You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

VFX Bake-Off Was “Reel” Stressful for “Harry Potter”


Although the Visual-Effects Bakeoff isn’t normally a news-filled part of awards season, David S. Cohen was there to report on a little bit of “Harry Potter” drama last night as the shortlisted films presented their clip reels.

Updated: 5:20 p.m.

There was an unprecedented moment of drama at Thursday night’s Academy Visual-Effects Bakeoff, when due to a snafu, “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2” almost didn’t get to make its Oscar pitch.

Visual-effects supervisor Tim Burke introduced the 10-minute “Deathly Hallows” vfx clip reel, but what then unspooled at the Acad’s Goldwyn Theater didn’t match his introduction. Within moments, the vfx branch’s Bill Taylor, who was MC for the event, was scrambling at the front of the house to get the attention of the projectionist, Marshall Gitlitz, shouting “This is the wrong reel!”

It turned out what they started to show was “Deathly Hallows,” but it was the makeup bakeoff reel, not the visual-effects reel. The Potter presentation was stopped and the next pic, “Real Steel,” took the stage, leaving “Deathly Hallows” in danger of not being able to show a reel at the bakeoff at all.

While not presenting a reel wouldn’t have disqualified “Deathly Hallows” from the race, since most vfx branch voters had probably already seen it, it would have put the pic at a huge disadvantage.

Initially there was confusion Friday over how this happened, especially once Variety began asking about the problem. By late afternoon, the mystery was solved — mostly. Taylor told Variety neither the studio nor the production had a representative at Thursday’s rehearsal to approve the clip. That made “Deathly Hallows” the only bakeoff contender with no one present at rehearsal to check and approve the reel presentation.

According to a Warner exec who works on visual effects, Technicolor was asked to deliver the visual effects and makeup reels on two separate drives to avoid confusion. Instead, Technicolor sent over one drive labeled on the outside “Makeup” and one labeled on the outside “VFX,” but each drive had both files. So the Academy engineer would have loaded the drive labeled “VFX” only to find, according to Warners, the following file names: “HARRY-POTTER-7B_BAKEOFF-MAKEUP_SHR_S_EN-XX_51-2K_WB_20120116_TDC” and “37836_HARRY-POTTER-7B_BAKEOFF_VFX_SHR_S_EN-XX_51_2K_WB_20120115_TDC.”

Warner adds, “Although Technicolor caused some confusion, an engineer at the Academy loaded both 10-minute segments and put the wrong reel in the playlist.”
So at almost 10:30, at the end of the bakeoff, Gitlitz put up the mysterious file. Taylor says, “As soon as it came on the screen, Tim Burke gave me the thumbs-up, and we knew that we had the right reel.”

For those not familiar with the Acad’s vfx nominating procedure, the vfx branch’s executive committee narrows the competish to 10 films. The supervisors from those pics present 10-minute highlight reels, each with a strictly-timed five minutes of introduction and three minutes after to answer questions. The vfx membership from around the world gathers for the bakeoff at the Goldwyn Theater and votes to choose the five Oscar nominees immediately after the event.

This year’s 10 pics, in the order they presented, were “Hugo,” “Transformers: Dark of the Moon,” “Rise of the Planet of the Apes,” “The Tree of Life,” “Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides,” “Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol,” “X-Men: First Class,” “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2,” “Real Steel” and “Captain America: The First Avenger.” The bakeoff is open to the public and is one of the Acad’s most popular public events. Taylor introduced it Thursday as “the greatest visual-effects show on Earth.”

Taylor said that he has never seen such a snafu at a vfx bakeoff before, and credits Gitlitz’s resourcefulness with saving the day. “It was a happy ending,” he said, adding that “Harry Potter” showed “wonderful, wonderful work.”

It’s not the first time a d-cinema snafu caused an awards-season embarrassment. The debut screening of “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” at the DGA, for an invited aud of press and luminaries, was halted 20 minutes in when the digital projector brought in for the occasion showed the pic with a green tint. Eventually the screening was cancelled, though guests got to enjoy the wine and cheese spread in the lobby anyway.

“Hugo,” “Transformers” and “Pirates” presented in 3D, and so had to be shown digitally. Six more were shown digitally by choice. Only one was shown on film: “The Tree of Life.”— David S. Cohen

More Film

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Box Office

    Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona' Conjures $2.8 Million in Previews

    “The Curse of La Llorona,” the latest entry in Warner Bros. and New Line’s “Conjuring” universe, conjured $2.75 million from Thursday preview showings, while “Breakthrough,” a faith-based offering from Fox-Disney, brought in $1.5 million from its second day of screenings. The two films are hoping to dominate the Easter and Passover holiday box office, but [...]

  • Chinese Films Make the Cannes Lineup,

    Cannes: Chinese Films Make the Lineup, but Will They Make It to France?

    Cannes has chosen two mainland Chinese titles for its official selection: Diao Yinan’s “Wild Goose Lake,” in competition, and Zu Feng’s “Summer of Changsha,” for Un Certain Regard. Both films appear to have received the necessary official approvals from Chinese authorities to premiere overseas. But their journey to the Cote d’Azur is by no means [...]

  • Festival director Thierry Fremaux speaks to

    Cannes: Thierry Fremaux on the Lineup's Record Number of Female Directors, American Cinema and Political Films

    The Cannes Film Festival has unveiled a lineup for its 72nd edition that includes some high-profile Hollywood titles, genre movies and films from 13 female directors. The official selection has been applauded by many for mixing established auteurs like Pedro Almodovar (“Pain and Glory”), Terrence Malick (“A Hidden Life”) and Xavier Dolan (“Matthias and Maxime”) [...]


    Film Review: 'Nureyev'

    It would be absurd to say that Rudolf Nureyev lived, or danced, in anyone’s shadow. He was a man who leapt and twirled and flew onstage, all muscle but light as a feather, with a freedom and force that reconfigured the human spirit. There’s no denying, though, that over the last few decades, and especially [...]

  • Die Kinder Der Toten review

    Film Review: 'Die Kinder Der Toten'

    The hills are alive (or rather, undead), with the sound of music (also mastication and the moaning of zombies) in Kelly Copper and Pavol Liska’s experimental, dialogue-free, home-movie-style riff on Elfriede Jelinek’s “Die Kinder Der Toten” (The Children of the Dead). A seminal text in Jelinek’s native Austria, the 1995 book has never been translated [...]

  • Idol review

    Film Review: 'Idol'

    How many twists can a plot undergo before it snaps? This, more than any of the many political, moral and personal conundrums that snake through “Idol,” seems to be the question writer-director Lee Su-jin is most interested in posing with his extravagantly incomprehensible sophomore feature. A seedy political thriller by way of grisly revenge movie [...]

  • The Last to See Them review

    Film Review: 'The Last to See Them'

    Truman Capote’s “In Cold Blood” stretches long as a late-evening shadow over Italian director Sara Summa’s feature debut “The Last to See Them.” The Italian title, “Gli Ultimi Viderli Vivere” which translates literally to “The Last to See Them Alive,” is also the heading of the opening chapter of Capote’s book. The setting is, similarly, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content