‘The Godfather’: An offer many helmers could refuse

Pic's durability defies many wrong predictions

Like most people, I hate being proved wrong — especially on national television.

Here’s the back story: For its thoughtful 40th-anniversary retrospective on “The Godfather,” to be broadcast July 24, the History channel mobilized a formidible array of academics, social commentators and even a few Mafia hit men to analyze the impact of this iconic movie. Their conclusion was that the movie was to become a favorite of several totalitarian rulers around the world, emerging as a sort of textbook for tyrants. Further, more than any other film of its generation, “The Godfather” changed society’s view of Italian-Americans, the mob and family obligations in general. Leaders of the Mafia came to view the film as a source of self-esteem.

So why did that prove me wrong?

When Paramount (where I was production VP) was prepping the movie in 1970 I was surprised and irritated as several of the world’s top filmmakers turned down offers to direct the film. The reason they gave was that, upon reading Mario Puzo’s novel, they were fearful that the film version would glamorize the mob and turn criminals into folk heroes.

I felt that these filmmakers were mistaken — they were letting their social consciences intrude upon their artistic decisions.

I was thus gratified when Francis Ford Coppola, who was always my first choice (and that of my boss, Bob Evans), proved willing to take it on.

Of course Coppola, too, was resistant. As a middle-class Italian kid from an artistic background, Coppola did not want to get into the business of making gangster movies. He saw himself directing small “personal films” at his San Francisco studio.

But Coppola was also broke and needed a job, as his friend George Lucas and I often reminded him.

History’s two-hour doc, titled “The Godfather Legacy,” relates how the movie that no one wanted to make ultimately emerged as “one of the greatest movies ever made” (the doc was produced by Kevin Burns for Prometheus Entertainment with Susan Leventhal serving as executive producer for the History channel). In making their case, the producers not only interviewed a long list of academics but also Coppola, Al Pacino, James Caan and Talia Shire (and me).

The fact that “The Godfather” did indeed create its remarkable legacy is a reflection not only of the film’s artistic merits but also of the nature of the times. Movies had become the center of the conversation in the 1970s, and the public’s taste was changing radically. Society’s sensibilities had been rubbed raw by Vietnam, political assassinations and racial unrest, all of which altered the dynamic of our pop culture.

Looking back from the perspective of four decades I, too, misjudged the potential of the film as it stumbled toward fruition. The pre-production of the project was steeped in controversy. Paramount’s corporate chieftains, awed by the novel’s success, decreed that Marlon Brando was a box office loser. Caan wanted to play Michael and Pacino favored Sonny while the corporate hierarchs disdained them both. A bizarre group fronting for the mob adamantly protested the production, demanding that the word “mafia” be removed from the script. (It was never there to begin with.)

Upon reflection, just about everyone at the time got it wrong, me included. But at the premiere in March 1972 it became instantly clear that Coppola had gotten it right. The legacy was born. And it was kind of nice that a few mafia families felt good about themselves along the way.

More Voices

  • Oscar Statue Oscars Placeholder

    Oscars 2020 Predictions: Who Will Get Nominated?

    The Oscar race is on. And it’s about to get a lot more intense when the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences announces the nominations for the 92nd Oscars on Jan. 13. Golden Globes shutout “The Irishman” is favored to earn several nods, as will “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” which went home [...]

  • Golden Globes Analysis Oscar Race

    Why Golden Globes Will Likely Have Little Effect on Oscar Nominations (Column)

    With the Globes now behind us and Oscar noms rapidly approaching on Jan. 13, what should we be paying attention to in Hollywood’s biggest film awards race? Surefire bets are Globe winners Renée Zellweger (“Judy”), who already has one Oscar, and Brad Pitt, who should garner his third acting nomination for his work in Quentin [...]

  • Renee Zellweger "Judy" Pathe

    Golden Globes Predictions: Who Will Win in the Film Categories?

    With the Golden Globes just around the corner, there’s only one thing that seems inevitable: Renée Zellweger will win for best actress in the drama category when the awards are handed out on Jan. 5. Besides that, the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. can go in so many different directions, as the Globes are arguably the [...]

  • Joe Talbot Jimmie Fails Last Black

    Want a Career in the Arts? Build a Community (Guest Column)

    Last November, 400,000 writers from around the world agreed to spend a month with their friends writing novels. They met in libraries and cafés, cheered on by 1,000 volunteers. One writer, a 20-year-old college student, recently signed a two-book publishing deal. Previous novelists have had their books turned into Hollywood movies. And it wasn’t just [...]

  • Saoirse Ronan and Timothée Chalamet in

    Can 'Little Women' Recover for Oscars After SAG Nominations Shutout?

    Where in the world was “Little Women”? That was the big question this morning when the 2020 SAG Award nominations were announced. Greta Gerwig’s adaptation of the classic novel was completely shut out by Wednesday’s nominations. It comes on the heels of “Little Women” snagging just two Golden Globe noms for Saoirse Ronan for lead [...]

  • Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) is

    Golden Globes: Six Things to Know About the Film Nominations

    Most of Monday morning’s Globe nominations didn’t come as a big surprise. “Marriage Story,” “The Irishman,” “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” and “Parasite” have been ruling awards season – their many nominations were expected. But Globe wins don’t necessarily translate to Oscar gold — about half of best pic wins have been in sync [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content