×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

After 9/11, what changed for Media?

Predictions 9/11 would change media unfounded

Many ill-advised things were said in the days immediately following Sept. 11, 2001. From a media and cultural perspective, none were more conspicuously wrong-headed than notions that terrorism on U.S. soil would fundamentally reshape news and entertainment, such as Vanity Fair’s Graydon Carter assertion, “It’s the end of the age of irony.”

The normally sober Smithsonian Channel is marking the 10th anniversary of the attacks by airing a spec with a monster-movie subtitle, “9/11: Day That Changed the World.” Yet closer inspection of media content suggests Sept. 11 actually changed precious little, and what alterations did occur were mostly cosmetic.Pundits can be forgiven their hyperbole amid the emotion and pressure to analyze what transpired at the time. Other than forever amending perceptions of terror threats, though — which previously seemed mostly the stuff of science fiction — there’s scant evidence of lingering effects on TV or movies traceable to those events.

Think back to “True Lies” — the 1994 James Cameron-directed Arnold Schwarzenegger film, where Islamic terrorists pursue nuclear annihilation. Or the terror-themed pilots commissioned in early 2001 that premiered after the attacks: “24,” featuring an exploding passenger jet; and “The Agency,” which specifically referenced a plot masterminded by Osama bin Laden.

Terrorism wasn’t a new concept prior to Sept. 11. Audiences were merely accustomed to James Bond intervening before anything terrible happened.

As for news, the parallels between this summer — in our ostensibly forever-changed world — and the silliness witnessed a decade ago are eerily and depressingly familiar.

In hindsight, news organizations were second-guessed for their trashy and inconsequential coverage leading up to Sept. 11. The most ostentatious examples included the media scrum surrounding missing D.C. intern Chandra Levy and a trumped-up outbreak of shark attacks breathlessly transformed into a “trend.”

Compare that to this summer’s preoccupation with Casey Anthony’s trial, or Donald Trump’s mythical presidential bid and suspicions about President Obama’s origins. News execs pretend they can simultaneously pat their heads and rub their stomachs, but the truth is salacious scandal or celebrity conflict overwhelms debt-ceiling fights and Arab Springs again and again.

Major events inevitably pull media — from screenwriters to news producers — in certain directions for a period of time. Like the bar in “Cheers,” there’s a comfort level — especially in an age of fragmentation — in planting a flag where everybody already knows your name.

Those very dynamics, however, are why such shifts will always be temporary and short-lived. Indeed, the only enduring certainty about media remains that works will be copied — a Hollywood maxim followed as faithfully as any in the Bible or Koran, and thus a means navigating pop culture twists far more reliable than other attempts to divine the public mood.

One can rightfully argue Sept. 11 helped polarize American politics, complicated travel, compelled a debate about security versus privacy, unleashed new apprehensions, and heightened feelings of vulnerability in public spaces. In TV news, it also birthed the 24/7 news crawl on news/talk channels (and remember, Fox News and MSNBC were just five years old when Sept. 11 happened), contributing to the media’s emphasis on urgency without context, as witnessed during the recent storm buffeting the East Coast.

What it has not done — in some ways reassuringly — is radically change what amuses or distracts us. Nor has it given our news media the backbone to focus on what’s important — as opposed to what’s interesting — in a brutally competitive, ratings-and-clicks-driven modern age.

Notably, Graydon Carter wasn’t alone in his “The party’s over” assessment. In Time magazine, Roger Rosenblatt said the attacks ushered in “a new and chastened time.” Tell that to Harvey Levin, who successfully launched TMZ in 2005.

Fortunately, others maintained perspective during those early days. A temporary bout of post-Sept. 11 sobriety “won’t and can’t last,” David Beers wrote on Salon. And speaking on “Nightline,” author Haynes Johnson presciently predicted that despite the pain and fear of the moment, the nation would soon “go back to our delights and diversions.”

That resiliency of spirit is the good news. Tragedies come and go, but people always want to be entertained, and the template — while ever-evolving — is never completely remade.

By contrast, the more salient problem is a news media so committed to share in keeping us diverted and delighted, we’re no better at recognizing news of genuine consequence until it lands at our doorstep.

More TV

  • Mindy Kaling Actors on Actors

    Why Mindy Kaling Turned to Social Media to Find the Lead of Her Netflix Series

    Constance Wu (“Hustlers”) and Mindy Kaling (“Late Night”) explained how the internet helped expand the casting pool for their projects during a conversation for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” Wu began the interview: “When I did ‘Crazy Rich Asians’ and they were looking for actors, it was crazy how many people said, ‘Well, there are [...]

  • SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE -- "Harry Styles"

    'Saturday Night Live' Turns the Impeachment Hearings Into a Soap Opera (Watch)

    “Saturday Night Live” kicked off its Nov. 16 episode with a take on the biggest news story of the previous week (and foreseeable future): the impeachment hearings. But another big story of the week, especially in Hollywood, was how NBC’s last remaining daytime drama, “Days of our Lives,” had let its actors out of their [...]

  • Andy Cohen attends BravoCon's "Watch What

    'The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City' to Debut in 2020

    Bravo announced Saturday during its first annual BravoCon that a tenth “Real Housewives” series, “The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City,” will debut in 2020. Bravo host and “Real Housewives” executive producer Andy Cohen made the announcement during a panel titled “Ask Andy” at the NYC convention. “We’ve always tried to choose a city that [...]

  • Sterling K. Brown on His Oscar

    Sterling K. Brown on His Oscar Buzz for 'Waves': 'Kind of Surreal'

    Sterling K. Brown can’t quite comprehend the awards attention he’s receiving for his work in the A24 drama “Waves.” “If the Academy sees fit to put me in a category with people who I absolutely adore, I will pee all over myself, dude” the Emmy winner says on the latest episode of “The Big Ticket.” [...]

  • TV News Roundup: 45th Annual Humanitas

    TV News Roundup: 45th Annual Humanitas Nominees Announced

    In today’s TV news roundup, Humanitas has released the finalists for the 45th Annual Humanitas Prize, and YouTube announced a new beauty competition series hosted by James Charles.  CASTINGS Jason Kennedy has been named as the host of E!’s new series “In The Room.“ The “E! News” host will bring viewers inside celebrity homes for [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content