DGA Awards have film-TV imbalance

DGA Awards 2012

Though the 64th annual Directors Guild of America Awards will be presented Saturday amid awards-season hoopla for 2011’s fave movies, most of the directors accepting kudos will be recognized for work that appears on TV.

Seven of the DGA’s 10 categories are for shows on the smallscreen, including comedy series, dramatic series, musical variety and daytime serials, far outnumbering the two bigscreen categories: documentary (which dates to 1977) and feature film, the org’s longest-running prize, created in 1948. The remaining award is for commercials.

“It does seem like they’re sort of shortchanging the film directors,” says Tampa Bay Times critic Steve Purcell, who would like to see more DGA categories for filmmaking.

Rewarding directors of animated features would be a good place to start, he adds, given the different skill set required to create them and the popularity of the genre.

Steven Rea, with the Philadelphia Inquirer, also would encourage an animation award.

“Adding animation would expand the reach of the guild in a good way,” he says. “It would show that it’s more inclusive and open to the artistry of animated film directors.”

While animation is the only award Rea would add to the DGA film roster, Purcell believes there’s merit in splitting the current feature kudo along drama and comedy or musical lines — as the Golden Globes does with its film awards — and he also would like to see annual recognition of up-and-coming filmmakers.

“Directors of the independents in a lot of cases have to take much more of the fundraising on their shoulders compared with the directors of more highly budgeted studio productions,” Purcell says. “That should be honored and regarded in some way. It would inspire more folks who are out there in film schools, and in doing so you bring in the next fold, the next generation of filmmakers.”

There’s already a history of the guild honoring a range of film genres, according to DGA media relations director Sahar Moridani.

“The DGA Award has recognized blockbusters, dramas, comedies, musicals, independents and foreign films. We are very proud of our tradition of honoring outstanding directorial achievement in feature film with one award.”

Indeed, nominees and winners from the past decade have included works from the likes of James Cameron (“Avatar”), Kathryn Bigelow (“The Hurt Locker”), Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris (“Little Miss Sunshine”), William Condon (“Dreamgirls”) and Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu (“Babel”).

Should the DGA add any more awards to its lineup, Spencer Parsons, an assistant radio/TV/film professor at Northwestern U., foresees an honors hierarchy developing. As it is, the DGA’s prize for feature director is not only coveted — last year’s winner, Tom Hooper, called it “the highest honor of my life” — it also is widely considered one of the most reliable indicators of the eventual Oscar winner for director. How would any new genre-based awards compare?

“They would still leave dramatic filmmaking as the most coveted award, the one treated as the top dog over awards for the other genres,” says Parsons, who’s wrapping his second feature, “Saturday Morning Massacre,” for the festival circuit. “Yes, you’re awarding more films, you’re creating more opportunity, but you’re also in a way giving a new prize that is somewhat less.”

Purcell doubts any second-class concerns if the DGA adds an animation category. “You’ll have to ask Disney/Pixar whether they’ve had any regrets about winning all of those Oscars for best animated feature and not for best film.”

Post-party obsession | DGA Awards have film-TV imbalance | Inner circle

More Film

  • For web story

    'The Burnt Orange Heresy,' With Mick Jagger and Donald Sutherland, to Close Venice

    “The Burnt Orange Heresy,” starring Mick Jagger as a reclusive art dealer alongside Elizabeth Debicki (“Widows”), Claes Bang (“The Square”) and Donald Sutherland, has been selected as the Venice Film Festival closer.  The English-language art heist movie marks Italian director Giuseppe Capotondi’s first time back at Venice since 2009, when his debut feature film, the [...]

  • A woman prays at a makeshift

    Kyoto Animation Death Toll Rises to 34; Suspect Still Too Injured to Be Questioned

    Shinji Aoba, the man suspected of setting a fire that killed 34 people at the Kyoto Animation studio, remains hospitalized and too injured to be officially arrested and questioned. Police in Kyoto have obtained an arrest warrant for Aoba but cannot serve it because of his condition. Police sources have raised the death toll from [...]

  • Azania Muendane

    Locations Africa Expo Sends Message in Durban: ‘Africa is Ready’

    DURBAN–The first edition of the Locations Africa Expo and Conference was held this week during the Durban FilmMart, with an eye toward identifying and growing the opportunities to lure incoming productions to the continent. “Locations Africa is trying to service a need on the continent to discuss the physical production…on the ground, highlighting film commissions, [...]

  • The Lion King

    China Box Office: 'Looking Up' Is Surprise Weekend Winner Ahead of 'Lion King'

    Actor and comedian Deng Chao underlined his enduring popularity with mainstream Chinese audiences by delivering a surprise No. 1 box-office hit in “Looking Up” over the weekend. It scored $38.6 million in its opening frame, according to data from consultancy Artisan Gateway, and displaced “The Lion King” from its perch. “Looking Up” is a family [...]

  • Unathi Malonga

    Report Urges South African Media to ‘Step Up’ Against Gender Violence

    DURBAN–In a country with some of the highest rates of sexual and gender-based violence in the world, South African media must step up and play a greater role in the fight against gender inequality and gender-based violence. That was the conclusion of a report, “Gender, Diversity and Gender-based Violence in South African TV,” that was [...]


    SAG-AFTRA Leaders Approve Proposal for New Film-TV Contract

    The SAG-AFTRA national board has approved proposals for a successor deal to its master contract covering feature film and primetime television — a key step in the upcoming negotiations cycle with companies. The board approved the package Saturday with the performers union declining to reveal any specifics — its usual policy. The board established the wages [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content