×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Competition series wrestle with change

New contestants might be all the reinvention a show needs

If you’re a reality competition series that’s been on the air as long as “American Idol,” “Survivor,” or “The Amazing Race,” it’s never easy to know if it’s time for a change to your proven format, or if you should stick with what your audience knows and loves.

It’s a dilemma that can rattle producers. How they tackle this problem can make or break a show that’s built a loyal following but still needs to remain relevant.

“This question of whether to stick with what you know is working or make certain changes goes to the heart of both reality and scripted television,” says Jane Tranter, exec VP and head of BBC Worldwide Prods. “The truth is that you’re never completely sure, but I think you want to maintain that connection with what people like, while at the same time, we can’t just do the exact same thing with ‘Dancing With the Stars’ that we’ve always done.”

For Tranter, casting is a fundamental way to keep things alive on “Dancing With the Stars.” Kirstie Alley, who might not seem like an obvious choice for the show, became a season favorite most recently, though she placed second in the finale.

“Top Chef” executive producer Dave Serwatka agrees that finding the right mix of contestants is one of the most successful elixirs in reality television. And it requires time and research.

“We have our ear to the ground to find up-and-coming young chefs, and we try to find people who have that thing that makes you want to watch them no matter what they’re doing,” says Serwatka. “You can change the show a lot, but the people have to be interesting.”

Jeff Probst, host and producer of “Survivor,” also believes casting is the best way to keep a show compelling to viewers so they return season after season.

“People want the same thing, but they want it given to them in a slightly different way,” says Probst. “We may go from location to location, but we’re always showing you people struggling to win a competition under tough circumstances.”

Some shows alter their format or structure in much bigger ways. The changes don’t always go over as hoped but, when cast changes happen as they did on “American Idol,” the show still must go on in one form or another.

“I watched them put four judges in, I watched them bring the safeguard in, mix the chemistry of the judging up, focus on the judges rather than the contestants, and I thought, ‘These are mistakes being made in front of my very eyes,’?” says Nigel Lythgoe, who was a producer on “American Idol” for seasons one through seven, then left the show during seasons eight and nine and returned for the current season. “I wonder if I’d have done the same thing if I had been there.”

Longtime reality show producer Jonathan Murray has spent decades struggling with the same problem, most recently on “Project Runway.”

“When we were first asked to work on ‘Project Runway’ we realized we just had to not screw it up,” laughs executive producer Murray, who started on the show when it moved from Bravo to Lifetime. “But we had great material so it made sense to expand to 90-minute episodes.”

Other shows are simply set up to include constant change as part of their design. So the burden falls to the producers to continually redesign the structure of the competition.

“I think the way our show is set up, that provides a lot of the sense of newness for the audience,” says “Amazing Race” executive producer and director Bertram Van Munster. “We’re constantly in different countries with a different cast on a different challenge, so no two shows are alike.”

ROAD TO THE EMMYS: REALITY COMPETITION
Stars embrace reality competition shows | Competition series wrestle with change | Treated like equals on reality TV | Social media draws live auds to reality shows | Why we watch | Playing the reality-competition field

More TV

  • GOTHAM: L-R: Guest star Cameron Monaghan

    TV News Roundup: Fox Drops 'Gotham' Final Season Trailer (Watch)

    In today’s TV news roundup, Fox released a new trailer for an upcoming episode of “Gotham” and Disney has announced the cast for its upcoming “High School Musical” series.  FIRST LOOKS Showtime released a new trailer and the official poster for the upcoming fourth season of “Billions,” premiering March 17 at 9 p.m. ET/PT. In [...]

  • Chris Rock

    Chris Rock to Direct Kenan Thompson Comedy Pilot at NBC

    Chris Rock has come onboard to direct the NBC single-cam comedy pilot “Saving Kenan,” Variety has learned. Rock will also executive produce the pilot, which stars “SNL” mainstay Kenan Thompson. Thompson will play a newly widowed dad determined to be everything for his kids while begrudgingly letting his persistent father-in-law become more involved in their lives [...]

  • Peak TV Saturation TV Placeholder

    Apollo Global Management Buys Majority Stake in Cox TV Stations

    Private equity giant Apollo Global Management has cut a deal with Atlanta-based Cox Enterprises to buy a majority stake in Cox’s 13 TV stations as well as three newspapers and a handful of radio stations in Ohio. Apollo has been in the hunt for broadcast TV stations for some time. Cox’s station group, which includes [...]

  • Ken Jeong TV Take Podcast

    Listen: Ken Jeong on His Return to Stand-Up and New Netflix Special

    Welcome to “TV Take,” Variety’s television podcast. In this week’s episode, Variety’s executive editor of TV, Daniel Holloway, talks with Ken Jeong about his Netflix comedy special, “Ken Jeong: You Complete Me, Ho,” and being a judge on Fox’s “The Masked Singer.“ Jeong started working on his new standup act after ABC canceled his show “Dr. [...]

  • "Brother" -- Episode 201-- Pictured (l-r):

    CBS Interactive's Marc DeBevoise on Streaming Boom, Content Strategy, and Apple

    Not everyone wants or needs to be Netflix to succeed in the streaming space. And not everyone sees Apple’s enigmatic new service as a threat. Even as rival streaming services offer gobs of content, CBS Interactive’s president and COO Marc DeBevoise sees the company’s targeted original programming strategy continuing to attract viewers to its All [...]

  • Ken Jeong to Star in CBS

    Ken Jeong to Star in CBS Comedy Pilot From 'Crazy Rich Asians' Author Kevin Kwan

    A “Crazy Rich Asians” reunion is happening at CBS. Ken Jeong has been cast in a lead role in the multi-camera comedy pilot “The Emperor of Malibu,” which is being co-written and executive produced by “Crazy Rich Asians” author Kevin Kwan. In the series, Auggie, the son of a Chinese tech billionaire, announces his engagement [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content