The Whole “Undeserving of Oscar” Argument Is Annoying

Now that the Academy Award nominations have been announced, let the sniping and griping begin. Yes, there are plenty of arguments to be made for the omissions among various categories, but it’s just in poor taste to talk about who isn’t deserving of an Oscar nomination.

Mary Pols at Time Magazine just wrote a story called “Bridesmaids’ Melissa McCarthy: Hilarious Performance, Not Oscar Worthy” that so annoyed BackStage’s Jenelle Riley that she felt compelled to retort via blog post.

The heart of Pols’ argument is that while McCarthy played the “Bridesmaids” role effectively, her performance was one-note. And, even worse, Pols says McCarthy’s nomination was strictly the Academy’s way of servicing flagging telecast ratings and showing how attuned to popular tastes its members are.

While Riley has her own argument against Pols’ position — specifically that comedy is just as hard, if not harder, than drama (true, people!) — the Time story also brings light to the cynical underside of Oscar prognosticating. Many awards-season-hardened watchers eventually come to believe that the Oscars are rigged, the Academy’s members are out of touch, and every seemingly surprise nom is designed to boost telecast ratings.

But there are a couple of problems with that.

Yes, it’s true that the Academy makes about $80 million a year in license fees from its deal with ABC to broadcast the ceremony. However, that deal goes through 2020, so ABC is not in any danger of abandoning ship just because the Academy nommed “Moneyball” for best picture instead of the highest-grossing film of the year, “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2.” The ratings always ebb and flow. After all, as important as awards season is in Los Angeles, the rest of the country has its own season, and it’s called winter.

(Incidentally, if you’re going to get really cynical about it, ABC has just as much interest in ratings because the Oscars are a good platform to advertise Disney’s movies and ABC’s TV series. So maybe “War Horse’s” Oscar nom was really a ploy to appease ABC. Yeah, and 5,000 Academy voters decided to put “War Horse” somewhere on the ballot just to make sure that when it comes time to renegotiate with ABC for telecast rights in, oh, 2018, ABC will remember that favor it got from AMPAS. See how ridiculous it all gets?)

As far as the Academy being out of touch, it is true that its members don’t generally honor the films that critics like. But very often, critics don’t like the films that audiences go to see, either. In fact, both groups are accused of being out of touch. The difference is that the Oscars are an industry honor, given by people who work in the industry. It’s great that everyone outside of the industry gets so passionate about who should get nommed and who should win, but that’s outsider passion. Those gold trophies aren’t meant to represent your opinion. They’re only meant to represent the opinions of an elite group of 5,000 executives, actors, producers and craftspeople.

And, finally, how awful would it be to get an Oscar nomination — the absolute pinnacle of honors in the entertainment industry — and know that some people are saying you don’t deserve it? It’s one thing to talk about how a really great performance got overlooked, but why take the steam out of someone’s big moment? Melissa McCarthy got recognized for a performance that sold movie tickets, made people laugh and that will go down in history as “Oscar nominated.” That is something that only the best and brightest in Hollywood ever get to say. Don’t tarnish it by saying it was all to generate ratings.

More Film

  • Roman Polanski extradition

    Academy Responds to Roman Polanski: 'Procedures Were Fair and Reasonable'

    UPDATE: The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has responded to a lawsuit from director Roman Polanski that claimed he was unfairly expelled from the industry organizaton. “The procedures taken to expel Mr. Polanski were fair and reasonable. The Academy stands behind its decision as appropriate,” a spokesperson said. Polanski is suing the Academy [...]

  • Lorraine Warren dead

    Lorraine Warren, Paranormal Investigator Who Inspired 'The Conjuring,' Dies at 92

    Lorraine Warren, paranormal investigator and demonologist whose life inspired franchises like “The Conjuring” and “The Amityville Horror,” has died. She was 92. Warren’s son-in-law Tony Spera confirmed the news. Spera said on Facebook, “She died peacefully in her sleep at home.” He continued, “She was a remarkable, loving, compassionate and giving soul. To quote Will [...]


    'Exorcist' Star Max Von Sydow Doesn't Let Age Define His Roles

    Max von Sydow turned 90 this month, which is a milestone for most people, but age has always seemed incidental to the actor. When he played the elderly, frail Father Merrin in “The Exorcist,” von Sydow was 44 — meaning he was the same age Bradley Cooper is today. In the 1950s, von Sydow had [...]

  • 'Changing the Game' Documentary

    Watch the First Trailer for Trans Documentary 'Changing the Game' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Another hurdle for trans rights could quite literally be the track and field hurdle. Transgender student athletes are put in the spotlight in the forthcoming documentary “Changing the Game,” set to premiere at 2019 Tribeca Film Festival. Variety has the world premiere of the doc’s first teaser trailer, which gives an in-depth look into the [...]

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Box Office

    Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona' Conjures $2.8 Million on Thursday Night

    “The Curse of La Llorona,” the latest entry in Warner Bros. and New Line’s “Conjuring” universe, conjured $2.75 million from Thursday preview showings, while “Breakthrough,” a faith-based offering from Fox-Disney, brought in $1.5 million from its second day of screenings. “La Llorona’s” haul tops recent horror counterparts “Pet Sematary” and “Escape Room,” which each took [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content