You will be redirected back to your article in seconds


Director Julian Schnabel's decade-spanning, controversy-stirring portrait of Arab sisterhood is now set to open Friday in a U.S.-only re-edited version that clocks in at 106 minutes

**Originally reviewed by Variety on Sept. 2, 2010, at the Venice Film Festival.**

Miral” was originally reviewed by Variety on Sept. 2, 2010, at the Venice Film Festival.

Following the picture’s middling fall-fest reception, the Weinstein Co. opted to remove it from the harsh glare of awards season and postpone its originally scheduled Dec. 3 Stateside bow. Having since grossed a little more than $500,000 in various European and Middle Eastern territories, director Julian Schnabel’s decade-spanning, controversy-stirring portrait of Arab sisterhood is now set to open Friday in a U.S.-only re-edited version that clocks in at 106 minutes (including closing credits), though there are only negligible differences between this cut and the 112-minute cut that premiered at Venice and Toronto.

Certainly no attempt has been made to blunt the tale’s pro-Palestinian p.o.v., and depending on their individual frames of reference (or lack thereof), viewers can be expected to applaud, condemn or yawn at “Miral’s” unflattering depiction of Israeli authority, in scenes that coexist uneasily with the film’s closing entreaties for peace and understanding.

And it would take more than a quick trim to address the fundamental flaws at the core of Rula Jebreal’s semiautobiographical saga of three generations of Palestinian women living under Israeli rule. The story remains a muddle of melodramatic gestures, extraneous protagonists and blunt political talking points, and Schnabel’s attempts to compensate stylistically with his trademark smeary, impressionistic visuals feel like auteurist doodles in the margins of an important subject.

The two chief excisions have been made to the picture’s bookending sequences. While it still begins in 1948 Jerusalem, the film no longer includes an early glimpse of a major character’s funeral (this is now reserved for the end, still accompanied by the throaty stylings of Schnabel regular Tom Waits). Also eliminated is the 1993 archival footage of post-Oslo Accords revelry, as the film now forgoes even the fleeting catharsis an uninformed viewer might derive from a peace treaty that has yet to be honored 18 years later.

Despite the odd decision to retain an early Christmas party sequence with Vanessa Redgrave sporting a bizarre yuletide headdress, the film plays out in a marginally more focused, present-tense register, and a second viewing only adds to one’s appreciation for the stirring performances of Hiam Abbass and Alexander Siddig as the chief guardians of Freida Pinto’s beautiful but inexpressive Miral.

Clearly aware of the difficulties of selling weighty topical fare to a U.S. audience, the Weinstein Co. has been diligently courting attention in the press: A lavish March 14 premiere at United Nations headquarters drew protests from various Jewish-American groups, and the distrib lobbied successfully for a PG-13 rating after the film was slapped with an R for a scene containing an unpleasant but not especially graphic sexual assault. (It’s the second such victory in months for TWC, after overturning “Blue Valentine’s” NC-17.) But even the most aggressive campaign can’t endow a movie with a sense of purpose, and in its shorn state, “Miral” remains a picture bereft of intellectual substance, psychological depth or widespread commercial interest.



Production: A Weinstein Co. (in North America) release of a Jerome Seydoux presentation, with Pathe, ER Prods., Eagle Pictures, India Take One Prods., with the participation of Canal Plus and Cinecinema, of a Jon Kilik production. Reviewed at Wilshire screening room, Beverly Hills, March 16, 2011. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 106 MIN.

With: **Originally reviewed by Variety on Sept. 2, 2010, at the Venice Film Festival.**

More Film

  • Brightburn review

    Film Review: 'Brightburn'

    “Superman” meets “The Omen” in “Brightburn,” a watchable but super-silly mix of superheroics and evil-child horror that mashes together singularly uninspired ideas from both. Offering R-rated fantasy competition to “Aladdin” this Memorial Day weekend, it should do OK with undiscriminating audiences seeking familiar, forgettable genre thrills. But the franchise prayers that an open-ended fadeout dangles [...]

  • Aladdin

    Film Review: Will Smith in 'Aladdin'

    Of all the characters in Walt Disney Studios’ canon, is there any more animated than the Genie from “Aladdin”? In 1992, old-school cartooning seemed the only way to keep up with comedian Robin Williams’ rapid-fire sense of humor and free-associative gift for improvisation. Much of the appeal of the original “Aladdin” came thanks to the [...]

  • Cannes: European Auteurs Launch Appeal to

    Cannes: European Auteurs Launch Appeal to Get E.U. Elections Vote Out

    A group of 500 prominent European auteurs – including heavyweights attending Cannes such as Céline Sciamma, Pawel Pawlikowski, and Luc and Jean-Pierre Dardenne – have launched an impassioned appeal to citizens of the 28 European Union nations to get out the vote at the upcoming May 23-26 E.U. parliamentary elections. “It is true, Europe is hardly [...]

  • Photograph by Svetlana Cvetko

    Blitz Films' Eryl Cochran Talks About Indie Film in Challenging Market

    Eryl Cochran heads production & development at production and financing shingle Blitz Films, where she works alongside company founders, filmmakers Nikolay and Sergey Sarkisov. Blitz, launched in 2018, is carving out a niche in the indie world with an eye for emerging talent. Blitz’s slate includes “Show Me What You Got,” directed by cinematographer Svetlana [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content