Toon boom blurs the line

Eye on the Oscars: Animation

Last year, the Academy’s animation branch sent a message to Hollywood: Just because an animated blockbuster sells millions of tickets and demonstrates cutting-edge technical innovations does not mean it represents the kind of achievement the group wants to award.

By giving two of its five nominations to small, foreign-made, hand-drawn toons — “Chico & Rita” and “A Cat in Paris” — the org appeared to be taking a stand against the sort of computer-animated pics that have become the industry’s bread and butter. Although CG “Rango” ultimately took the prize, American toon studios are starting to get nervous again, now that GKids (the indie distrib that released “Chico” and “Cat”) plans to Oscar-qualify four more titles this year — three of which are traditional hand-drawn entries.

“Let’s face it, a lot of the older members have a real hunger for what they consider to be art in animation,” says Bill Kroyer, a governor on the Academy short films and feature animation branch. “Anything hand-drawn and hand-painted immediately has an impressionistic, very unpredictable quality to it that makes it very difficult to come up with a computer film to which audiences will respond in the same visceral way.”

That’s not to say that the branch members are all a bunch of Luddites opposed to impressive technical leaps in animation, despite the fact they snubbed Steven Spielberg’s motion-capture “The Adventures of Tintin” last year. “We’re the guys who make films that are 100% technology,” Kroyer says. “I look at ‘Avatar’ as one of our kind of films. Even though James Cameron didn’t submit, it would technically have been admitted, since keyframe animation was involved in every single frame of the simulated action.”

Further blurring between performance capture and traditional character animation can be found in such “live-action” projects as Peter Jackson’s “The Hobbit.” Referring to the role mo-cap played in the production, visual-effects supervisor Joe Leterri says, “These guys just use it everywhere. The animators, if they’re assigned to a shot and they have to go in and animate a character, they’ll put on a (performance capture) suit and just do it themselves. In the old days, you’d set up a video camera, you’d film yourself as reference and you’d go in and try to match it all. It’s really interesting how the technology has fully integrated now with animation.”

The Academy’s toon branch is spared the debate of whether to award such work in the animated feature category this year, since the 2012 crop of submissions features no mo-cap pics. It does, however, include a startlingly high number of stop-motion films — Tim Burton’s “Frankenweenie,” Laika’s “ParaNorman” and Aardman-made “Pirates!” — which have an incredible track record of being rewarded by the branch (the impression being that the hand-puppeted frame-by-frame approach is considered even more artistic than hand-drawn toons by the pros).

With the last-minute addition of several foreign-made contenders (including “Delhi Safari” and “Hey Krishna,” which each claim to be India’s first stereoscopic computer-animated feature) pushing the total number of submissions to a record-setting 21. Enough toons opened in 2012 to support a full five-pic race, which gives everyone hope for that roughly 1-in-4 shot at a nom.

In a year without a clear frontrunner, that leaves a sizable pool of high-performing CG contenders from nearly every studio fighting for recognition against the perceived biases of the branch. Illumination mixed eco-awareness and pop appeal with “Dr. Seuss’ The Lorax”; Blue Sky did incredible business with “Ice Age: Continental Drift”; Pixar pleased fans by delivering a strong female heroine in its first fairy tale, “Brave”; Sony had a monster hit with “Hotel Transylvania”; DreamWorks unfurled a franchise in “Rise of the Guardians”; and Disney’s videogame-set “Wreck-It Ralph” is playing like gangbusters.

The latter — a late-season favorite from a studio that may finally have found its footing — could face some unexpected competition from “The Painting,” an award-winning French toon submitted by GKids. Just as “Ralph” imagines a world in which unfulfilled 8-bit characters venture beyond their respective arcade games, “The Painting” brings an unfinished painting to life, as figures abandoned by the artist undergo a courageous quest to improve their social standing.

GKids founder Eric Beckman acquired the pic with an eye toward its Oscar chances: “Before we launched GKids, we said we were going to handle Oscar-caliber animation, and the response from the Academy has been great. I don’t want to pick up a film that I would be embarrassed to run for best animated feature.”

While CG dominates among bigscreen features, the 56 animated shorts represent “unbelievable quality and unbelievable variety,” according to Kroyer. “Everybody thinks CG is going to take over. Not in short films. We have every medium you could think of, and the quality level is remarkable.”


The following 21 films vie for the five slots in Oscar’s animated feature race:

“Adventures in Zambezia”
(Triggerfish Studios)
Director: Wayne Thornley

Directors: Mark Andrews, Brenda Chapman

“Delhi Safari”
(Applied Art/Krayon)
Director: Nikhil Advani

“Dr. Seuss’ The Lorax”
Director: Chris Renaud

Director: Tim Burton

“From Up on Poppy Hill”
(GKids/Studio Ghibli)
Director: Goro Miyazaki

“Hey Krishna”
Director: Genndy Tartakovsky

“Hotel Transylvania”
(Sony Pictures Animation)
Director: Genndy Tartakovsky

“Ice Age: Continental Drift”
(Fox/Blue Sky)
Directors: Steve Martino, Mike Thurmeier

“A Liar’s Autobiography: The Untrue Story of Monty Python’s Graham Chapman”
Directors: Bill Jones, Jeff Simpson, Ben Timlett

“Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted”
(DreamWorks Animation)
Directors: Eric Darnell, Tom McGrath, Conrad Vernon

“The Mystical Laws”
(DreamWorks Animation)
Director: Isamu Imakake

“The Painting”
(GKids/Blue Spirit/Be-Films)
Director: Jean-Francois Laguionie

Directors: Chris Butler, Sam Fell

“The Pirates! Band of Misfits”
(Sony Pictures Animation/Aardman)
Director: Peter Lord

“The Rabbi’s Cat”
Directors: Antoine Delesvaux, Joann Sfar

“Rise of the Guardians”
(DreamWorks Animation)
Director: Peter Ramsay

“Secret of the Wings”
(DisneyToon Studios)

Bobs Gannaway, Peggy Holmes

“Walter & Tandoori’s Christmas”
Director: Sylvain Viau

“Wreck-It Ralph”
(Walt Disney Animation Studios)
Director: Rich Moore

(GKids/Prima Linea)

Remy Bezancon

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • UMC-Marriage-Boot-Camp-Hip-Hop-Edition-WE-tv

    WE tv, UMC Reteam on Bonus Content for 'Marriage Boot Camp: Hip Hop Edition' Season 2

    AMC Networks is touting the benefits of cross-pollinating content and promos across its TV and streaming properties. In the latest bit of synergy, the programmer’s WE tv announced the continuation of its partnership with sister company UMC (Urban Movie Channel) to produce a second season of “confessional” episodes for WE tv reality series “Marriage Boot [...]

  • Google Play Pass

    Google Launches Play Pass, Its $4.99 Apple Arcade Competitor

    Google officially launched its Play Pass game and app subscription service Monday morning. Play Pass gives users access to more than 350 premium games and apps for $4.99 per month. The launch comes just a few days after Apple unveiled it own game subscription service Apple Arcade. Apps and games included in this subscription do [...]

  • ESPN - Always Late With Katie

    ESPN Inks Facebook Deal to Bring Exclusive Shows and Content to Watch Service

    Disney’s ESPN is looking to expand digital reach across Facebook, under a new deal to distribute exclusive digital shows and content on the social giant’s Facebook Watch video platform. At launch, ESPN’s Facebook Watch lineup includes additional segments from “Always Late With Katie Nolan,” the late-night sports/comedy show premiering this week on ESPN2; exclusive versions [...]

  • David Benioff, D. B. Weiss, Carolyn

    Emmys 2019: 'Game of Thrones,' Jharrel Jerome Top Social-Media Buzz

    HBO’s “Game of Thrones” and Jharrel Jerome, star of Netflix’s “When They See Us,” were among the leaders of social conversation during Sunday’s 71st Primetime Emmy Awards on Facebook and Twitter. “GOT” picked up 12 Emmys in total for its final season, including outstanding drama series, while series star Peter Dinklage picked up his fourth [...]

  • Oprah Winfrey

    Oprah Sets First Book-Club Pick for New Apple TV Plus Series

    Oprah Winfrey’s interviews with authors of her book club selections will be featured exclusively on Apple’s forthcoming Apple TV Plus service, and she’s announced the first book selection for the project: “The Water Dancer” by Ta-Nehisi Coates. Apple teamed with Winfrey for Apple TV Plus series “Oprah’s Book Club,” premiering Nov. 1 when the service [...]

  • NBC LX - Valari Staab

    NBCU Launches Digital News Outlet LX to Reach People Who Don't Watch Local TV (EXCLUSIVE)

    NBCUniversal’s local TV division is taking a new tack to reach younger audiences that don’t tune in to its traditional newscasts. On Monday, NBCU’s 42-station local TV group is launching LX — a digital news brand that will produce original content for online distribution and, in 2020, via a live-streaming internet network and multicast over-the-air [...]

  • 'OpenAP' CEO David Levy Sees New

    'OpenAP' CEO David Levy Charts New Course

    A consortium built by some of the nation’s biggest media outlets to win new kinds of advertising is quickly changing its course. Founded in 2017 by Viacom, 21st Century Fox and Time Warner, OpenAP was initially designed to help marketers figure out ways to buy advertising based on reaching segments of audience that aren’t defined [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content