision widescreen), John Mathieson; editor, Tariq Anwar; music, Richard Hartley; production designer, Jim Clay; art director, Dominic Masters; costume designer, Beatrix Aruna Pasztor; sound (Dolby Digital), Peter Lindsay; supervising sound editor/sound designer, Ian Wilson; re-recording mixer, Robert Farr; visual effects supervisor, Sheila Wickens; visual effects, LipSync Post; stunt coordinator, Andy Bennett; assistant director, Josh Robertson; second unit director, Shawn O'Dell; casting, Susie Figgis. Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Gala Presentations), Sept. 10, 2012. (Also in London Film Festival -- closer.) Running time: 127 MIN.

With: Pip - Jeremy Irvine Mr. Jaggers - Robbie Coltrane Miss Havisham - Helena Bonham Carter Magwitch - Ralph Fiennes Wemmick - Ewen Bremner Joe Gargery - Jason Flemyng Estella - Holliday Grainger Uncle Pumblechook - David Walliams Mrs. Joe - Sally HawkinsWith: Olly Alexander, Toby Irvine, Helena Barlow, Tamzin Outhwaite, Ben Lloyd-Hughes.

More Film

  • Days of Christmas

    Pau Freixas on Netflix Spanish Miniseries ‘Days of Christmas’

    BARCELONA – A Netflix original produced by Spain’s Filmax, “Days of Christmas” marks the new series of Pau Freixas, one of the highest-profile creators on Spain’s vibrant drama series scene. A three-part miniseries, “Days” will be made available worldwide by Netflix on Dec. 6. The story takes place over three different Christmas days, the first [...]

  • Writers-Room-Panel

    Ventana Sur: Argentine Directors on Benefit of Writers’ Room (EXCLUSIVE)

    BUENOS AIRES — Ventana Sur hosted two of the country’s leading screenwriters to relay the benefits of utilizing a writers’ room while conceptualizing fiction projects, delivered to a packed auditorium on Tuesday afternoon as part of the Fiction Factory series held at the UCA Campus in Puerto Madero. Director Daniel Burman, known for films such [...]

  • Kathleen Kennedy to Receive Prestigious BAFTA

    Kathleen Kennedy to Receive Prestigious BAFTA Fellowship

    Kathleen Kennedy, president of Lucasfilm and producer of scores of movies, will receive a prestigious BAFTA fellowship, the British Academy’s highest honor, in February. Across a 40-year career, Kennedy has produced pictures that have garnered 25 Oscars and more than 100 BAFTA nominations and 27 wins. She will be honored with the fellowship at BAFTA’s [...]

  • Lee Byung-hun stars in "The Man

    Lee Byung-hun’s ‘Man Standing Next’ Secures 2020 Asia Theatrical Releases (EXCLUSIVE)

    Showbox’s political drama “The Man Standing Next” has secured releases in multiple territories in Asia. The film was picked up by Falcon for Indonesia, The Klockworx for Japan, Viva Communications for the Philippines, Shaw Renters for Singapore and by Moviecloud for Taiwan. Release dates in each territory have yet to be confirmed. Set 40 days [...]

  • Lulu Wang and Zhao Shuzhen'The Farewell'

    Zhao Shuzhen on Stealing Scenes in Her First American Movie, 'The Farewell'

    A year ago, 76-year-old actor Zhao Shuzhen shot her first American movie, “The Farewell,” based on writer-director Lulu Wang’s very personal family story. In November, Shuzhen found herself making her first visit to the States, where she earned standing ovations from audiences and posed for pictures with stars like Robert Pattinson at parties. Then she [...]

  • Jennifer Lopez and Director Lorene Scafaria

    'Hustlers' DP Todd Banhazl Discusses How Not to Shoot With the Male Gaze

    Cinematographer Todd Banhazl had to rethink conventional wisdom in shooting Jennifer Lopez starrer “Hustlers.” What sort of approach did you and director Lorene Scafaria discuss in terms of how you were going to shoot the women and create these strong images of strippers? From the beginning, we talked about this idea of control and the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content