You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Thesps urge probe into SAG foreign tax revs

Letter asks Labor Secretary Solis to intervene

More than 100 Screen Actors Guild members have asked U.S. Secretary of Labor Hilda Solis to investigate how SAG disburses money collected from foreign tax revenues.

Signers of the Aug. 17 missive include SAG national board member Clancy Brown, former SAG president Ed Asner, veteran thesps Michael Bell and Peggy McCay, guild activist Michelle Santopietro and screenwriter William Richert (“Winter Kills”).

“What it alleges is startling, disturbing, and extremely serious,” Brown told Variety. “To continue the current investigations seems like an appropriate and reasonable request.”

Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, SAG’s general counsel, said in response, “These complaints are unfounded as the foreign royalties issue has been addressed in litigation against Screen Actors Guild (and also

the DGA and WGA). Not only were all parties satisfied with the outcome of that action, but the presiding judge approved a settlement covering a class of more than 70,000 people — all of whom were notified before the final settlement and none objected. Only one objection was ultimately noted and that single objector was found by the presiding judge to lack standing in this matter and is also one of the authors of these communications.”

A spokesman for the Dept. of Labor confirmed to Daily Variety that the department has received the letter, which was attached to another letter from SAG and WGA member Eric Hughes. Both documents include allegations of embezzlement, tax fraud and money laundering by SAG. “We are reviewing the letters,” the Dept. of Labor spokesman said.

Guild officials have insisted repeatedly that SAG has done nothing wrong in how it handles foreign levies.

McCay said that she’d distributed the letter among her “Days of Our Lives” castmates. Thesp said she’s received only miniscule foreign levies payments over the course of her lengthy career.

“If the allegations are true, it’s really shocking,” McCay said. “I think it definitely should be investigated.”

The letters stem from issues raised in Ken Osmond’s 2007 class-action lawsuit against SAG, which was settled in February. Osmond had asserted when he filed the suit that SAG had over-stepped its authority in collecting the funds for the past two decades and had never disclosed the collection agreements until he and Jack Klugman threatened to file suit.

SAG has asserted that it settled the Osmond suit to avoid prolonged litigation. It declared in its current issue of SAG Actor magazine that it had distributed over $11 million of the foreign funds to members as of July.

The foreign levies are collected from countries through mechanisms such as taxes on video sales and rentals to compensate copyright holders for reuse. The monies began to flow in 1989 after the U.S. agreed to the terms of the Berne Convention, which established the right of authorship for individuals who create works of art. SAG, the WGA and the DGA began collecting the foreign funds in the early 1990s on behalf of members and nonmembers who had a stake in films and TV programs.

Attorneys for the guilds have asserted that previously copyright holders — studios and producers represented through the Alliance of Motion Picture & Television Producers — received all the funds before the guilds negotiated agreements with foreign collection societies for portions of it.

A similar foreign levies suit was filed in 2005 against the WGA West by Richert and was settled last year; another was filed in 2006 against the DGA by William Webb, who settled in 2008.

The letter said that the signers had written to “express serious concerns” regarding the allegations of unlawfully accessing the funds. And it accused SAG of mis-representing that its members have given it the right to collect the funds.

“SAG represents to foreign rights societies that its members have agreed to remit, to designated AMPTP companies, from 50% to 100% of the royalties collected in foreign countries for our performances in U.S. audiovisual works,” the letter said. “Only a society of performers can access these monies.”

The letter also asserted that an investigation by the Dept. of Labor into the handling of the funds had been stalled by the three class-action suits filed against the guilds.

“Nonetheless, the issue of whether the unions have a right to be collecting these monies and allegations of fraud and conversion were not litigated and are outside the scope of the settlements,” the letter said. “There was no discovery, not a single deposition taken, in the SAG case. And there are false and misleading statements in the filings by the union, including the submission of an agreement that SAG claims is a collective bargaining agreement in which the members of SAG assign our right to claim these monies to the companies.”

Attorneys for SAG asserted earlier this year that questions about the legality of the foreign levies agreement were outside the scope of the suit. Only 31 SAG members opted out of the settlement and only a single objection was filed by Hughes on grounds that the foreign levies agreement is illegal. Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Carl West West denied Hughes’ objection, asserting that the settlement contains safeguards against improprieties and pledging that he’ll monitor its execution.

The letter also noted the July 1 raid in Madrid of Spain’s copyright management organization, the Sociedad General de Autores y Editores, in which the chairman and eight people were arrested on suspicion of involvement in a scheme to divert tens of thousands of euros through companies that provided non-existent services.

“It was only weeks ago, when the Spanish national police raided a rights society in Madrid, that we even knew the name of any foreign entity representing our performers rights,” the missive noted.

More Film

  • Abigail Disney on Bob Iger

    Abigail Disney Calls Robert Iger's Pay 'Naked Indecency' in Op-Ed

    After stirring a flurry of reactions over her Tweets calling out wage inequality at the Walt Disney Co. on Sunday, Abigail Disney, a filmmaker and philanthropist who is the grand niece of Walt Disney, penned an opinion column outlining her arguments against Disney’s pay practices. In her op-ed, which was published in the Washington Post [...]

  • Avengers: Endgame

    'Avengers: Endgame' Reaps $90 Million in China by Late Afternoon of Opening Day

    “Avengers: Endgame” is already breaking records in China, raking in $89.6 million (RMB602 million) as of 5 p.m. on opening day Wednesday – two days ahead of the U.S. – and putting itself firmly on track to become the biggest Hollywood title ever in the Middle Kingdom. The Marvel finale has already set a new [...]

  • ‘The Gift: The Journey of Johnny

    Film Review: ‘The Gift: The Journey of Johnny Cash’

    Very much in the manner of an “unplugged” acoustic album that showcases the musicianship of a major artist without distracting flash and filigree, “The Gift: The Journey of Johnny Cash” is a tightly focused yet impressively multifaceted documentary that attempts nothing less than to delve past familiar myths and illuminate the soul of its fabled [...]

  • Emily Morgan Cormac Fox Gregoire Debailly

    European Film Promotion Reveals 2019's Producers on the Move

    Twenty of Europe’s up-and-coming producers are going to Cannes with European Film Promotion. The organization unveiled its latest roster of Producers on the Move on Wednesday, a lineup that features France’s Gregoire Debailly, who produced Jean-Bernard Marlin’s “Sheherazade,” which premiered in Critics’ Week in Cannes last year, and Ireland’s Cormac Fox, who produced Sophie Hyde’s [...]

  • Avengers EndGame Trailer

    ‘Avengers: Endgame’ Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Marvel claims the top spot in spending with “Avengers: Endgame.” Ads placed for the superhero film had an estimated media value of $6.28 million through Sunday for 927 national ad airings on 39 networks. (Spend figures [...]

  • Oscar OScars Placeholder

    Netflix Can Chill: Academy Rules No Change in Streaming Oscar Eligibility

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences will not change eligibility rules for the Oscars, despite speculation that streaming companies might see a crackdown on their release practices when pursuing golden trophies. A board of governors meeting on Tuesday voted to maintain the status quo, that any feature-length film can be considered for the [...]

  • Aniara review

    Film Review: 'Aniara'

    Each year brings an example or three of purported “thinking person’s science-fiction” films, a category that pretty much embraces anything not centered on monsters or lightsaber battles. These efforts are often more admirable in theory than result, but “Aniara” — the first film drawn from Nobel Prize-winning Swedish poet Harry Martinson’s 1956 cycle of 103 [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content