Trial set as O’Donnell deal collapses

Prosecutor refuses plea deal as judge balks on jail time

A trial has been scheduled for Pierce O’Donnell after a federal judge refused Monday to sentence him to jail time and prosecutors declined to budge from a plea agreement that would have seen the famed litigator serve six months in prison on charges of making illegal campaign contributions.

U.S. District Judge James Otero said Monday that O’Donnell, perhaps most famous for representing Art Buchwald in the suit that exposed studio accounting practices, showed an exceptional record of contributions to the community that made jail time unwarranted. He also cited health concerns, including input from experts who said that O’Donnell suffers from bipolar disorder.

But federal prosecutor Dennis Mitchell refused to agree to a sentence without the jail time, arguing that it was sending “a message to the community” about the gravity of O’Donnell’s offense.

O’Donnell pled guilty last summer to two misdemeanor counts of illegal contributions to John Edwards’ 2004 presidential campaign, in which he got 10 employees of his law firm and others to each contribute $2,000 to the campaign, for which he would then reimburse them. The plea agreement called for six months in prison, one year of supervised release and a $20,000 fine.

Popular on Variety

Otero instead wanted to sentence O’Donnell to three years’ probation, including six months detention with an electronic monitoring device. Mitchell refused, leading to a contentious hearing in the Los Angeles courtroom in which Otero said that the government was “interfering with the sentencing power of the court.”

“What you are causing taxpayers here is a significant amount of money,” Otero told Mitchell, going so far as to predict that the “outcome will be the same” during a trial.

“This is a person who has impeccable character who has made a mistake in his life caused by a psychiatric condition,” Otero said. Nevertheless, he scheduled a trial to begin on Jan. 31.

Exacerbating O’Donnell’s case was that he already pled guilty in 2006 to misdemeanor state charges of making “conduit” contributions to the 2001 mayoral campaign of James Hahn.

O’Donnell was clearly pleased with Monday’s outcome, even if it extends even further a case that has cost him huge sums. His attorney, Brian 0’Neill, called the developments “unprecedented” and said of prosecutors’ refusal to agree to the judge’s proposed sentence, “I actually think it is personal at this point between the prosecutor and maybe me.”

More Film

  • Father

    'Father': Film Review

    “Father” begins with a mother. Dragging her two sullen, uncomprehending kids along with her, Biljana (Nada Šargin) strides onto the grounds of the factory from which her husband was let go more than a year before and harangues the foreman about the severance package they still have not received. The children are hungry, she wails, [...]

  • Scream, Queen! My Nightmare on Elm

    'Scream, Queen! My Nightmare on Elm Street': Film Review

    In 1985, New Line rushed out a sequel to its breakout horror hit of the prior year. But while commercially successful enough, “A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge” was initially disliked by mainstream horror fans, then later won cult status, for the same reason: It struck many as “the gayest horror film of [...]

  • Leaving Neverland HBO

    HBO Seeks Dismissal of Michael Jackson Estate's Suit Over 'Leaving Neverland'

    HBO urged an appeals court on Friday to throw out litigation brought by the Michael Jackson estate over the 2019 documentary “Leaving Neverland.” HBO and the Jackson estate have been locked in a legal war ever since the premium cable network agreed to run the documentary, which chronicles child sexual abuse allegations against Jackson. The [...]

  • Denzel Washington

    Film News Roundup: Denzel Washington-Rami Malek Thriller Set for Early 2021 Release

    In today’s film news roundup, a Denzel Washington-Rami Malek thriller gets a release date, “Escape Room 2” gets moved, Paramount sets a double feature, “So Cold the River” wraps and the Sonoma Film Festival unveils its lineup. RELEASE DATES Warner Bros. has set the Denzel Washington-Rami Malek police thriller “The Little Things” for a Jan. 29, [...]

  • WGA Agents Contract Tug of War

    Writers Guild Says It Helped Negotiate 100 Deals for Agent-Less Members

    The Writers Guild of America has asserted that it has assisted in negotiating more than 100 deals in recent months for members without agents. The missive from the WGA West board of directors comes nearly a year after the guild leaders ordered their 15,000 members to fire their agents if the agents had not agreed [...]

  • the jesus rolls

    Émilie Simon Contributes Flamenco/Gypsy Vibe to John Turturro's ‘The Jesus Rolls’

    For French musician Émilie Simon, the flamenco-meets-gypsy vibe writer-director John Turturro was seeking for the soundtrack to his movie “The Jesus Rolls” turned out to be in her musical and genetical DNA. “This music originally comes from where I grew up in the south of France,” says the 41-year-old electronic musician, who has released five [...]

  • My Hero Academia Heroes Rising

    'My Hero Academia: Heroes Rising' ADR Director on Adapting the Anime for a U.S. Audience

    “My Hero Academia” has officially Detroit Smashed into North American theaters. Sony Pictures Television’s Funimation released “Heroes Rising” in the U.S. on Wednesday, grossing $2.5 million on its opening day. Theaters are showing the film, a standalone entry in the popular superhero anime based on the manga, with options for either subtitles or with an [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content