Siegfried

How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner's "Siegfried"? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage's new production. If this is scraping the bottom of the barrel, then the Met should do it more often: Newcomer Jay Hunter Morris is magnificent, and he's mostly surrounded by equally wonderful singers familiar to auds who've seen Lepage's stagings of the previous two operas in Wagner's tetralogy.

With:
Siegfried - Jay Hunter
Morris Wanderer - Bryn Terfel
Mime - Gerhard Siegel
Alberich - Eric Owens
Erda - Patricia Bardon
Fafner - Hans-Peter Konig
Forest Bird - Mojca Erdmann
Brunnhilde - Deborah Voigt

How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If this is scraping the bottom of the barrel, then the Met should do it more often: Newcomer Jay Hunter Morris is magnificent, and he’s mostly surrounded by equally wonderful singers familiar to auds who’ve seen Lepage’s stagings of the previous two operas in Wagner’s tetralogy.

After “Das Rheingold” and “Die Walkure,” Lepage’s staging of this chapter of “The Ring” is less revelatory. Those humongous piano keys of Carl Fillion’s unit set are more stationery, not so abstract, and are used primarily as a wall to project images. Acts one and two begin with a lot of hyper-realistic snakes and bugs that slither about, but when the keys turn, they morph into a beautiful forest suitable for your favorite fairytale. When the libretto asks for a bear, a mountain stream and a bird, we get precisely that. But all this literalism ultimately turns into kitsch. After grossing us out with those snakes and bugs, the forest’s ultimate bad secret is a cutesy dragon straight from Universal CityWalk.

Lepage and Fillion are on firmer ground with the more abstract earthscape and firestorm of act three. Perhaps kinks will be worked out in future perfs, but when those piano keys flip to create new formations, they often sound like they weigh every pound of their many tons.

There have been more expansive readings of “Siegfried,” but Fabio Luisi’s conducting has real drive that doesn’t lag for a minute of the opera’s five-plus hours. Opening-night perf came in 20 minutes under the estimated running time.

Morris, possessing a clear and focused voice, sings with great precision, and his lament for the mother he never knew is truly poignant. A sympathetic Siegfried? What a wonderful contradiction. Bryn Terfel continues to offer a commanding yet deeply conflicted Wotan/Wanderer. And Gerhard Siegel’s Mime is beautifully sung. OK, he’s playing a hate-filled hunchback, but within the twisted confines of the role, this is impassioned singing.

The character Brunnhilde actually gets beautiful music to sing. Unfortunately, Deborah Voigt is no longer up to the demands of the role.

The Met’s “Live in HD” transmission of “Siegfried” plays in movies theaters Nov. 5.

Siegfried

Metropolitan Opera, New York City; 3,800 seats; $430 top

Production: A Metropolitan Opera presentation of an opera in three acts by Richard Wagner. Directed by Robert Lepage. Conducted by Fabio Luisi. Associate Director, Neilson Vignola.

Creative: Sets, Carl Fillion; costumes, Francois St-Aubin; lighting, Etienne Boucher; videos, Pedro Pires. Opened, reviewed Oct. 27, 2011. Running time: 5 HOURS, 10 MIN.

Cast: Siegfried - Jay Hunter
Morris Wanderer - Bryn Terfel
Mime - Gerhard Siegel
Alberich - Eric Owens
Erda - Patricia Bardon
Fafner - Hans-Peter Konig
Forest Bird - Mojca Erdmann
Brunnhilde - Deborah Voigt

More Legit

  • Skintight review

    Off Broadway Review: ‘Skintight’ With Idina Menzel

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • Sugar in Our Wounds

    Off Broadway Review: ‘Sugar in Our Wounds’

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • SPRINGSTEEN ON BROADWAY

    Bruce Springsteen Condemns Trump's 'Inhumane' Border Policy During Broadway Show

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • Kenya Barris and Pharrell Williams

    Kenya Barris, Pharrell Williams to Collaborate on Juneteenth Stage Musical

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • BD Wong

    Stagecraft Podcast: BD Wong Talks Basketball in Beijing, Dinosaurs and Batman

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • Michael Jackson Musical Coming to Broadway

    Michael Jackson Musical Coming to Broadway in 2020

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

  • Watch Tom Hanks Vamp on Stage

    Watch Tom Hanks Vamp on Stage to Calm His 'Henry IV' Audience

    How difficult is it to stage Richard Wagner’s “Siegfried”? Or more precisely, how difficult is it to find a tenor to sing the punishing title role? The Met Opera announced no fewer than two tenors, who then withdrew, before it came up with someone who actually could sing Siegfried for Robert Lepage’s new production. If […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content