You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV tome: Left has heft

Shapiro's 'Propaganda' creating a stir

Hollywood conservatives have long lamented being shut out of an industry with a leftward tilt. They see a new book as offering proof.

Ben Shapiro’s “Primetime Propaganda: The True Hollywood Story of How the Left Took Over Your TV,” published last week, is creating a stir not just for its claims, but for a series of interview excepts Shapiro posted to the Web in which some series creators acknowledge and even appear to celebrate liberal staffs and content.

The interviews were enough to trigger the resignation of writer-director Lionel Chetwynd, who has been the dean of Hollywood conservatives, from the Caucus for Producers, Writers & Directors.

In an open letter he sent on Thursday, Chetwynd wrote, “In preparing his book, Mr. Shapiro interviewed a large number of our Hollywood notables on the subject of diversity — not the sacrosanct melange of race, religion, gender orientation and the like, but a more challenging diversity: that of opinion and policy. The vast majority felt quite comfortable endorsing discrimination against those whose political philosophy was not rooted in the reflexive Leftism of Hollywood.”

Chetwynd was has been instrumental in bringing such GOP figures and Rep. Eric Cantor (R-Va.) and Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) to caucus events, balancing them with politicos from the other side of the aisle.

“I knew most of my fellow members looked upon the political positions of these people as distasteful; what I now understand is the disgust was not for their views, but for their very person,” Chetwynd wrote.

Chetwynd was particularly up- set with the remarks of fellow caucus member Vin Di Bona, creator of “MacGyver” and “America’s Funniest Home Videos.” According to the audio portion of the interview posted to YouTube, when Shapiro asks Di Bona about the critique that Hollywood is a “one-sided town” and “that only one perspective tends to get told in scripted shows,” Di Bona responds, “Well, I think it’s probably accurate and I’m happy about it. If the accusation is there, I’m OK with it.”

In a statement last week, Di Bona said that “while the quote is correct and I stand by it, it was obtained in a duplicitous manner.”

“Mr. Shapiro in his interview with me misrepresented the nature of that interview and subject matter of his book, which he originally described as a yet untitled book, chronicling the history of the television industry from the 1950s to current, particularly profiling the most important figures in TV. He asked for an interview that would discuss my rise to the top of the TV world and thoughts on where the TV industry will go — and where it ought to go — from here.”

Shapiro said that the way the book was pitched “is precisely what the book is about.” He said it was untitled until a few weeks before publication.

There’s little doubt of the book’s point of view — and that its provocative premise has helped Shapiro promote it, particularly in conservative media. It comes from HarperCollins’ conservative imprint Broadside Books.

But some TV creators in the book reject the premise of an “institutional bias against right-wingers in Tinseltown” as just not true, particularly in a business dictated by ratings and advertisers.

Marta Kauffman, the co-creator of “Friends,” said it was all “much ado about nothing.”

“I don’t think there is any collaboration among liberals to keep conservatives out of Hollywood,” she said in an interview with Variety. “I think that’s silly.”

She said that storylines for “Friends” were rooted in writers’ experiences and stories that they wanted to tell. “The idea that we are pushing an agenda is nonsense,” she said. As for whether writers were selected based on their politics, she said, “I have never asked someone that question during an interview any time in my life.” Often the big concern was whether a writer could endure marathon hours, or “whether we could spend 18 hours in a room with someone.”

“The truth is I can’t think of a conservative who would want to do ‘Friends,'” she said. “It was a show that was highly sexual.” Some conservatives were critical of the fact that it came on at the start of primetime viewing hours, she said.

“The dangerous thing about the book is it implies we don’t want a dialogue. We want a dialogue because it’s the only way liberals and conservatives will be able to meet somewhere.”

George Schlatter, the creator of “Laugh-In,” is quoted making barbs at conservative figures like Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh and Ann Coulter.

But speaking to Variety, he said that Shapiro mistakes Hollywood for a cabal that is somehow conspiring to shut out the conservative point of view.

“Who is ‘Hollywood’? That is what I want to know,” Schlatter said. “Hollywood is the name of an industry. Hollywood makes a lot of mistakes, but it’s not a philosophy; it’s a business.”

Schlatter noted that during the days of “Laugh-In,” they strove to maintain a balance, not only by hiring Paul Keyes, Richard Nixon’s joke writer, but by featuring quips on such volatile issues as abortion that took a conservative bent. Nixon had his famous pre-election appearance on the show, along with William F. Buckley and even the Rev. Billy Graham.

“We got a 50-share. You can’t maintain that if you are one-sided,” Schlatter said.

He challenged the subtitle of the book — how the left “took over your TV” — given the proliferation of Fox News and a bevy of other conservative commentators.

“They are guilty of everything they accuse the left wing of,” Schlatter said.

Like Di Bona, Schlatter said that Shapiro presented the book as a history of TV, but did not tell him the title.

Had he known, Schlatter said, “I might have said the same thing, just a little stronger and funnier.”

More Film

  • Swiss Film Award Winners Led By

    ‘Those Who Work,’ ‘Chris the Swiss’ Top 2019 Swiss Film Awards

    Two debut features in writer-director Antoine Russbach’s “Those Who Work” and Anja Kofmel’s animated documentary “Chris the Swiss,” were the big winners at Friday night’s Swiss Film Awards, notching three plaudits each. Sold by Be For Films, “Those Who Work,” stars Belgian actor Olivier Gourmet, who has appeared in every single film by Jean-Pierre and [...]

  • Lupita Nyong'o as Adelaide Wilson doppelgänger

    Box Office: Jordan Peele's 'Us' to Easily Surpass 'Get Out' in Killer Opening Weekend

    Jordan Peele’s horror-thriller “Us” will likely slay the box office competition this weekend. It’s projected to generate an impressive $64 million through the weekend at 3,741 sites in North America, early estimates showed Friday. It’s over-performing recent forecasts, which had ranged from $38 million to $50 million. It should wind up with about $27 million [...]

  • France's Investment in Movies Plummeted in

    France's Film Production Levels Remained High in 2018, But Local Investment Plummeted

    While the volume of production in France remained high with 300 films made in 2018, investment in local films dropped by 15.2% to €1.12 billion ($1.26 billion), hit by the sharp decline in financing from traditional distribution deals and TV channels. Among the 300 films produced last year, 237 were French-majority films and 63 French-minority [...]

  • Unicorn Store Trailer

    Watch the First Trailer for Brie Larson's Directorial Debut, 'Unicorn Store'

    Brie Larson is seeking salvation from Samuel L. Jackson in Neflix’s first trailer for her directorial debut, the offbeat comedy-drama “Unicorn Store.” Larson is portraying a lonely 20-something dreamer who’s been kicked out of art school. She’s forced to move back home with her parents and take a temp job at a PR agency. But [...]

  • Patti Rockenwagner

    Chief Brand Officer Patti Röckenwagner Leaves STX Entertainment (EXCLUSIVE)

    Patti Röckenwagner is leaving STX Entertainment where she has served as the company’s chief brand officer. She announced her departure in a memo to staff, in which she said she was departing for “another opportunity.” The exit is an amicable one. Röckenwagner joined STX in 2016 as its chief communications officer before being promoted to [...]

  • Gabrielle Union

    10 Things We Learned at Variety’s 2019 Entertainment Marketing Summit

    Variety’s 2019 Entertainment Marketing Summit, which brought top execs to Hollywood’s NeueHouse on Thursday, covered considerable ground. From cutting through the noise in an oversaturated media landscape to welcoming exciting technology like virtual reality, industry veterans offered insight into what to expect from the marketing world in coming years. Here are 10 things we learned [...]

  • Orange Studio, OCS Join Forces On

    Orange Studio, OCS Join Forces on Flurry of High-Profile Series

    Following “The Name of the Rose”(pictured) and “Devils,” France’s Orange has unveiled four internationally-driven series projects as part of its commitment to step into premium original shows with its film/TV division Orange Studio and pay TV group OCS both of board. Currently in development, the social western “Cheyenne & Lola,” the dance-filled workplace drama “The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content