Canuck high court: ISPs unlike b’casters

Says Internet service providers should not have to adhere to same rules as broadcasters

Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks.

Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell and Rogers, to follow Canadian content and funding regulations.

“When providing access to the Internet, which is the only function of ISPs placed in issue by the reference question, they take no part in the selection, origination or packaging of content,” the court stated.

It’s a blow for actors union ACTRA, the Canadian Media Production Assn., the Directors Guild of Canada and the Writers Guild of Canada, which originally brought the question to the Federal Court of Appeal in 2009. That court also ruled that the ISPs were not “broadcast undertakings.” The cultural groups argue that the broadcasting rules are technology neutral — in other words it doesn’t matter if a TV show is being shown on a TV network or on the Internet, the same rules should apply.

The coalition says it will still press for all involved in broadcasting to contribute to Canadian production.

The TV networks have to follow Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission rules that force them to finance local production and give shows significant airtime.

More TV

  • Andrew Lincoln as Rick Grimes - The

    ‘Walking Dead’ Star Andrew Lincoln Confirms Series Exit at Comic-Con

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • Walking Dead Season 8 finale

    'Walking Dead' Unveils Season 9 Trailer, Premiere Date at Comic-Con

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • Kimberly Guilfoyle

    Fox News Confirms Kimberly Guilfoyle Has Left the Network

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • Fear the Walking Dead Trailer

    'Fear the Walking Dead': Survivors Battle Zombies and the Weather in New Trailer

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • Glow Netflix Cosutmes

    'GLOW' Costume Designers on Revisiting the Flashy, Colorful '80s

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • 'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New

    'Hammerhead' Takes Top Honors at New York Television Festival

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

  • Michelle Robert King Remote Controlled Podcast

    Listen: 'Good Fight' Creators Michelle and Robert King on How Trump 'Infected' the Show

    Canada’s Supreme Court on Thursday rejected the argument that Internet service providers should be treated like broadcasters and forced to adhere to the same rules that govern local TV networks. Several of Canada’s cultural unions and guilds had petitioned the court in an attempt to make ISPs that offer download or streaming services, including Bell […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content