You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Phantom of the Opera’ sequel dies

Andrew Lloyd Webber show to shutter

Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months.

Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing campaigns that downplayed the show’s status as a sequel were reversed to point to its predecessor to boost sales. The show also suffered from the widely circulated name “Paint Never Dries,” coined by a Web review.

Unsatisfied with the production, Lloyd Webber reworked the show, helmed by Jack O’Brien, designed by Bob Crowley and lit by Paule Constable. It was closed for four nights to re-order and restructure the material, with additional lyrics by Charles Hart, under the uncredited hand of producer Bill Kenwright.

But despite more positive reviews, tuner failed to take off. Nominated for seven Olivier awards, it walked away empty-handed. An incarnation of the show opened in Melbourne, Australia, on May 28, helmed by Simon Phillips, to a far more positive press.

Lloyd Webber blamed the failure of the London run on his diagnosis and treatment for prostate cancer prior to rehearsals.

Regarding Phillips’ new version, he said, “There is no question that this production cannot be improved upon. It is fabulous to look at, and they completely understand what I’m trying to get at with the score.”

A Gotham transfer failed to materialize and Lloyd Webber’s Really Useful Group has not said whether the Oz version will travel.

More Legit

  • Watch Tom Hanks Vamp on Stage

    Watch Tom Hanks Vamp on Stage to Calm His 'Henry IV' Audience

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Donald Trump, Robert De Niro

    Trump Punches Back at Robert De Niro: 'A Very Low IQ Individual'

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Matt Bomer Andrew Rannells

    Stagecraft Podcast: Matt Bomer, Andrew Rannells on Broadway's 'Boys in the Band'

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Bruce Springsteen72nd Annual Tony Awards, Show,

    Tony Awards: Everything You Didn't See on TV

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Tina Fey72nd Annual Tony Awards, Show,

    Tony Awards: The Night’s Biggest Snubs and Surprises

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Amy Schumer introduces a performance by

    Tony Awards: Amy Schumer Calls 'My Fair Lady's' Henry Higgins a Mansplainer

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

  • Robert De Niro gestures while introducing

    Robert De Niro Says 'F--- Trump' at Tony Awards, Gets Standing Ovation

    “Love Never Dies,” Andrew Lloyd Webber’s much-hyped sequel to the record-breaking “The Phantom of the Opera,” has failed to live up to its title: The London show will shutter Aug. 27 after just 18 months. Following its March 2010 opening at the 1,469-seat Adelphi Theater, most reviews for the long-gestating tuner were poor, and marketing […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content