×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Battle for Brooklyn

A chronicle of the years-long grassroots resistance to the design-, delay- and deception-plagued Atlantic Yards project in New York, "Battle for Brooklyn" might have been better titled "Boondoggle in Brooklyn."

With:
With: Daniel Goldstein, Shabnam Merchant, Patti Hagan, Letitia James, Marty Markowitz, Michael Bloomberg, Bruce Ratner.

A chronicle of the years-long grassroots resistance to the design-, delay- and deception-plagued Atlantic Yards project in New York, “Battle for Brooklyn” might have been better titled “Boondoggle in Brooklyn.” A battle ordinarily requires two sides, yet this earnest, ungracefully reconstructed saga posits that opposition to the building of the New Jersey Nets’ future home took place in a virtual vacuum, and that the fix was in from the start. Failed crusades don’t make for very inspiring cinema, and pic seems unlikely to galvanize followers in limited release, kicking off June 17 in Gotham.

It’s not that helmers Suki Hawley and Michael Galinsky don’t have a decent story to tell: Billionaire developer Bruce Ratner had a plan and, abetted by the leading lights of New York politics, including the near-comedic Brooklyn borough president Marty Markowitz, believed nothing could stop him: He would use abandoned Long Island Railroad Yards to build a Frank Gehry-designed arena for his NBA team, with adjacent residential housing, in the middle of a flourishing neighborhood called Prospect Heights. If any inconvenient buildings on the periphery of his project stood in the way, he would simply get the appropriate agencies of New York State to condemn them under the rule of eminent domain.

But Daniel Goldstein, who had recently bought his first apartment, and whose living room was to be Ratner’s center court, had a problem with the plan. Rather than sell out like his neighbors, Goldstein resisted, on the principal that eminent domain — the intent of which is the greater public good — shouldn’t be exploited for the benefit of billionaire campaign contributors.

“Battle for Brooklyn” punches plenty of holes in the arguments of Ratner and his accomplices, including their phony claims about local jobs and low-cost housing, and the idea that there was local support for the project; one pugnacious pro-Ratner group, called Build, turns out to be on the developer’s payroll.

At the same time, however, Galinsky and Hawley never really make Goldstein’s argument: They never cite the well-reported history of publicly financed sports stadiums — a deal in which the public generally loses — or investigate whether Ratner has financial connections to influencers like Markowitz and New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

Moreover, they provide no penetrating interviews with supporters of the project, or discuss the fact that firing Gehry after the plans were approved — a move that New York Times architecture critic Nicolai Ouroussoff referred to as a “cynical double-cross” — should have forced Ratner to regroup. (The Times, castigated in the film for supporting the Atlantic Yards, isn’t cited for its later criticism.) Worse, they don’t extend their story beyond a few blocks of Brooklyn, which seems like a missed opportunity. “It’s un-American,” Goldstein says about the abuses of power at the heart of the film, before correcting himself: “No — you know what? It is American.” That’s precisely the message that “Battle for Brooklyn” doesn’t sufficiently explore.

Tech credits are adequate.

Popular on Variety

Battle for Brooklyn

Documentary

Production: A Rumur presentation. Produced by Suki Hawley, Michael Galinsky, David Bielinson. Directed by Suki Hawley, Michael Galinsky.

Crew: Camera (color), Galinsky; editor, Hawley; music, David Reid, Derek Bermel; sound, Alex Noyes; associate producers, Adam Galinsky, Susan Littenberg. Reviewed on DVD, New York, June 10, 2011. (In Hot Docs Film Festival.) Running time: 93 MIN.

With: With: Daniel Goldstein, Shabnam Merchant, Patti Hagan, Letitia James, Marty Markowitz, Michael Bloomberg, Bruce Ratner.

More Film

  • The Irishman

    Martin Scorsese's 'The Irishman' Set for Centerpiece Screening at Rome Festival

    Martin Scorsese’s “The Irishman” will be among highlights of the upcoming Rome Film Festival, following its European launch as the closing film at the BFI London Film Festival. As with the Oct. 13 London premiere, key cast members of the hotly anticipated Netflix film are expected to attend the screening in Rome, as is Scorsese. [...]

  • 'Cheer Up, Mr. Lee' to be

    Korean Comedy 'Cheer Up, Mr. Lee' to be Remade in French

    Currently on-release South Korean comedy drama, “Cheer Up, Mr. Lee” is to be remade in French. “Mr. Lee” is the story of a mentally-challenged man who learns that he has a sick daughter, and embarks on a voyage of discovery with his new family member. A remake deal was struck between Yong Film, part of [...]

  • The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos

    Korea: 'The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos’ Rules Chuseok Holiday Box Office

    Local films dominated cinemagoing in South Korea over the 4-day Chuseok holiday weekend, traditionally one of the year’s busiest periods. The winner was “The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos.” Opening on Wednesday, the CJ Entertainment release earned $20.2 million from 1.97 million admissions over five days. A film adaptation of CJ E&M’s 2014 hit TV [...]

  • Disco

    New Europe Sells Toronto and San Sebastian Film 'Disco' to Several Territories (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jan Naszewski’s New Europe Film Sales has signed several distribution deals on “Disco,” which had its world premiere in Toronto Film Festival’s Discovery section and makes its European premiere in San Sebastian’s New Directors competition. The film has been picked up by Palace for Australia and New Zealand, Artcam for Czech Republic and Slovakia, Kino [...]

  • "Jade Dynasty" in front at the

    China Box Office: 'Jade Dynasty' in Front Ahead of Mixed Competition

    With “Jade Dynasty” out front, Chinese action and Asian animation films led the way at the China box office over the past weekend, while the few American titles in play have failed to attract many moviegoers. Chinese action fantasy “Jade Dynasty” led the weekend box office in its debut with $38.1 million, figures from consultancy [...]

  • The Painted Bird

    Venice Competition Film 'The Painted Bird' Is Czech Entry in Oscar Race

    Václav Marhoul’s “The Painted Bird,” which world premiered at the Venice Film Festival in the main competition and also played at the Toronto Film Festival in Special Presentations, has been selected as the Czech Republic’s entry for the 92nd Academy Awards in the international feature film category. The pic follows the journey of an unnamed [...]

  • Pakistan Picks Freshman Effort 'Laal Kabootar'

    Pakistan Picks Freshman Effort 'Laal Kabootar' as Its Oscar Entry

    Pakistan’s Academy Selection Committee has chosen “Laal Kabootar” as its candidate for the Oscars’ international feature film category. Directed by first-time helmer Kamal Khan, the gangland thriller set in Karachi’s underbelly follows the events that transpire when a woman in search of her husband’s killer is thrown together with a cab driver and petty criminal [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content